Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
TR-6325
James F.King,President ..So Town Hall Annex Jill M..Doherty,Vice-'President �� O`er 54375 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Peggy A.Dickerson Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen.. ' ► • Q Telephone(631) 765-1892 Bob Ghosio,Jr. Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE #0419C Date: April 24, 2009 , THIS CERTIFIES that the 4'x40' open-grate catwalk with ladder down to a 6'x20' floating dock held in place at the seaward end with two 2"metal pipes a 3 '/2' x 27' long launching rail on east side of dock with 4 cross-members holding it gazebo or storage shed less than 100 soft in size; 20'x20 parking area; restore the marsh area at landward end of launching ramP At.1275 West Cedar Point Drive Southold,New York Suffolk County Tax Map#.90-1-2 .Conforms to the applications for a Trustees Permit heretofore filed in this office Dated 2/28/06 & 11/7/07 pursuant to which Trustees Permit# 6325 Dated 12/12/07 was issued,conforms to all of the requirements and conditions of the applicable provisions of law.The project for which this.certificate is being issued is for the 4'x40' open-grate catwalk with ladder down to a 6'x20' floating dock held in place at the seaward end with two 2"metal pipes a 3 '/2' x 27' long launching rail on east side of dock with 4`cross-members holding it• gazebo or storage shed less than 100 saft in size, 20'x20' parking area; restore the marsh area at landward end of launching ramp The certificate is issued to Benah,LLC owner of the. aforesaid property.. Authorized Signature ��OgpFF04�-c0 �� GS James F. King,President N Town Hall,53095.Main Rd. Jill M.Doherty,Vice-President ,�. P.O. Box 1179 Peggy A.Dickerson Southold,NY 11971 Dave Bergen '�� ,b0 -Telephone(631)765-1892 Bob Ghosio,Jr. �' Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD DATE OF INSPECTION: . b2z-) Ch. 275 Ch. 111 INSPECTION SCHEDULE Pre-construction, hay bale.line/silt boom/silt curtain 1st day of construction % constructed Project complete, compliance inspection. INSPECTED BY: COMMENTS: e- ' MSS► Sk Do ,,, i CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE: J q •t �; P Id r '� 1 i; �r� f Y F I , �� E.., � r 11r 1� t t� \i �� �! ,�1��•I' � � yr r;� ,� >�� i�� Pb�ii /�� �.Jf,jrµ �, iYt , � 1 y r P' f: 1 �Qfr••� JV s 101 r . 1' i t pit MY NN i - \ lk 23120,09 14 : 01 n ` icy. �• 6 asi �P u:a t, Key� _ � > x IT MON16M, -A J_ r M - rA `�J! x �'T ^:, s .�. *fir, ,X�µ..yiiOrN�ir' ,�r � r. � �•. a c .. 'i Ile • } W y ;<EWAji t,��.. ✓ I ,, /, � it + � ,� , � ,r '1 �?f ,_• } .� ,.+ ,� r. �� ,.• y ,' �a iy � elf � .; . s',�4 !;' � f•• ;+ Ir �, ,� rid i . **FAR, •I � � �� - - ,.. �. T,J, .A ` ! ' w `/J �a/ ` `�jam- • �'' � \ a '•a�. :. -.i.' ifs. ,�r - i�— -r 'tw�� e _fir. ' i`a � �� ,� �.+'` ht.�� �:+�. ��' '� �-.` ,�� �►. \�,/���i�'; `� ai •r `�+ � ��! �. 1 .i s, •tv.a. + !7,jn'f�f` r _,\ilk � - l�i4. '�"�-•.� •/.J ,'f wr �• -c-. � {�,.... �/ -rl.��� ��-�.k '�. �; .� I �taf i t•: ~��'i..�Vr ,I''�ta'l��t,,�` •. Pq 9 All � Ic ♦ e 34 X _mc 411- fiiA"�`� � • f•� `D. � r• - -- rn .... ,jam_ �, ��` N 'a"F �, ';' '_..,� � ��'�'" = � ' '4+• _ ,� ._ ,•� � � ! .� 1�. „ .;,ram f e�j �. � r�.0 3 ;�i t t E � 'Y�tR � y,•Y f lei �� i �� ( X,'MR •1 ,4r SA' r ` Y,F 9 If, y } f dot! v[ 74,7 Y a7►,� _ PROPOSED PARKING AREA 20'X 20'; REMOVE EXISTING BCA AND REPLACE WITH DEC-APPROVED, PERVIOUS SURFACING MATERIAL 1 120.. _V LIMIT OF CLEF RING I � 1000-90-1-2 PROPOSED GAZEBO �` 1 C F1�� OR STORAGE SHE'D VAA 1 IO GLVECl119 49� 7'X 14' OR OTHER SIZE �. uU LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. w� Fes- _ I MAR 14 2008 D F i- -� WLUZ ; � O \ w y 1 Southhold Tawn M p w o O u..' Board of Trustees g Q p • Q d�- i'" ! PROPOSED-LAUNCHING L--S rn(5 � o o �.� _L_ \ SPACED 3.5'±X 27' OVERALL; 0 0 0 0 �- Q p p, ,O _ - 'CROSS-MEMBER"LOCATIONS p Q LL, N Z ,� TYPICAL r du a ob��b ° SHW ^ ��'� C ) ��-WETLAND BOUNDARY i W p1- �' _, ,-C31-.._- _,_ BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 -t�.W 1 bu/khegd _ Z �1 _I.0 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED �'�1 R I - Z , 11 " •-� DOCK 4'X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE 1. ��oQ �0 1 DECKING AND 6"d. PILES. 00 1 1 ..�,rJ 24 �1 SOIL DISTURBED NEAR LANDWARD "PIQ 't, C .2 .,� END OF LAUNCHING RAILS TO BE \O f 1 REPLANTED WITH NATIVE VEGETA- ` FLOAT U X 20' SECURED AT END -3.0. 2.4 I TION, APPROX. 36 SQ. FT. OF DOCK BY TWO 6"d. PILES OR 2" METAL PIPES.ACCESS TO FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER AT- r. , 2.5 1 SCALE: T'=20' . TACHED TO DOCK. --~ • �.—a 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN Application regarding the property of ' PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Benali,LLC; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE; floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching Represented by . 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES SOUTHOLD• NY 11971 DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised March 3,2008 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED DOCK 4'X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE DECKING AND 6" d. PILES. LADDER 2'-2.5'WIDE ATTACHED ----- TO DOCK FOR ACCESS TO FLOAT SEAWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; LANDWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; 27' LONG OVERALL RAILS 4X LUMBER ON EDGE, SPACED 3.5'± APART, OR FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENT - FLOAT 6' X 20' SECURED AT END OF DOCK BY TWO 6" d. PILES OR 2" METAL PIPES. HIGH WATER EDGE OF WETLANDS, BY ' ° � LOW WATER R. FOX, 1/19/06 SPRING �, � to �v- HIGH WATER . EDGE OF BANK `r�j�1/�i' /�l�4j,+��/i'��.`�''�'��:g►'+'�`� ALL DIMENSIONAL LUMBER, TIMBER AND PILING ARE OF 6" DIAMETER PILES 11'± ON CENTER, CCA—TREATED WOOD.ALL EXCEPT LESS IN SEAWARD BAY ' HARDWARE IS GALVANIZED STEEL. SCALE: 1/8"= 1' ® C E .I111 2 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA SECTION VIEW V L� Application regarding the property of on PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching . Represented by MAR 1.4 2008 ramp for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN:West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 Trustees Southhold Tovr° COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised February 29,2008 Board of Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (631) 734-5800 March 14, 2006 President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road MAR 1 4 2006 Southold,New York 11971 Re: Shirley Kram; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Dear Sir: Judge Kram has requested that certain changes be made in the plan which was recently submitted: the fixed open walkway is twenty feet longer,the fourteen-foot hinged ramp is eliminated,the float is reduced in length by five feet and relocated to the side of, and parallel to,the fixed open walkway, and the launching ramp is increased in length by nine feet to reach the low water line. A possible alternative to the gazebo, a storage shed of the same size, is proposed. Three copies of the revised plan are enclosed. The new project description is as follows: PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Construct fixed open walkway 4' x 50', and float 6' x 15' parallel to the fixed dock; install two piles or metal pipes to Secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6' x 23' with 6' x 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' x 12' gazebo or storage shed. Clear upland phagmites as necessary for access to structures and for off- street parking. vlgL)a lv y/ The project plan and the included project description mailed to adjacent property owners reflected these proposed changes. Sincerely, es E. Fitzgera r. a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION i � e 40 Alf. V� d tsl , 210' po �p o - - - - - - - � i Edcle, of q e I Hof I ands 460 `? - - - _ _ e _ a 1 delineated ,}, P - o fi 9e of b R. 1=0X t � o�-1 a-o6 Ramp -o,q� % `/o A;e 1h ` O Float I 'V6.�� 4� 11C � CV GJ.3 ,o X cy � J i e eat4 4p eke ion Site Plan Prepared for Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview CGQ w E Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY L86��o �q�r S Surveyed: 01-19-06 Q�� A Amended: 01-24-06 � 0 . o Amended:02-27-06 13 t Amended:03-11-06 c3 3°ck�°p°se Datum: Low Water T •S k o' o ate abl, So' Ar r% o '%a't°S�`o4 ro�b ssa r�0� Le • �� � k rs �x r�° �e S pr° 1` 6� po ---- a1�j23� %'ram J3� Ed e of lands delineated Ram Dock,ff -0.4 ! `. op `I � by R. FOX ? [. Float !/ '/.p �L A,.`/rye Q Ol-la-06 CJS e . . �v •o / % •o JJrj / e on 4 a k� Cross Section MAR 1 4 2006 1" =20' All hardware Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float -----'-- _ 6'x 15' Proposed ____ Hyy PREPARED BY: Gazebo J __ _ _________ LN SEA LEVEL )=dole of - - MAPPING 10'x 12' Wet ands ed e ` -- ------ PO BOX#538 delineated o� 8" dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY I q-0b Fri.WFox bank les oc 631-722-3390 5/12/2006 9.21,55AM 0:\5LM\KramWL3.pro Site Plan Prepared for Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview Ce w E Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY L863 to ��r s Surveyed:01-19-06 Amended:01-24-06 �Ot AO/ 73 Amended:02-27-06 Amended:03-11-06 3 °°k¢pOse Datum: Low Water a�o 'cote'0s o� o° atSx S11; r0�rb°ea A sk4°sea cvj Ede of V40 lands T `eQg 1 delineated �Ot Dock, r of t i by R. Fox 73 Ramp 4 b.4 �C �e OI-ICI-06 S Float / .o N./he �•6 i 3 io `Q ��`y � \ %`` 1 O o0k� b9 � he -6 / ak �.,/' e - MAR 2000 Cross Section 1 4 1" = 20' All hardware 1 Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float ---'--- _ _ 6'x 15' Proposed - - -- ____ -_-- HW PREPARED BY: J SEA LEVEL Gazebo - - --------- Lw Edge of - - ___ MAPPING 10'x 12' Wet ands ad a --- ---- - ------------------- PO BOX#538 delineated o 8 dla. exist. bttm. RNERHEAD,NY R. Fox bank piles I-19-Ob 1. oc 631-722M90 3/12/2006 9:21:55AM C ASLM\KrpmWL3.pro Site Plan Prepared for Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview C� wE Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY o s�63.t 4��I. Surveyed:01-19-06 Amended:01-24-06 �o� AO/ Amended: 02-27-06 73 Amended:03-11-06 c3 °ek Datum: Low Water o o epsb1, So�°p°s�d o- 7oat to 9r ri0°s ��• V o� Sx S� 70, e� o h r �x GQ A sag°spa to cli Ede Of 1 delineated �OLc Dock, op t i byy R. FOX 13 Ram 8 �•9 • /e OI-IQ-06 S Float /p > 1. \ �0 N.0\0. ?6 lw.e 4 c7 Cross Section 1" =20' All hardware Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float -----"- _ 6'x 15' Proposed - ____ ---- HN PREPARED BY: Gazebo l --- - --------- LW SEA LEVEL i=dge of __ MAPPING T ~- - 10'x 12' Wet ands ed a PO BOX#538 delineated o 8" dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY by R. Fox bank pilex CSI-IQ-06 ll' oc 631-722-3390 5/12/2006 11:21:55AM GA5LM\Kramwl34/ro Map of-Lot 134 .- --- 'Cedar Beach Park' ill = 30 Filed Dec 20, 1927 as Map # 90 F E B 2 8 2006 N SCT# 1000-90-1-2 Ce wE Situate: Bayview Town:Southold &863, pp� aat s Suffolk County, NY Surveyed: 01-19-06 p Amended: 01-24-06 J3 pr ��r Amended:02-27-06 3 ook4;00. ss90 Datum: Low Water ? 9 3S� x or 4 , O Ion, �a ►A_ po t �s-1'4aL 41j �' rampk r4�ok ,3� Ni Ed a of g82 Fs pq�-� ----- - --I We lands �o delineated hr pt ------e-r-o���9eof � iby R. Eox W , Ramp•& -0.9 �i � ���� �tJe4 COI Float o N Ana 4/ nQ 01%- �� > �Q 6Wit ��0 9 30 (�o 40 � 3J 36 �.g •3 yJ� .. 6G J �qq � oh f JYjAp S 2g `.2�RV E S ,� ?S J . ke Cross Section 1" = 20' Al hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 30' Al I lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.9r. approved from / roved list ramp � Ram I 3'x 14 Float Proposed -------- 6'x 20- ------ H PREPARED BY V : SEA LEVEL = Gazebo yy ------------- MAPPING 10'x 12' 112ands ed e -------------- ------ , PO BOX#538 delineated o� 8 dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY kxa R. fox bank piles iLl-Ob 10' oG 2J2,Jz636-722-3390 GA5LM\KramWL2.pro Map of.Lot 134 'Cedar Beach Park' ill = 30' Filed Dec 20, 1927 F E B 2 8 2006 as Map # 90 " SCT#1000-90-1-2 C wE Situate: Bayview s8 :d Town:Southold C&"�23, ape d r s Suffolk County, W 6Q� na Surveyed: 01-19-06 Ap - Amended: 01-24-06 J3 pr /fir Amended:02-27-06 3 ook¢poso SS90 Datum: Low Water ; ,9 3S' .y- IVY�� � St , a ab 30, p . Fo3k 9r C%pos�, 10, e a o 6101 --'Q/ a,6, rack 7a L` N Ed e of ?q ' pq. iWe lands IX C co T-o'` q9e of i buu R. FOX 3 amp$ -oe / / OI-IQ-ob R Float / o /�/ :fie Q/ n0 sOa4c�'i-9 itoy OQ , oh f�/ zs vy e., 4a k� Cross Section 1° = 20' All hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 30' All from lumber 6 wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved Ilst ramp Ramp - 3'x 14' Float e 6 x 20 PREPARED BY, Proposed J- --- ---- ----- --------_HV4 Gazebo SEA LEVEL c� MAPPING 10'x 12' WetTands ed e ` - PO BOX#38 -------------------------------- delineated O 8 Clio. exist. bttm. RNERHEAD,NY R.Fox bank piles I-IQ-06 10' or. 21211 006-722-3390 GA5LM\r-ramV4L2.pro Board of Trustees 77 March 22, 2006 example, what tools are there to go back and assure that the applicant is doing the right thing unless you have a set of. plans and specs. Like putting that pile of material they take out. Okay, it's going to be behind the 1.00 feet so it's out of your jurisdiction, but I'm very concerned, as you mentioned, with the flooding we have in New Suffolk, suppose we,have that pile there, the hay bales are between there and sea, but we get a storm and the runoff starts going the other way down to Lake New Suffolk, and then it gets pumped into the sea. These are the kind of issues we have with this proposal. I mean, granted,.[ will be as an engineer admit, these bulkheads need to be maintained and repaired, I won't argue with that. It's just a damn poor job of describing what they're going to do and don't provide the tools to follow up to make sure you're getting the kind of job you want when you're projecting the environment. Thank you. TRUSTEE BERGEN: Thank you. MR. RAYNOR: If it helps, I'll be more than happy to talk it over for any rain runoff for any soil. TRUSTEE BERGEN: If no other comments, I'll make a motion to close the public hearing. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Second. TRUSTEE BERGEN: All in favor? ALL AYES. TRUSTEE BERGEN: I make a motion to approve the application of Patricia Moore on behalf of Love Lane Acquisition as described with the conditions that a dry well is installed as we showed on the plans and you'll submit new plans, obviously, showing these, but the dry well, the new walkway is shown in the area that we specified, and that the spoil is going to be moved and stored outside of our jurisdiction no more than 100 feet away from any waterway or wetland area, and contaminated material moved offsite and also would you consider using a silt screen at the entrance of the harbor area to help prevent any debris going out into Peconic Bay in the bulkheading part of this. All subject to new plans. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Second. TRUSTEE BERGEN: All in favor? ALL AYES. ,12. Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of SHIRLEY KRAM requests a Wetland Permit to construct a fixed open walkway 4' by 50', and float 6' by 15' parallel to the fixed dock; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float, construct wood launching ramp 6' by 23' with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' by 12' gazebo or storage shed; 77 Board of Trustees 78 March 22, 2006 clear.upland vegetation as necessary for access to structures for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Drive, Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 TRUSTEE DOHERTY: The description I read is a little different than on the agenda, it's been updated. We all were at the site. The CAC did not inspect, so therefore, no comments. And LWRP found it inconsistent, which we talked about in the field and made some changes. The setbacks were one of the things. MR. FITZGERALD: The gazebo or shed 25 feet back from the end of the dock and the parking area, 20' by 20', is shown. The 25 feet is the figure you gave me. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And there's one comment here from LWRP that I don't understand, it says swimming pool and related structures. Because he has that highlighted, but -- MS. CUSACK: He took it out of the code, it says swimming pool and related structures have to be 50 feet -- TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Right, it's in bold, so I didn't know, right. We talked about the ramp next to it and how we felt we didn't need to have that size ramp there. I see that's still -- MR. FITZGERALD: The discussion was about the width as I recall, and I asked the applicant's son to measure the dolly they use for the Sunfish, and the outside dimension of the wheels is 4'4". TRUSTEE DOHERTY: So, what are you proposing that be? MR. FITZGERALD: Six feet, which seems reasonable given the width of the boat, which is somewhat more than that. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: What were you proposing material for that ramp, to build that? MR. FITZGERALD: I don't know. I would presume that marine plywood be -- TRUSTEE KING: If we allow that, it should be the new grated system, kept low and the stuff will grow up toward -- TRUSTEE BERGEN: Let me ask you this, would it work, would it suffice if instead of installing a ramp, you just clear the area like you said about 6', she said about 4'4", so next to the dock about 6' of extra clearing so they could just wheel it down there; is there any need for the ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: That would be the best way of doing it, but the bank at that point is at least 18 inches high. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Maybe we could use the new material that's out that you could put down and the growth could still grow through it. MR. FITZGERALD: That's a good idea. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: It's a hard surface, but yet you still 78 r 7 J' Board of Trustees 79 March 22, 2006 have the growth. It's not going to get out of control because you're going to be using it. I think we would rather see something like that. MR. FITZGERALD: I think I would too, it seems more practical. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Here are hand-drawn new plans in red. MR. FITZGERALD: I wasn't able to get the real map done by the map guy in time, so I did that and unless you have some changes, if you could act on it contingent upon the new map ` being that way in black instead of red? TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Sure. TRUSTEE KING: What was the proposed height of this ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: You mean height above grade? It would be at grade. The flat part up top just four feet would be at grade and it would go down, straight down from there. TRUSTEE KING: I'm just thinking DEC, I'd like to see it up off the ground a foot. MR. FITZGERALD: Okay. But there's got to be a way to get the wheels up. TRUSTEE KING: Just have a little ramp up to it out of that grated material, and that would allow some vegetation to grow under it. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And to use that material. Are there any other comments from the Board? I make a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES i TRUSTEE DOHERTY: I make a motion approve the application of Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of Shirley Kram.for a fixed open walkway 4' by 3,0'; hinged ramp 3' by 14% floating dock 6' by 20% install two piles_or_metal pipes to secure float; construct a launch ago-ar--p-a—oximate!y_ot_e_ fad pit fiig�rr ade of--a-fiberglass-or-some-other-or-alumina grating system tk�at the vegetation could grow through, and that would be approximately a 6' by 14' ramp with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end, and to construct a 10' by 12' gazebo 25 feet back from the landward edge of the dock, and a 20' by 20' area for off-street parking all subject to revised plans showing all that. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES. 15. En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of SUSAN & LOUIS VALENTE requests a Wetland Permit to remove and replace in-place approximately 114 linear feet of existing timber bulkhead with vinyl bulkhead; backfill with approximately 50 cubic yards of clean sand to be trucked in from an upland 79 Site Plan Prepared for Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applica-nt: Steven Kram N SCT# 1000-90-1-2 Situate: Bayview �� a or w E w To n: Southold $8 q� .vFprCTO �� s Suffolk County, NY C? to r Surveyed: 01-19-06 9�� A Amended:01-24-06 �0 O% 7a Amended:02-27-06 Amended:03-11-06 a Oct °�� Datum: Low Water aby. o oat O 19,60 ctear q s/ro� ab X 4��d Ed e of lands , 0 - `T-q 9e Dock, / 4 , I b P SOX 3s Ramp 8 -O.4 / � �C �:/e LO�-IC{-06 Float / Q) �/`/ .fie •gs / y ?91.9 •l1/0 ` r- .¢ / may 1 �/ 1 �g2 ?p b9 `♦� \ \ \0\Orn r! ao 41 eqq 4a Cross Section 3 22 0 6 1° = 20' AI I hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv,gr. from ramp steps to LW approved 115t Float MAR 2 2 2006 -------- _ _ - 6'x 15' Proposed - - -------- HV4 PREPARED BY: Gazebo J --- - -.---_-_-- LW' SE,A LEVEL 10'x 12' wetlands d e-==- = _ MAPPING --------^ PO BOX#536 delineated 0 W dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY R. Fox bank pp1le5 I-Iq-Ob I�' o0 631-722-3390 5/12/2006 9:21:55AM 0+\5LM\KramWL547ro Site Flan Prepared fortot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicgnt: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview �� O r w E Town: Southold Sa � --c'WrIP �� s Suffolk County, NY =�E63-to �/- Surveyed: 01-19-06 "�� A Amended:01-24-06 o 0 - Amended: 02-27-06 7 Amended:03-11-06 3 °ek °pros Datum: Low Water e Gq cF 8R 4- es etearl s'IQ P --- 6 t Q[ cn x4 �'a �„I Wtlf Op C[tVrj&iA Ed e of � Wetlands -- _o fi` age ,r i delineated 1 Ot T Dock, / 4 1 �L 1 byy R- Fox 3S Ram -O•q / ,11c t/e L 0 -11-06 Z?e 6 � q /112 � 0 10"BUJ p 8 OJQ) '2 / 36 3S ,s �Uq Y @ p h 4 c7 Cross Section 3 22 6 1" = 20' All hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber - 6'wride 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list MAR 2 2 2006 Float --'--`-- 6'x 15' Proposed ---- HW PREPARED BY: Gazebo _- -.-------- LW SEA LEVEL 10'X12' Edge of _ __ MAPPING T _ Wet ands ed a �'�--- ��---- - - -PO BOX#53B - ---- ----------------- delineated o}g 8" dia• exist, bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY b�� R. Fox bank 1 ile5 I a-O6 , or_ 631-722-3390 3/12/2006 9�21:55AM r A5LMIKramWL3.pro Site Flan Prepared for-Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview �� a or W E Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY �8a�. a�� s Surveyed: 01-19-06 bq� Amended:01-24-06 �o Ap Amended: 02-27-06 p Amended:03-11-06 _ 33 �s�k4p�se Datum: Low Water ab o Deb c'F o ' i rs �� r2° clean v�e 6,61 rope X t t _� � i Ede of de I ineated 1 Dock, � 4 'b R. Fox 3 Ramp -o.q / 1 �� ��� Float �! o ` � N6`n�q� L _ she i 3 i 1 • Z� '8/ DQ 0 10, / he c?, e orj e ci 4a / e Cross Section 3 zzlb b 1" = 20' All hardware Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6 wride 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float `--'--- 6'x 15' Proposed --- ____ Rw PREPARED BY: Gazebo cca�l __ —___-__ LIN SEA LEVEL 10'x 12' Wetlands a e - - -- - ____-- ____ MAPPING ---------- PO BOX#538 delineated o}g r dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY es b� I Fox bank ll iloc 631-722-3390 61-19-06 snz✓zoob a:zissAM C.\5LMU:romWL3.pro BENALI,LLC Southold Town Trustees Main Road, Southold Public Hearing: December 12, 2007 Dear Mr. King and Southold Town Board of Trustees We appreciate the efforts on the part of everyone to try to settle.the situation with this dock. I have the DEC approved plan dated November 3, 2006 before the Board and I would respectfully request that you consider the following as you make your decision: 1. We would never have applied for, or built, a dock with a ramp and a float. Because I live so far away it is much too difficult and costly to move the ramp and float seasonally out of the water. We purposely designed a straight dock without a ramp (only 32.5 feet is actually beyond the high water mark) so that there would be NO annual maintenance charges, and no labor charges, to put the ramp and float in and out each season. I have not installed a float and will use the dock for a season before I make a final decision whether I will ever install a float. I have offered, through my attorney,to give up the float if that will resolve this situation. 2. .We built the dock to be minimally invasive ecologically. We have light filtering decking (at least 60% of the light is transmitted through the decking) and it is built three (3') feet off the. water so that more light will be transmitted to the wetlands below. 3. A great deal of time and money has been spent already. There will be more DEC costs (and who really knows what the DEC will do when they get a permit change application on this -they have turned us down twice when we asked if it was possible to shorten the dock. Most recently to me and my attorney, in person) as well as more survey costs and more construction costs with no environmental benefit. 4. Some of the trustees have indicated that they thought that the dock was over the "stringline" between the two adjoining properties and their docks. Bob Fox's survey, photos, and the approved DEC permit ALL show that the dock as it exists is NOT over the string line, in fact it is several feet short of the string line (photos and survey attached). 5. Please note that some of the Trustee's have proposed an alternative that would reduce the length of the dock to 40' and allow a 6' x 20' float. If the dock were shortened we would then need a larger float. This alternative would create an additional environmental burden on the wetlands. This would necessitate significant disturbance in the wetlands and increase the surface coverage and shading of the wetlands . Currently the 10' ft of dock that is contemplated for removal has a surface area of 40 square ft. The decking is more than 60% light transmitting and is 3 feet off the water, which means that the effective surface area is less than 16 square feet. The proposal suggested by the Trustees is for the removal of 10 feet of dock and the addition of a 6 x 20 float (120sq feet of float). The float would be impervious to light and represent a SIX TIMES GREATER amount of surface area in the wetlands. This proposal is not the plan we ever wanted, covers much more surface area, and places a GREATER ecological burden on the wetlands. 6. The proposal to reduce the length of the dock to 40' and add a 6' x 20' float would only decrease the overall length by 4'. This proposal is not only disruptive to the wetlands, but punitive on the applicant. For the above reasons we respectfully request that the Trustees carefully consider this matter and recognize that the issues involving the permit were an innocent mistake. A reduction in the length of this dock would only be a punitive measure, costing us more time and money to have the plan reviewed and approved by DEC. Please realize that the situation as it exists today is the least harmful environmentally and meets all of the DEC requirements. Please approve the pending application without modification. Thank you, Steven Kram for Benali, LLC, Nv- 1,ym �•�'';92 � �;;��C h ReT/k` Oil r scan0002[1]jpg(JPEG Image,2338x1700 pixels) file:///C:/Documents%20and%20SettingsBob.UPSTAIRS FRONT... r�rrr� � L9 w r ��aaraac - r � 5� I of 2 12/1 1/2007 12:02 PM -PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL 20' X 20' 120 . LIMIT OF CLEARING j - HON. SHIRLEY KRAM PROPOSED GAZEBO UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT OR STORAGE SHED 500 PEARL STREET TX 14'OR OTHER SIZE I NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. ( U I. 11 SIX STAKES PLACED, Uj w W ---- --1 1 NUMBERED•AS SHOWN w U �� W � Q0 �Z — I. I \ PROPOSED LAUNCHING RAILS •0 �- a p �. 1 1�_ SPACED 3.5'±X 27' OVERALL; O O � CROSS-MEMBER LOCATIONS 0 U) TYPICAL ^ cm '\"A WETLAND BOUNDARY BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 wo -1,p -- �+ PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED 1.11 Ra oq't el 1 -37i ' DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE 1 DECKING AND 6" d. PILES -3.PJ LcL; �OV� 9ss. 1 kPPROVED AS PER TERMS tt`9�'C, -.4.0 1. -4.2 _2.�11 AND CONDITIONS OF �/pip � 00 1.. -4:1 1 PERMIT N /-V� '"0o `/I r s FLOAT 5'X 10' SECURED T .�,p 2.q. I DATE 1 OF DOCK AND d. PILES 3.6 O PIPES. ACCESS TO LOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- -2.5 2.5 I SCALE: 1"=20' ED TO DOCK. _._ _ - -- - ._- . I CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA ra PROJECT PLAN —3.0 Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram, SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE; ramp and floating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE launching ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM: MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 SOUTHOLD, NY 11971 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 -PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL J 1 20'X 20' 120 a F LIMIT OF CLEARING i HON. SHIRLEY KRAM PROPOSED GAZEBO t UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT OR STORAGE SHED t 500 PEARL STREET TX 14' OR OTHER SIZE'--, I NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. t v 14 #z #I SIX STAKES PLACED, w w v ---- -� NUMBERED AS SHOWN w t _.._. H o ¢ O PROPOSED LAUNCHING RAILS O H LO p p i Z t L \ SPACED 3.5't X 27' OVERALL; O H O a-Y � 6�. CROSS-MEMBER LOCATIONS TYPICAL CD sHw r o Nb- - CM '__'_---WETLAND BOUNDARY • �� �� __r r _Q.__ _ _ _ —� � BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 _0A 1 bt,lkhead —t,p PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED 1.11 Ramp t i �-� DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE I FJpa� 'O!A , DECKING AND 6" d. PILES - I iy Q _4:0 .1 -4.2 -3.5 2.4 I ,�- LD AS PER TERMS �00 1.. --4:1 "a'`II 4D CONDITIONS OF . FLOAT 5'X 10' SECURED TO END �.p 2.4 ERMIT N -`1-73�-vL�y,Ia�,r � OF DOCK AND BY TWO 6" d. PILES 3.ta I )ATE .;)-V0(D ,e S 4— OR 2" METAL PIPES. ACCESS TO FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- I SCALE: 1" =20' ED TO DOCK. -- -�� CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA • t PROJECT PLAN Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE: ramp and floating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE launching ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES SOL117HOLD, NY 11971 DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 ----..---.- ... -... . IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE: New York Revised November 3,2006 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE DECKING AND 6" DIAMETER PILES LADDER 2'-2.5'WIDE ATTACHED TO DOCK FOR ACCESS TO FLOAT SEAWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS,- LANDWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS, 27' LONG OVERALL RAILS 2X LUMBER ON EDGE SPACED 3.5'± APART, OR FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENT FLOAT 5'X 1 O'SECURED AT END OF DOCK BY TWO V d. PILES OR 2" METAL PIPES. HIGH WATER EDGE OF WETLANDS, BY `~% �YZ += d - ^ R. FOX, 1/19/06 LOW WATER SPRING � m � � . HIGH WATER ` l EDGE OF BANK ?ti ` ALL DIMENSIONAL LUMBER, TIMBER AND PILING ARE OF 6" DIAMETER PILES CCA-TREATED WOOD. ALL 11'±ON CENTER HARDWARE IS GALVANIZED STEEL. SCALE: 1/8"= 1' CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA SECTION VIEW Application regarding the property of •>S PER TERMS PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 �UNDITIONS OF ramp and floating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by �RMIT N //— OZIV L/i A)oo(D launching ramp for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES SATE DATUM:MLW IN:West Lake AT: Southold P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 5167-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 Proper-T Permit Services P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue NY 11935 Phone: 631-734-5800 Fax: 631-734-7463 MEMORANDUM DATE: April 4,2007 TO: Jim King IrE � p� Jill Doherty 1�J Peggy Dickerson Dave Bergen - 5 2007 Bob Ghosio FROM: Jim Fitzgerald southhold Town Board of Trustees SUBJECT: The Kram Project Please read my comments below, and the attached material, carefully. It's really important to all of us that we resolve the misunderstanding about what exactly were to Board's intentions in"approving the application of Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of Shirley Kram." When you listen to the tape of the 3/22/06 public hearing,please listen to it from the begin- ning of Jill's presentation of Item#12. You will hear her describe the project with"the 50-foot dock". The project as originally submitted had an overall length of 50 feet, consisting of a fixed walkway, a hinged ramp, and a float(Plan A, attached). The revision of the project resulted in a new plan, a,copy of which I handed to each of the Trustees present at the site for the 3/15/06 inspection. The new plan had the same overall length as the old plan,but the new configuration eliminated the hinged ramp and float(Plan B). During the open hearing,the Board's discussion had to be about the revised project, since it was the only one described in Jill's opening statement. During the discussion, Jill says, "Here are hand-drawn new plans in red."(Plan C) Nothing in the Board's discussion during the open hearing had anything to do with the overall length or configuration of the project. The only substantive discussion had to do with the size, configuration, and materials of the launching ramp. When, on 5/4/06, I submitted final drawings of the plan the Trustees approved, I was told that there existed a discrepancy between the submitted drawings (Plan D) and the description in the minutes. The Trustees -2- April 4,2007 During the period 5/12/06 to 5/26/06 I talked to Heather about the discrepancy between the minutes and the drawings submitted. On 5/26/06 Heather called me and reported that the min- utes were incorrect, as noted by the Trustees during review, and that they had been corrected. Please officially correct the minutes of the 3/22/06 public hearing to reflect the Board's inten- tions of approving a permit for the project as described by Jill at the beginning of the open hearing. Map of Lot 134 'Cedar Beach Park' 1" =30' Filed Dec 20, 1927 as Map # 90 " SCT#1000-90-1-2 C wE Situate: Bayview Town:Southold LIt ppe 41C?r s Suffolk County, NY 6q� na A Surveyed: 01-19-06 p . . Amended:01-24-06 �/j Amended: 02-27-06 c33 4°Ok4pose S'S9 o r Datum: Low Water ,� •S .r I � M Foap 3b�9r�� �����` sX4°Sea s1/ -i Ed e of----_ Ac ---- - rWe lands i-o��` 9eof ib R. FOX �V? Dock, 40, Ramp S s0°2 on IONT `i O/ CY / ,Y s 0h %q Q7 .!/. Cross Section 1° = 20' All hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 39 I lumber 6'wider.3.5'abv. from 9 approved list ramp Ramp 3'x 14' Float --- 6'x 20' n Proposed --- --- _ - __ ___ �yy ; t PREPARED BY. l ---- _ SEA LEVEL Gazebo Ed of �� - '--- ------------ _ ; MAPPING 10'x 12' q -�- ------ -------=------------ - , Wetlands ed a 8" dia. exist. bttm: � ', PO BOX#538 delineated o RIVERHEAD NY bu I;?- Fox bank piles ' I=1a-06 10' oc 631 722-3390 =7712006 0:5q.44PM G:LSLM\Kr o Site, Plan Prepared forgot# 134 1" = 30' 'Ceder Beach Park' Applicgnt:Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview C� wE Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY L863,to as f. s Surveyed:01-19-06 Amended:01-24-06 Amended: 02-27-06 73 pr �r Amended:03-11-06 c3 3°�k4'00se Datum: Low Water o a tees 6`S0 a p o to row krs 6 0.Se0' k 3� k Ede of W0�lands / - T 1 delineated ,cOt _ _o� 9e Dock, / op k 1 by — FOX 3S Ramp # 4-0. / t/e O . . /*V k ` 10 T OJ / e9q, /rje , cob a / Oak ' Cross Section 1"=20' All hardware Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 59 All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW Approved list Float -------- ---- 6x 15' Proposed -' - -- PREPARED BY: Gazebo J =_ ----- LN SEA LEVEL 1 O'X 1 Z Edge of - --------- __ MAPPING Wetlands edge --`-- --- ---- ---------------------- PO BOX#536 delineated o S° dia• exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY by R FOX bank ppiles 631-722-3390 I-1a-Ob File* 5/12/2006 9.21.55AM G.t5LM\Kro N15pro site Plan Prepared fora of#134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 N Situate: Baydew �� or w E Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY c&23,t s Surveyed:01-19-06 �� - Amended:01-24-06 �Oz- Amended: ®Amended:02-27-06 �03-11-06 ��%4��se Datum: Low Water Lail+ 6 e of 1 We lands delineated , OZ Dock, a'� o .r 1 6yy F- FOX Lj Ramp 8 fl e / / sic :/�// OI-1 a-06 a Float /U IIl/ .ne 4 . .�H eat `e` �LQ FJ" (Cross Becton 1° =20' ,411 hardware l Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float `-'-'-- _ _ _ 6'x 15' Proposed - yy PREPARED BY- Gazebo cc��Jgts---_- _ - ---------- Lh SEA LEVEL 10'x 12' WetTands ed a Of MAPPING -- - PO BOX#538 delineated o S° dia- exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY by R.Fox bank ppiles or, 631-722�39D OI-IQ-06 ll' 3/12/2006 9:21:55AM G,\5LM\rrc=KL54p o Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" =30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant:Steven Kram SCV 1000=901-2 " Town: Southold Ce 6*pkdd. w e Suffolk County, NY &I. �°?r s°4t6, !kla ?% f S Surveyed:01-19-06 �� �p ,4 eva, Amended:01-24-06 O - y77 A°feet 04-04-06,04-10-06 ,33 y °.c �h t 9�7 �nt�7te` ° �r Datum: Low Water o Q C-1 d �oopOs y N,N St x24e� � C V N� Mtn •/ ! ripen CID Dock, Ramp ff -�•9 ; a .` oghq >1 �V Float 9 ' / -gam %4p b9 `\ \ ` \O!\wO' / e a4seQ,� V Off+ F70, $kySS o st tV 4.ak L Section 1"=20' Proposed All hardware p galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv,gr. approved list ramp steps to LW --- _ Float Proposed ----- 6 x 15 Gazebo J- -- - -- --- -----HW ___ -_ _____-__I=N SEA LEVEL 10'x12' edge of MAPPING Wetlands ed a `--- ------ PO BOX#53B - ---- ----------------- delineated o 8" dia. exist. bttm, R RNERHEAD,NY Fox bank plies dI-IQ-06 p'or, 631-722-3390 4110/2006 0.45:33PM C;ASLM\*-=KL4.pro Apri14, 2007 CHRONOLOGY OF KRAM PROJECT PERMITS On 2/28/06 submitted original application to Trustees with plan dated 2/27/06. On 3/6/06 Steve Kram requested changes in the plan: dock to be 50' long,no ramp, steps to grade at end of float, float parallel to dock on west side, ladder for access to float. On 3/15/06 met Trustees at site, presented new plan dated 3/11/06 with my cover letter dated 3/14/06. This plan shows the dock at 4' x 50'. The Trustees required changes: gazebo to be 25' landward of the end of the dock, show 20' x 20' parking area, show access paths. At 3/22/06 public hearing,presented marked-up copy of 3/11/06 map,with required changes shown in red annotations with my initials and the date 3/22/06. Trustees "approved"the project as shown in the marked-up plan dated 3/22/06, and as read by Jill Doherty at the beginning of the hearing,with the condition that the launching ramp platform be one foot above grade and be made of some light-transmitting material, although the original superceded project description was read into the record as part of the motion to approve. (A revised plan dated 4/4/06 was produced but had an error and was discarded.) On 4/20/06, submitted applications to NYSDEC,NYSDOS,USACE based upon the correctly revised plan dated 4/10/06. On 5/4/06 three copies of the plan dated 4/10/06 were forwarded to the Trustees with a request to advise me of the fee for the permit. On 5/12/06 went to Trustees' office to discuss the submitted new drawings with Heather. She said the drawings didn't match the description in the minutes. I looked at the typed minutes which specified a 30-foot dock, as in the superceded plan, instead of the 50-foot dock reviewed at the 3/22/06 hearing. I got a copy of the minutes and later reviewed with my notes. The only two items discussed were the height above ground of the platform at the landward end of the launching ramp, and the need to use a light-transmitting material for the ramp's decking. On 5/15/06 I called the office to get a copy of the minutes covering the entire hearing on our project, since I was sure there was no discussion concerning reverting to the "old" design. The minutes were not done yet. On 5/18/06 I spoke to Heather reminding her that I was anxious to see the minutes. On 5/26/06 Heather called me and left a message on my answering machine saying that their previous comments about shortening the dock were"somehow incorrect" as noted by the Trustees in reviewing the minutes, and the only thing we needed to do to get the permit was to include the details of the launching ramp (see above). (There is present on the Trustees file copy of the portion of the minutes in which Jill Doherty reads the superceded project description into the motion to approve the application,the notation "50' includes stairs" in what has been described as Heather's handwriting.) On 5/30/06, in response to DEC Notice of Incomplete Application, submitted Project Plan in new format, dated 5/15/06,project same size and configuration as approved by Trustees. On 6/6/06 discussed certain minor changes in launching ramp platform that we would prefer, asked that she discuss it with Jim King. On 6/9/06 Heather called and said Jim King said our proposed change to the launching ramp was OK. I should do plans and submit to get Trustees' permit. I decided to wait since we were actively making more changes per continuing DEC requests. On 7/11/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan, Revised 7/9/06, project same size and configuration as approved by Trustees. On 10/23/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan,Revised 10/19/06, project configuration changed per DEC requirements and design of launching ramp changed. On 11/3/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan, Revised 11/3/06. On 11/25/06,received DEC permit based on Project Plan, Revised 11/3/06. I'Proper-T Permit SerVlCeS P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue NY 11935 Phone: 631-734-5800 Fax: 631-734-7463 MEMORANDUM DATE: April 4,2007 TO: Jim King Jill Doherty Peggy Dickerson Dave Bergen Bob Ghosio APR - 5 2007 FROM: Jim Fitzgerald SUBJECT: The Kram Project Please read my comments below, and the attached material, carefully. It's really important to all of us that we resolve the misunderstanding about what exactly were to Board's intentions in"approving the application of Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of Shirley Kram." When you listen to the tape of the 3/22/06 public hearing,please listen to it from the begin- ning of Jill's presentation of Item#12. You will hear her describe the project with"the 50-foot dock". The project as originally submitted had an overall length of 50 feet, consisting of a fixed walkway, a hinged ramp, and a float(Plan A, attached). The revision of the project resulted in a new plan, a copy of which I handed to each of the Trustees present at the site for the 3/15/06 inspection. The new plan had the same overall length as the old plan,but the new configuration eliminated the hinged ramp and float(Plan B). During the open hearing,the Board's discussion had to be about the revised project, since it was the only one described in Jill's opening statement. During the discussion, Jill says, "Here are hand-drawn new plans in red."(Plan C) Nothing in the Board's discussion during the open hearing had anything to do with the overall length or configuration of the project. The only substantive discussion had to do with the size, configuration, and materials of the launching ramp. When, on 5/4/06, I submitted final drawings of the plan the Trustees approved, I was told that there existed a discrepancy between the submitted drawings (Plan D) and the description in the minutes. The Trustees -2- April 4, 2007 During the period 5/12/06 to 5/26/06 I talked to Heather about the discrepancy between the minutes and the drawings submitted. On 5/26/06 Heather called me and reported that the min- utes were incorrect, as noted by the Trustees during review, and that they had been corrected. Please officially correct the minutes of the 3/22/06 public hearing to reflect the Board's inten- tions of approving a permit for the project as described by Jill at the beginning of the open hearing. Map of Lot 134 'Cedar Beach Park' 1" =30' Filed Dec 20, 1927 as Map # 90 N SCT# 1000-90-1-2 wE Situate: Bayview s Ce a Town: Southold c&8�3, ppe �r s Suffolk County, NY 6Q� �a A Surveyed:01-19-06 p Amended: 01-24-06 J3 t p10 7/)r Amended: 02-27-06 c3 % pos s no Datum:Low Water 3S� 4 °oe 4 M Fa�p 3b g o' ° o�a 0 -i Ede of ?98 eq pqe We lands to eq i delineated hhs� �pLc. b T-o � 9eof , y R. foX co , y 3 Pock, c LOl Float / o 6, 1", / eCj 0 IQ �j' k Q 10 IC? Al� J� eq .q /rje / Top on ��ry� c7 Cross Section 1" = 20' Al I hardware galvanized Proposed Proposed Dock 4'x 30' All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv. r. from 9 from list ramp Ramp 3'x 14' .Float ------- ----- 6'x 20' ! Proposed �-- y -- HW S E A ALEDV E L Gazebo Ed a of - LW I t MAPPING 10'x 12' �~ - ------------ i i PO BOX#538 Wetlands ed e, 8"dia. -----exlet. bttm. delineated o RIVERH�AD NY R. FOX bank ples 61=1a-06 1i 0 oc �?, 631-722-3390 22'72006 0.59,49PM C,06LMVtram ro Site Plan Prepared for6t# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedkr Beach Park' Applic6nt: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Situate: Bayview C wE Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY &863-� aar s Surveyed:01-19-06 Q=� Amended:01-24-06 `�� Ap Amended: 02-27-06 73 pr Amended: 03-11-06 3 °ok4pOse Datum: Low Water o a ens 6 j S0 a '° I'll-i boat 1`° 9r ' Ci r'OoS, 2Q• 7 V 0 Sx S� r0 rb°ed. . � Ar st s o � � a cn� � \ bxg;p�a 0' Ede of lk i Via lands, -- --- e, I delineated --r-o�` P Dock, / 9e t 1 byy ia. Fox c3 8 -0.4 iZamp / �c /e the �49 /110 O 4�� . % •o a' s ' 4d k� Cross Section 1 20' All hardware Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 59 All lumber 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. from , (I ramp steps to LW approved list Float -------- --- Proposed 6'x 15'___- HW PREPARED BY: Gazebo cJ Lw SEA LEVEL 10'x 12' W MAPPING ,tT na a e `- - ------- PO BOX#536 delineated o� W din. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD, 8 by R Fox bank Fpiler, 1=I�-O6 ll' or, 631-722-3390 5/12/2006 q.21:55AM G:\5LM\KramKL347ro Site Plan Prepared for Lot of•# 134 1° =30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Dram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 N Situate: Bayview �� or � w E Town: Southold Suffolk County, NY E Surveyed:01-19-06 6Q� Amended:01-24-06 o0 . Amended:02-27-06 73 ® �r Amended:03-11-06 a �oe/`4p�se a ®atom: Low Water o a dab ' r a-o boat � 0 �o oteari 3=d e of 4e�lands o eo ® 1 delineated ��DZ- Dock. / byy R SOX Ram Float n Ol-i a-06 S 0 Q ��. bg T c® a-a 107 i U / oQE R R/ eke b � Cross Section ZZ 1° = ZQ' All hardware J Proposed galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All lumber 6 wide 3.5'abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved list Float -------- ---- 6'x 15' Proposed ''- --- -- � PREPARED BY: Gazebo Edg 1� - - --------- LW SEA LEVEL MAPPING 10 x 12 YJeRc nds ed e ` -- - - PO BOX#538 --- - delineated o 8" dia. ---- -exist. bttm. -- RIVERHEAD,NY bu R Fox bank ppflex oc 631-722-3391) I-IQ-O6 ll' 3/12/2006 9,21:55AM G:LSLMV.ramWL3.pro Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot#134 1"=30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant:Steven Kram SCr#-1'000=90=1=2 ---- -- - " — Town: Southold Ce 72�Set`ao,. we Suffolk County, NY O, �c�f. s°4th aes ac ss S Surveyed:01-19-06 64� °�Amended:01-24-06 a A �r7 d1-A oils 3 / � ° l s 02-27-06,03-11-06 7 "2t4 s/te- 04-04-06,04-10-06 c3 CO °.0 ►'e Datum: Low Water Q°0 0 r i°L �PC'U�o a 0 0 a i0/ st x20 o• 2 0y pr 'bdr/vne @�, s1�c 4s.�-23aOC r OAt CPj -� -;'----G� -T Dock, : J\Q } 0& C. 0Do � � Oy O to yy / 4-ak e Section 1" =20' ' Proposed All hardware galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp steps to LW :: -� Float Proposed -----'------- _ 6 x 15 Gazebo . ---- -----IOW . J -- - - ti-- -- -- _-_--___may SEA LEVEL 10'x 12' Ed e of -- - - MAPPING Wet ands ed e ` -` -----' - ---- ---------------- - PO BOX#538 dbellineated 0 $"flea exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY dl-F- Fox ICi-06 ink 11' oc 631-722-3390 4/10/2006 0.4533PM G.\SLM\KramWL44'ro April 4,2007 CHRONOLOGY OF KRAM PROJECT PERMITS On 2/28/06 submitted original application to Trustees with plan dated 2/27/06. On 3/6/06 Steve Kram requested changes in the plan: dock to be 50' long,no ramp, steps to grade at end of float, float parallel to dock on west side, ladder for access to float. On 3/15/06 met Trustees at site, presented new plan dated 3/11/06 with my cover letter dated 3/14/06. This plan shows the dock at 4' x 50'. The Trustees required changes: gazebo to be 25' landward of the end of the dock, show 20' x 20' parking area, show access paths. At 3/22/06 public hearing,presented marked-up copy of 3/11/06 map, with required changes shown in red annotations with my initials and the date 3/22/06. Trustees "approved"the project as shown in the marked-up plan dated 3/22/06, and as read by Jill Doherty at the beginning of the hearing,with the condition that the launching ramp platform be one foot above grade and be made of some light-transmitting material, although the original superceded project description was read into the record as part of the motion to approve. (A revised plan dated 4/4/06 was produced but had an error and was discarded.) On 4/20/06, submitted applications to NYSDEC,NYSDOS, USACE based upon the correctly revised plan dated 4/10/06. On 5/4/06 three copies of the plan dated 4/10/06 were forwarded to the Trustees with a request to advise me of the fee for the permit. On 5/12/06 went to Trustees' office to discuss the submitted new drawings with Heather. She said the drawings didn't match the description in the minutes. I looked at the typed minutes which specified a 30-foot dock, as in the superceded plan, instead of the 50-foot dock reviewed at the 3/22/06 hearing. I got a copy of the minutes and later reviewed with my notes. The only two items discussed were the height above ground of the platform at the landward end of the launching ramp, and the need to use a light-transmitting material for the ramp's decking. On 5115106 I called the office to get a copy of the minutes covering the entire hearing on our project, since I was sure there was no discussion concerning reverting to the "old" design. The minutes were not done yet. On 5/18/06 I spoke to Heather reminding her that I was anxious to see the minutes. On 5/26/06 Heather called me and left a message on my answering machine saying that their previous comments about shortening the dock were"somehow incorrect" as noted by the Trustees in reviewing the minutes, and the only thing we needed to do to get the permit was to include the details of the launching ramp (see above). (There is present on the Trustees' file copy of the portion of the minutes in which Jill Doherty reads the superceded project description into the motion to approve the application,the notation "50' includes stairs" in what has been described as Heather's handwriting.) On 5/30/06, in response to DEC Notice of Incomplete Application, submitted Project Plan in new format, dated 5/15/06, project same size and configuration as approved by Trustees. On 6/6/06 discussed certain minor changes in launching ramp platform that we would prefer, asked that she discuss it with Jim King. On 6/9/06 Heather called and said Jim King said our proposed change to the launching ramp was OK. I should do plans and submit to get Trustees' permit. I decided to wait since we were actively making more changes per continuing DEC requests. On 7/11/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan, Revised 7/9/06, project same size and configuration as approved by Trustees. On 10/23/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan,Revised 10/19/06, project configuration changed per DEC requirements and design of launching ramp changed. On 11/3/06, in response to further DEC comments, submitted Project Plan, Revised 11/3/06. On 11/25/06, received DEC permit based on Project Plan,Revised 11/3/06. Proper-T Permit Services P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue NY 11935 Phone: 631-734-5800 Fax: 631-734-7463 MEMORANDUM DATE: May 4,2006 TO: Lauren -Trustees FROM: Jim Fitzgerald SUBJECT: Kram; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Here are 3 copies of the plan the Trustees approved at the 3/22/06 meeting. Please calculate the permit fee and let me know. MAY 8 2006 Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" =39 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant:Steven Kram SCT#1000-90-1-2 " T wnt Sou hBayvold iew C� 72�Setaa we Suffolk County, NY t86 1. aar s°4ih0/0, 0,sor s Surveyed:01-19-06 Q�� adr pro. Amended:01-24-06 � � a a 0/� y7 9>A ��O 02-27-06,03-11-06 1 7 0; sI/e 04-04-06,04-10-06 33 y °.0 r,`e Datum: Low Water Q D� QyC?�o Ar° r'�� 0 Q � ; ��' �0k osea r2Q. s10 �0 s, prop eo. esr� l ' .k / Dock, k o q A� -}- � quo qh .\ \ MAY - 8 2006 � `per� ?,6 �•o �g ��,/ 'pq eQ4 . . .. aF 01�9r,0oCk4 vY e a °atsX7ss tO 4 W 4-a k e Section 1" =20' Pro osed All hardware p galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp steps to LW ___ Float Proposed 6X15, Gazebo __ -HW SEA LEVEL 10'x12' Edge of I _ MAPPING 1^leRands ed e - PO BOX#538 delineated o{ 8° d►a• exist. bttm. RPO BOX D,MY 38 WR. Fox bank Iles ICI-Orb p' oc 631-722-3390 4/10/2006 0.45.33FM GA5LM\rrGMKL4.pro Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" =30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant:Steven Kram SCT#1000-90-1-2 N Situate: Bayview C 7streel` IN E Town: Southold190,2�S do' Suffolk County, NY `86 c 4�d r ih°/aes ac ss or s Surveyed:01-19 06 A , N eryar p,°. Amended:01-24-06 0/ y7 A � t 02-27-06,03-11-06 73 L` o � 79>7°���`p byte 04-04-06,04-10-06 c3 y .� e Datum: Low Water 0 °� Ord Ir LO o ''v 61A l,,o�aSea 9 \ 071. CVj l_ I ---___—T o e,- JCL` Dock, If Ramp ff -O-Cr / Float '�� O c;" 6 J SG /rO�r , `tee. Jr \\\ 0 I i, r . 0 b,�QJ 04) 010 & MAY — 8 2060CY o \� o�m I Sro'o I: : 3 osea ,fie o 2S 2 abv �o� ;ell �` 3't 1V l.a k e Section 1° =20' Pro osed All hardware p galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp steps to LW Float ----------------- - --- - -- Proposed 6'x 15' Gazebo __ -HW SEA LEVEL ----- - --------L-W 10'x12' Ed a of _ __ MAPPING Wetlands ed a ``--- - - PO BOX#538 - ---- -------------- -- - - delineated o 8" dia. exist. bttm. RPO BO AD, 38 by R Fox bank Iles GI-14-0b lNY l' or, 631-722-3390 4/10/2006 0,45,33PM i GlSLM�KramWL4{�ro Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" = 30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant:Steven Kram SCT#1000-90-1-2 " SituaTown: Southold CGQ 72>Setaa ew w e Suffolk County, NY &t c to 4�d r s°Oth°saes ac ss°f s Surveyed:01-19-06 A , N eo." A,° Amended:01-24-06 `O� a Y a pin yyt9, t0 Site 02-27-06,03-11-06 1 04-04-06,04-10-06 33 y °.c Datum: Low Water �►a o Ord o-o °'C?`�o @ Ar o r V ,b 0 Q " ' N, ?Oko 0�6 ;/o. A stogy 20, �c 0 , r o� rd�'bm Dock, � � ,1' Ramp 8 �•9 / `` o+ Float _ _, . �'e //► �� �/ ����` ,1� �Off`/q/7qq i 0 > `�T . . p0tiO 10 eQCY MAY - 8 2006 S,ab ssao 2s zg ��, q� F ' ►•gr °ck ,/ice, , 1 .� FtoatSX�s to0, _ k S Section 1" =20' Proposed All hardware p galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp-,,, amp steps to LW Float Proposed ------------------------ _ _ ____ ____ ----- 6'x15' Gazebo _ SEA LEVEL �-_-_ - --------LTV 10'x1Z Edge of MAPPING Wetlands ed a ----- -- - ------ - ---- -------------- - - PO BOX#538 delineated a 8" dia. exist. bttm. RPO BO AD, 38 . R Fox bank pIles NY VICI-06 il' oc 631-722-3390 4/10/2006 0.45.33PM GA5LM\KramWL4.pro Plan View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" =39 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT#1000-90-1-2 N SituaTown: Southold iewCe 72�setaa w+e Suffolk County, NY &t 0'�r s°016, q ce 6,°or S Surveyed:01-19 06 00,P AP . Amended:01-24-06 Lp� Ap j Ny77 'O0�ect 02-27-06,03-11-06 13 a a 7 tQr; e 04-04-06,04-10-06 3 0 o Datum: Low Water a o Orj Le 00 Q CO ;io. �ry s o 20ea r2o� 0 � sA Aare;h9�pr° s, , o U 1 �I c cli - -T-o z i 6Y� Dock, I RFloat$ 4o ��` 1� o+O�o o q�y OQ MAY - 8 20Q§ • O b�9r, GO to 4 yak e 'Section 1° =20' Proposed All hardware P galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6 wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp steps to LW Float Proposed ------------------------ --- -_ 6'x 15' Gazebo _ SEA LEVEL 10'x 12' Edgc�e of WetTand5 ed a ------------- MAPPING PO BOX#538 delineated o w Clio. exist. bttm.WRNERHEAD,NY . Fox bank riles 19-06 II' oc 631-722-3390 4/10/2006 0:45:33PM 0ASLMIKr=K-44;ro Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (631) 734-5800 May 4, 200 ByFederal Express { M AY - 8 2007 "ti" Charles Hamilton,Natural Resources Supervisor ) V Office of Natural Resources NYS Department of Environmental Conservation `id Town 1 Sou ftia 1 SUNY Campus,Building 40 Ecard of Trusteas Stony Brook,New York 11790-2356 Re: 1-4738-02842/00002• Shirley Kram SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Dear Mr. Hamilton: I have become aware that-the drawings (both"Revised 5/2/07")provided with my 5/3/07 letter to you both indicate, erroneously, that the change in the proposed length of the dock was "required by the Southold Trustees",when in fact the change was"requested by the Southold Trustees". The drawings have been revised to reflect the correction of this error, and four copies of each are enclosed. These should replace the earlier-dated versions previously supplied. S' c rely, es E. F'i rald, Jr. Enclosures: Project Plan; Revised 5/3/07 (4 copies) Section View,Revised 5/3/07 (4 copies) cc: Jill Doherty, Southold Trustees Steven Kram a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION -PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL n �V' � EXISTING SURFACE MATERIAL 20'X 20' V TO BE REMOVED AND RE- PLACED WITH BLUESTONE LIMIT OF-CLEARING HON. SHIRLEY KRAM GRAVEL PRO POSED GAZEBO UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT . OR STORAGE SHED 500 PEARL STREET 7'X 14'OR OTHER SIZE j NEW YORK, NY 10007 to LESS THAN 100 sq.ft. I U SIX STAKES PLACED w w `- - ---- -1 NUMBERED'•AS SHOWN o wo PROPOSED�LAUNCHING RAILS SPACED 3.5±X 2T OVERALL• O W O 1�57 �. . CROSS-MEMBER LOCATIONS s : i i TYPICAL co iN o 0 1 VHV Y CD ,' _ =_= ._T. ,'� �' ,''•• , `,��y,, �Y"m—'--1NETLAND BOUNDARY • •. ---- - '� ! ` I _ •(3:1--. ._ _ _ BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED .,Ramp r DOCK N X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE I Moat .O!h ti, -3•3 DECKING AND 6" d. PILES, AS RE- j QUESTED BY SOUTHOLD TRUSTEES I �• I ¢ 10\00 FLOAT 5'X 10'SECURED TO END OF DOCK AND BY TWO 6"- d. PILES 3.6 OR 2"-METAL PIPES. ACCESS TO FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- I SCALE: T'=20' ED TO DOCK. 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN 'O Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE: floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching Represented by 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES SOUTHOLD, NY 11971 DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617 Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised May 3,2007 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED DOCK 4'X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE DECKING AND 6" d. PILES, AS RE- QUESTED BY SOUTHOLD TRUSTEES LADDER 2'-2.5'WIDE ATTACHED TO DOCK FOR ACCESS TO FLOAT LANDWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; SEAWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS;2T LONG OVERALL.- ' RAILS 2X LUMBER ON EDGE SPACED 3.5'± APART, OR FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENT ; FLOAT 5'X 10'SECURED AT END OF DOCK BY TWO 6" -d, PILES OR 2" METAL PIPES. l ; jj -- —� — _------ HIGH WATER EDGE OF WETLANDS, BY LOW WATER R. FOX, 1/19/06 �' , SPRING M �t- HIGH WATER «.— EDGE OF BANK ALL DIMENSIONAL LUMBER, TIMBER AND PILING ARE OF 6" DIAMETER PILES- CCA TREATED WOOD.ALL 11'±ON CENTER HARDWARE IS GALVANIZED SCALE: 1/8"= 1' STEEL. CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA SECTION VIEW Application regarding the property of . PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching Represented by ramp for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised May 3,2007 Proper-T Permit Services P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue NY 11935 Phone: 631-734-5800 Fax: 631-734-7463 MEMORANDUM DATE: 11/26/07 TO: Dave Bergen - Trustees Bob Ghosio - Trustees FROM: Jim Fitzgerald SUBJECT: Kram/Benali—SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Steve Kram asked that I provide you each with two copies of the Project Plan(Revised 11/3/06) approved by the DEC. One copy has a"stringline" added in red. Also, there is a photo Steve took, on which he's drawn the magical stringline. 7 cc: Jill Doherty (photo only) Steve Kram — - ---- DJL �� „f i_;.' NOV 2 6 20,07 -PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL 20'X 20' 1 20.- „ _ LIMIT OF CLEARING j - HON. SHIRLEY KRAM ' PROPOSED GAZEBO t UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT OR STORAGE SHED 500 PEARL STREET TX 14'OR OTHER SIZE I NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. I v ti �I �z �. lit �•� , . � � SIX STAKES PLACED, w w w W_�- ---- -� NUMBERED'AS SHOWN W Iwo O , _ l t el PROPOSED-LAUNCHING RAILS a �'' �. L_ SPACED 3.5'±X 27' OVERALL; � O O r p CROSS-MEMBER'LOCATIONS 1 I ' o C� r , TYPICAL N � (n V 1 V11VV r� \`\\1 %- -'-WETLAND BOUNDARY BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 WV Y" y —I.O ' PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED �'�1 Ramp 4 DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE • ' �dl , DECKING AND 6" d. PILES 1 3.8 'v' ✓c V Y ' 2.4 1 APPROVED AS PER TERMS -` ;5 1 —42 � AND CONDITIONS-OF ,,a+��/DOOD d O 1.. --4.1 PERMIT N . /:—V 7. 91. 0. `I FLOAT 5'X.10'SECURED —2;q r 1 DACE OF DOCK AND 6°' d. PILES 5.h OisAL PIPES.ACCESS TO FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- 2.5 1 SCALE: 1"=20' ED TO DOCK. --- '-• ' 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN Application regarding the property of ^ PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 ramp and floating Dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE;STREET WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE launching ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 SOUTHOLD,NY 11971IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 .PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL 20'X 20' 120. Y LIMIT OF CLEARING i _ HON. SHIRLEY KRAM PROPOSED GAZEBO UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT OR STORAGE SHED 5Q0 PEARL STREET 7'X 14'OR OTHER SIZE I NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. I to SIX STAKES PLACED, UJ w w-r �• ---- -� `NUMBEREDAS SHOWN w • U,�6, �l- , t � w o CO O PROPOSED-LAUNCHING RAILS 01 SPACED 3.5'±X 2T OVERALL; O .�'a O o \� �1�p � -� �. GROSS-MEMBER'LOCATIONS Ito,N b TYPICAL SH ^ ^4 Q It ... n {N a `\1 .......i-—— .. —HJAI I _ r ;,i / _ 7 '--'' — '' 1,- --WETLAND BOUNDARY '� �'.• I _— —C31——— __ BY R. FOX, 1/19/06 0A_ .p -Wi -O.q khead I 1.1! Ram 1 _I,p - PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED 1 Flop 4 DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE 1. opal , DECKING AND 6"d. PILES .- I �oGY , ib. —3.5 2.<F I ItPPROVED AS PER TERMS D '` —�i.�i C -q.2 2.�f! aND COIdDITIQ(dS`QF 1/DaUD Vj00 1.. --4.f _ I PERMIT N . ��o'�`>�I FLOAT 5'X 10' SECURED TO END �,p 2.q. r I DATE OF DOCK AND BY TWO 6"' d. PILES OR 2"-METAL PIPES.ACCESS TO ! FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- _�� 2,5 I SCALE: 1"=20' ED TO DOCK. - 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN 1 3.0 1 Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 ` ramp and floating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented.by STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE: launching ramp,for private recreational purposes_. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 SOUTHOLD, NY 1197 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (631) 734-5800 May 3,200 By Federal Express Charles Hamilton Natural Resources Supervisor - ! �' Office of Natural Resources NYS Department of Environmental Conservation �;l MAY 2007 SUNY Campus,Building 40 Stony Brook,New York 11790-2356 --- -" " JGuliiulu ...[". Re: 1-4738-02842/00002; Shirley Kram, SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Dear Mr. Hamilton: Enclosed are revised drawings for this project, which NYSDEC has previously approved under the referenced file number above,prepared in consultation with Jill'Doherty, Vice-President of the Southold Trustees,with the intent of resolving certain issues concerning the size of the dock. The-revised plan reduces the overall length of the fixed dock, as approved by NYSDEC, by 10 feet. This revision is requested.by the Southold Trustees in order to resolve their concerns about the length of the dock. We ask that the NYSDEC permit be amended to reflect this change. Note also that a notation has been added to the project plan indicating that the now-existing sur- face material placed in the parking area will be carefully and completely removed and replaced with bluestone gravel. / If you have any questions or comments,please call me. rely, es E. Fitz ald, Jr. Enclosures: Project Plan,Revised 5/2/07 (4 copies) Section View, Revised 5/2/07 (4 copies) cc: Jill_Doherty__S1outhold Trustees Steven Kram a subsidiary of -THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION -PROPOSED PARKING AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL*' �0I � EXISTING SURFACE MATERIAL 20'X 20' TO BE REMOVED AND RE- PLACED WITH BLUESTONE, LIMIT OF CLEARING � ,.. � ;, HON.SHIRLEY KRAIVI GRAVEL _ PROPOSED GAZEBO UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT . . OR STORAGE SHED 600 PEARL STREET TX 14'OR-OTHER SIZE i NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. i SIX STAKES PLACED, W w U ---- -1 `NUMBERED'•AS SHOWN o �I- o o Y r / t �� PROPOSED"LAUNCHING RAILS j _ LO p'Vj p / SPACED 3.5'±X 27'OVERALL; O CROSS-MEMBER'LOCATIONS to ��,. sL ► TYPICAL • SHW `.. Q � r„ •— .. ..� ,� \may'- hr N' Y`-----WETLAND BOUNDARY . _Q I_ BY R. FOX, 1119/06 -O.a -0.q I bUlkhepcl I Ram PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED I I� el t DOCK 4'X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE 1 loq� !h DECKING AND 6" d. PILES,AS RE- A� , 3•b QUIRED BY SOUTHOLD TRUSTEES 9OL -3.5' �� I.. --4.1 .. FLOAT 5'X 10,SECURED TO END 2.4 1 " E• OF DOCK AND BY TWO 6"- d. PILES 3.6 OR 2"-METAL PIPES.ACCESS TO 1 FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- I SCALE: 1"=20' _ ED TO DOCK. .2 5 2.5 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN r Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE;_ floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching Represented by 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE ramp,for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES SOUTHOLD, NY 1.1971 DATUM:NEW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 _______...___.... .... . IN: West Lake AT: Southold • ' . James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised May 2,2007 '1 PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED DOCK 4'X 40'WITH OPEN GRATE DECKING AND 6"d. PILES, AS RE- QUIRED BY SOUTHOLD TRUSTEES LADDER 2'-2.5'WIDE ATTACHED TO DOCK FOR ACCESS TO SEAWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; FLOAT LANDWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; 27' LONG OVERALL: RAILS 2X LUMBER ON EDGE SPACED 3.5'± APART, OR FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENT ; FLOAT 5'X 10'SECURED AT.END �- OF DOCK BY TWO 6" -d, PILES OR 2"METAL PIPES. HIGH WATER EDGE OF WETLANDS, BY b R. FOX, 1/19/06 LOW WATER, �� SPRINGa- HIGH WATER EDGE OF BANK ,� �,r7-7 ALL DIMENSIONAL LUMBER, TIMBER AND PILING ARE OF 6" DIAMETER PILES- CCA-TREATED WOOD. ALL 11'±ON CENTER HARDWARE IS GALVANIZED STEEL. SCALE: 1/8"= 1' CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA SECTION VIEW Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway and Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 floating dock,and two-rail small craft launching Represented by ramp for private recreational purposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN: West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised May 2,2007 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation chow Division of Environmental Permits, Region One NMF Buildino 40-SUNY,Stony Brook,New York 11790-2356 Erin M.Crony Phone:(631)444-0365 PAX: (631)444-0360 Commissioner NOTICE OF PERMIT DENIAL January 4,2002 Mr.Frank Campanelli 31 Pond Path Lake Grove,NY 11755 APR - 3 2007 Re: 1-473 8-02841/00001 1275 Cedar Point Drive West SUM#1000-090-01-02 Southold,New York 11971 Dear Mr.Campanelli: We have carefully reviewed your application to construct a single family dwelling, deck, garage,driveway and sanitary system in the adjacent area of a tidal wetland. It has been determined that your application fails to meet the applicable standards for permit issuance as contained in the Tidal Wetland Land Use Regulations, 6NYCRR Part 661. Section 661.9(c)(2)requires that regulated activities must comply with the development restrictions of section 661.6, and section 661.9(c)(3)requires that regulated activities must not have an undue adverse impact on the present or potential value of any adjacent or nearby tidal wetland. This project does not comply with development restrictions 661.6(a)(1) or 661.6(a)(2) which respectively require that the minimum setback for all principal buildings in excess of 100 square feet be 75 feet from the tidal wetland boundary and the minimum setback for any on-site septic system be located 100 feet from the tidal wetland boundary.The proposed setbacks for the dwelling and deck are 10.7 feet and 3 feet instead of the required 75 feet. Additionally,the setback for the proposed septic system,is shown at 25 feet and does not meet the required minimum setback of 100 feet. The proposed lot development does not meet the standards for permit issuance described in section 661.9(c)(1)and 661.9(c)(3) since it is not compatible with the public health and welfare and it will result in an undue adverse impact to the present and potential value of the tidal wetlands. High ground water influenced by tides at the site will ultimately result in the failure of the septic system thereby leaching nutrients and pathogens from the system's effluent into tidal wetlands and surface waters.The proposed 25 foot setback of the septic system from the tidal TO 30Vd ZLZOVVVIE9 10:60 LOOZ/EO/bO wetland boundary is not sufficient to prevent leaching of these chemicals into tidal waters. The introduction of these materials into Nest Bay would constitute an undue adverse impact to the resource.In fact, this lot would not support a septic system in any location. Residences can also negatively impact wetlands by increasing storm water runoff into the wetlands. The 75 foot setback is intended to provide a buffer to the wetland. Construction of impervious structures(dwellings and decks)and construction activities within the buffer zone decrease its effectiveness to act as a buffer by allowing runoff of nutrients,pathogens and potentially toxic materials into surface waters. Additionally,.encroachment of structures into the buffer area will decrease its use as a habitat for wildlife. Given that this undersized lot cannot support a primary residence and a sanitary system which meets the standards of 6NYCRR Part 661. the permit is hereby denied. G o)fAs ternaOve,the Department suggests that the property be used for structures such as a shed,storage b ' 'ng,gravel parking area or any other type of small structure which will not utilize a saw' system equire extensive amounts of ill. This permit denial is made without prejudice and is based upon the current conditions on site. Please be advised that Uniform Procedures 6NYCRR Section 621.7(f)provides that an applicant may request a public hearing if the permit is denied or contains conditions that are unacceptable to them. Any such request must be made within thirty(30)calendar days of the date of the mailing of this notice of permit denial and should be addressed to the Regional Permit Administrator at the above address. You will be responsible for all costs associated with the hearing and will have the burden of establishing that the applicable standards of Section 661.9 can be met. If no response is received with 30 days,the denial will be final and a new application will be required for any future project at this location. Sincerely, John Wieland Permit Administrator cc: R Haje,ronsultants Y.ou lla,BNffW Page 2. ZO 39Gd ZLZOPOPTE9 Z0:60 LOOZ/EO/b0 The applicaaat has requested a waiance from setback development restrictions to construct a single family dwelling and deck three feet from the tidal wetland boundary, garage,driveway, septic system 25 feet from the tidal wetland boundary,a 4'x 27'ramp and a 6'x 20'float.The property is located at 1275 Cedar Point.Drive West, SCT?%I##1000=090-01-02, Southold,Suffolk County on West..Lake. 1-4788-02841/00001, KRAM PROPERTY TO"d 2b:ST zooZI oT JdN 092MVTi9:xp--I NG�'IhK3 D3GS ..N i Appllcatian Detail-1-4738-02841/00001 Batch ID 891861 Printed: 041'1012007 3.42pm Appi Idr1.4738.02841100001 Fac FRAM PROPERTY Current{S.ttaatus�Ina�ch)nt Information Leg Rear)Id 1518961 Leg ReSp 3HIRLEY WOHL KRAM t,egtResgs 7'" Atitiva x Historec Bokh One ineiDescriptlon c�c�nst std,parage,deck,drlve,sa,4'x27'ramp,8'x20'flOat ' I Lod ell, y I r+ If Page 1 of 1 TO'd OS=ST ZOOZ OT jd.d 092OM T29:YPd 15lli4d3d NMIM3 03GSAN Facility Detail-1473a02a41-KRAM PROPERTY Pointed; 04010/2007 3;43pin DEC ID 1-4738.02041 Sub Of63c9 0 Verified Locked Create Date 03/Q9J20Q7 .""'*,..... . .. .. ........_.., Name KRAM.PROPERTY Update Date r D 08'2000 m Street)' 1275 CEDAR POINT DR WEST Directions gCTM#1000-090•01.02 t'Ity SOUTFIOLD State NY Zip 11971 -[-a...... Country USA This facility is within an area of interest to the Environmental Justice program i Municipallly Information Natr'is SWIs Cod* Type County Primary SQUTHOLDTOWN SUFFOLK Legally Responsible Information Primary; Public ID Name Begin Data End Date LRP Type 151B9firL CRAM"5HIRLEY"WOIiL 5 O5/`dODfi00/0010000 ' Olvner - 1477339 ' CAMPANELLIWANK 031Q9/2001 Q5105/100E� i Program lifentiflers •-._--- _�- -��-� — ---_- AKA Names Name: Type Begin Date End Date AMPANEW PROPERTY ORMLRLY KNOWN AS 00►OOfOQO0 00/00/0000 Reference Points -- Facility Princiaal Reference Polnt NYTME; NYTMN Latitude Longitude Source 2' 7 e 78 46,696 1°01'66.6" 24'08.0 Utilixntion of GilS-Facility Mapping System Contacts �-.....,�,. -•— -._—_�—._.__._�._ Contf'ict Type Contact Name Begin Data End Dat* PROPER-TPERMITSERVICES 05!06d8Q06; DO/00lOQ00. __ PERSSONVALTER 03'0912001 05/041.20QS- • SIC Cod®s.,_�....��----_..,—.-- --- - Classiflcat'ion DEC ID HhAory DEC ID End Date 473802841 Applicatio is Appllc ltlPn ID Permit Typo Roceivod Final Disposition Expiration DEP Code Date Dispositions Date Date Analyst 1.4738.02�41/00001 TW 02/28/2001 Insufficient I 0 4/2112 0 0s LAURA J SCOVA=0 1-4738.021U1100002 TW 04/2012006 Issued 11/17/2006 11130/2011 KAREN S WESTERLIND Page 1 of 1 20'd 17G:ST ZOOtT OT 'dU 09iQre t7T'1_9:x'e.:.� NG?i APj3 :D31ISAN f Application Detali-1-aIW02$a1/0oo01 Batch ID 891861 Printed; 04JI012007 n-42pm Appi Idri,.4738.02841/DOD01 Fac KRAM PROPERTY Current 5t.tu:. —uclent Intormotlon multi Io --^ --- Lag Resp Id 131$961 Log Ros "]R•LEII'1R 97K KRATJI P R Lacy Rasps e y 1�ct!ve fiEstaric Bath p One Une'DescrlpElon co� MM+C1ge tsfd 'al.r 6YMMfS..,,NIXN' iYNYOAir�'+o'�T��WMMMY.WhiMWV[M.VM.RYwwn�FMnw.wm[rn,rw ns ,gaYrge,dookCk,drive,ss,4'x27`ramp,6'x2D'Float Page 1 of 1 zo 2V:ST 2.00Z OJT Jd-� oKOMT29!XP.� Facility Detail-1473802841 .KRAM PROPERTY Printed, 04MO/2007 3:43pm DEC ID', 1-4738-02841'. Sub Office Verified Locked Create Date 03109/200/ Name'FRAM PROPERTY Update Date D5f08/2D08 Street); 1276 CEDAR POINT DR WEST Dlraction6 CTM#1000.090.01.02 I.Ily OUTWpL,D u - $Cate rNY Zip 119T1 '.- Counlily USA This facility 1S Within an area of interest to the Enyironmpntal Justice program Municlpall.ty Infonnatlon Narr}e SWIS Code Type County Primary $4U1HOLD F3 VOWN SUFFOLK Legally Responsible Information Primary' Public ICi Name Begin Date End Data LRP Type 23 15189a1 KRAM"SHIRLEY'WOHL 05195/2006 0010010000 woe Program k:1ent1flerg AKA Nam*4 Nam,) Type begin Date End Date CAM4'A ELLI PROPERTY FORMCRLY KNOWN AS 00/0010000 - OO/DOl0000 .,, Reference Points Y� Facility Principal Reference point NYTME, NYTMN Latitude Longitude Source 16.3T8 '� 548.608_i°OV 66.6" 2°24-08,0"! Ptinzation of GIS-Facility Mapping System --- Contacts Conte',ct Type C*ritact Name, Begin Date .End Date PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES 6/0612006 i OO1D010000 PERSSOM'WALTER 08108/2001 ; 05iO4/2008 SIR Codes Classification DEC ID Hiutory DEC ID End Date 1473802841 Applicatioi'is Appliastion ID PermitCode Type Received] DisFDate'on 'EXtlon Date -DiSposition ate Analyst i'-4738.02141100001 TW 02/2812001 Insufficient 1 04/21/2005 LAURA J SCOVAZZO 1-4738.021141/00002 TW 04/2012006 Issued 11/17/2000 11/30/2011 KAREN 3 WESTERLIND Page 1 of 1 b0'd t'b:ST z007, 0T Ab 09MVVVTi9:XPA SlIN83d t O•� WIAN3 n'31SAA Applfcation DQtall-1-a738-028al/00002 Batch lD 962150 Printed. 041101200' J:44pm �. Appl Id�1'-4708-42841/04002 Fac JKRAM PROPERTY Current Sfatua 1s$ugd Leg Rxsj)Id risnrim 1.®g Reap ISHIRLEY WOHL KRAM Leg=Reapa P"' !° actide l"i—H storIC Both One Line Description —Mtat�B,float,a launching ramp,gazebo/shed,&parking area i i i I i i i Page i of 1 SO'd Sh:ST �)OOZ OT •Jdb 09'ObbbT-9:XP:11 SJTW�3d NOdTt^jN3 a3CQAN N` S'DEC EINIVIRCIN PERMITS' FCC;:6314440560 Rpr 10 2007 15:45 P.06 i Ail OdOlid NV N `ZOOOO/VW013UV-6 I ------- - S.' N0. . . � �.. � � 'A\ (% ,` r.'^• I —1 / —-e(`.\1. �' � '' � -"- 77 57ATEMENOF INTENT a zr�, THE WIATER SL��'PLY ANQ SEWAGE DISPOSAL. i r�Y✓lc'N SYSTEMS f0J? 7HIS RESIDENCE .WILL \� OARDS QF THE i •wu-fHOLU,N.Y. - N 1 �� CONFORM TO THE :STA ; SUFFOLK CO DEPT 0 EA TH SERVICES t (S) CANT .. f APPLI SUFFOLK 'COUNTY DEPT .OF .HEALTH. h :vvcai,t! .. '• 13-1 1. SERVICES = FOR. APPROVAL OF N _. . 'CONSTRUCTIONONLY GATE: }l..S.'R Er.NO.: P.—t T Ci 1VC Y`If.S? 'oj; !�rrv.rrea ) 4i APPROVED: 3 • ,._ SUFFOCO;TA P DESIG , .O r dPy.-,�.� ''-yJ��• LK C X MA NATION:' e N -1 r 7i• -• '�� _ 'V, .; 'DIST. SECT. BLOC PCL.. i Y 0c;, G aO C O.WNERSADDRESS:' i`P IT N --�]-L ' O �t :, - I —L. 2 [�e?rr :Yf4r{-, •1.•1. ,;7�_i Ro :i oL i I �' ,(.<• +•. Are-T�1�._ :,a.j-C: .DEED.:1.65-41 P. l 1 i� TEST HO STAMP L' 4 rrr r � ° W2Ir TO T;sI if VINE; •c-:r-� icr VATE nn-W c,.. rte Z. I i 1 11 N f• I`' t u•::.:• ,_.,.ut w .t) .I} - as.'•' :�•rrn 70 r--A r7.;.,a:cs r,• ; GUAR :rTm III,a=N r:tAu rut our toTn:rs.:u,:e:::ra,,ira:it:va Cr -LI 1L:'-JA4 G rn 1mt cturA:tr,ca�r.ca'_�u AW-r Aro t _fit io I ww"u`#TI All wi twmra uy 50' TO AWmOI IIIIIIIq suMVW" t .a '1 •� (of' SEAL 1 ;•t 1 �'ieva•!-ietrs'r�«zr- f*� Ntecsn �:ra level; z'" ri:.ttirsrrk-ac�f•rq-i-ir'- - f` t �g O,.,,1 ••~j l ^.: .:nicay?.i t f•fe/nor--yrt.:� :�anr(~•arty :>r..lr^vex.ri F-e-b. .Xi �� �T •r.rra r a:�wrt. —•r- :�.,.'Fzy, RODERICIC.VAN TUYL,P.C. vr ;? LICENSED LAND SURVEYORS }' GREENPORT NEW YORK - __ t K_. TOWN_OF SOUTHOLD 'BOA RD O.F.'SOUFHOLD. TOIVN;TRUSTEES :cSOUTHDLD :.. , - :.WETLANDS PERMIT.:• "k:" • : ., This:Wet{ands.;Permit.No ..:.2.34 :has.b n 6's s'r``" . . ., ,.. � :;:.•.•,,: e;: cord ee ,grantee�.. .y;;th T r ,;tee ing_to. iriforRtatioii:fiirnished�nAppheatior%L�to.'. ltl F. ,fteffby �pj{canteriz lYar y. E E]fl i ;. ... �.�?......:...... on .:}g, .. / rnap of tfie p'ropase`�twork-will>he.kepf ' onfile.in.tfieTrustee Office under the:applicationnu{1tfergnten, ,� ;µ - .<��� '•�S°,oar:,: ..l,.+>s�:_, - Per, it gran :tke`foll g rk Cor�stxuatton,of a s Ttstl�?shy, W��� iq m ranted to do owm wo ................ xk i.:And to fill with`approximtetr 2.(X �cti i dL............. ,. 4 1 a i" �s•':r 1 .... ..:. ':1.'.:•. .�... Location of.prpperty,on;which weriC to be dale L�f;t e„Pecan e a i 2d'c't .:Paint @: Drive .West • •+ , Southold: .... .t.. .... r................................ ... .....� ...... Creeks Bay or:klar6or:fronting;-property West Lake .......................... :..................................................................... ... Size of work:':Length.:...4�........ .......................................... . . 9. ............... ..................... Width .....30...: • Height Above High Water ...........?`.I�>�}..... Depth Below.Low Water N/A �.. .................. .................... ..N/A Yards-to be Excavated:............. ...................................:......:.......................:....:..:.. Yards to be Filled Agj?roximatel 200 cu yds............. , ......... ....... Manner in which material is to be removed or deposited .....,T,,rucked„in ..................................................................................................:.................................................................... Intended use of property...P:rivate residential . -------------= Conditions if any •...................................................:................................................................................. . ...........................................................................................................................................................:..... September 25, 1986'.if work-h mmen 'Expiration Date ....... ......... .... ...... .. as„not..c4 gI:4q..by'.a�[1e.,.::: •. Number of Inspections Required Z_„Trustees are:to be. notified,}{pQ�„Gq�jg�q�j,Q� .... of the work. Inspection Fees. ............$.5.00....... ............. ................................... .. .......... . .............................. Liability Policies in the Amount of ...'-"`-.-----=-------,-- :T.he validity of this permit is or may be subject.to the approval of other governmental•or municipal authorities. The Tbwn.accepts no.responsibility in applying.for or.obtaining such approval. In the: event that such approval is necessary; the holder'of this.permit shall not commence operations-here, under until such'approval has been.obtained in writing.The failure to obtain such other approval.when required-shall-'subject this permit.to immediate revocation by the Trustees upon-receipt by the- Trustees• of f written notice from'such other governmental or municipal authorities of its refusal or. disapproval:" ' .:.• . r.. �, 36 ' .. "` March 22, 2000 :: Board 'of Trustees TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Sure.. TRUSTEE FOSTER: . In. other :words 'that anything that. has to be removed . :. on your ,proper'ty:` Will -be replaced'. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : Should be restored. TRUSTEE FOSTER: That is not unreasonable. :. -TRUSTEE. KRUPSKI : `Any other comment?'Do I have a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE SMI:THt I 'will make a motion .to close.. . hearing. TRUSTEE POLIWODA ...: Seconded: `. .:. , ' TRZT5T9.E KRJPSI{I: All- in* favor. ALL AYES :. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I 'will make a motion to Approve the plans: The.." ..' newly submitted plans. The -condition-'that the •neighbors 'property . stone, rip abutment' that if anything is disturbed that it be. restored : .to its present state. = . TRUSTEE POL:IWODA: Seconded.. TRUSTEE K°RUP•SKI: All in favor. - ALL AYES 22 : Walter Perrson on behalf 'of FRANK CAMPANELLI requests a Wetland Permit, to .construct a one family dwelling. septic system; deck, 2715 ramp and a 5 ' x 20' float.. Located 1275. Cedar Point Drive West, Southold: :• : T.RUSTEE KRUPSKI : Any one here like to speak in favor . of, the application. . WALTER PERRSON: I am representing Mr: Campanelli.' TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Artie and Henry did you take' a look at this? This is right next to Mr.' DeFeis• which :was the previous one: TRUSTEE- FOSTER: No we did not. TRUSTEE SMITH: . Do' you have DEC approval? Do you . have Board of Health approval. :. .. WALTER PERRSON: No... TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: It is about 24 feet to the wetlands of the septic system. One' of our' big concerns is ' the septic . system. . That is one: of our big concerns: . WALTER PERRSON: Mr. Campanelli bought this property in 1967 . . ' At' that time there was a building permit issued on it.: He had expediation of building eventually: (cannot understand) Things Would ,come up say that he could not build on it: There were other concerns of DEC or health department. That would be a different matter. TRUSTEE FOSTER.: Well in 1967 he would not have had any trouble building on it. But things have changed so now. You .will never that through the health department. WALTER PERRSON: I did speak' to the health department, and they said it, was part of the septic system. TRUSTEE FOSTER: 'Well you know I should not say that. You may get it through there. If you- put a concrete retaining wall all around it. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : I . have seen the, high ones . That are further away. TRUSTEE FOSTER:'.:: .But they will I am sure you .will have to put a concrete retaining wall •completely around that septic system Definitely: : ' TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: See what' I 'do not understand there? How can you encapsule, the sewage and then, what. You are going to have finite• area ofcapacity.. It has to leak .out some where. y ,y Board of Trustees-. 37 March 22 2.000 TRUSTEE FOSTER: Well it goes vertically.. ' You have to dig. down through whatever .soil ,that is there.. Until you hit good. sand which, . .:may or 'may not You may not have a problem. with that. Into. the " water table. The'n.you have to back fill with 'good clean sand- and .:. : . . WAITER -PERRSON: Is the cesspool, on that? TRUSTEE FOSTER: No it shows 'it as ,a septic tank and five pool system. : .°A regular.standard. health department approved system. ,. WAFTER PE:RRSON: There was A cesspool there R�JSTEE FOSTER: � Three foot brown . lomie sand:. So you have to dig.. down. S-1/2 feet .to .the course sand: :Then back fill with good clean m;aterial.i. I .know they are going .to make you put in a retaining wall in. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I do not, see where it .is. .from- that: distance. I . lave" Seen them deny ones further. What is .the depth o€ water there? TRUSTEE FOSTER: 'Out ';where they.did the .test -hole. It shows 5 .7 . you need . 3 foot above water to the bottom of the pools. . There 2- foot and 3 foot; So you do not .have th°e depth. So they would have to be above the surface:: WAITER PERRSON: Scale them out from the high water mark to the* back of.-.�the 'property line. How many feet that is? .:: TRX:TSTEE SMITH: : - They show,, 66 feet on one side, . but that is below l:ow water. TRUSTEE. FOSTER: From the high water you mean: ' •RUSTEE SMITH:. From the high water mark ; TRUSTEE FOSTER: Actual .high water line,. about 52 - feet'. . TRUSTEE SMITH: The jurisdiction was 75. TRUSTEE FOSTER:. ; The other side 'is even less . TRUSTEE POLIWODA: bur policy should be one that.*allows the septic tank within our jurisdiction. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: We :do not. Well we `start with our standard 50 'foot buffer-high water. See you are really constrained there;. TRUSTEE FOSTER: . The septic,:tank is a sealed unit. It is. 'not a .. leaching unit It is a . solid containment tank it st'. like the one at your house. . TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: What about the leaching pools? TRUSTEE FOSTER: Well .the leaching pools ' are leaching pools. They . leach 99% of that goes down. Very little goes to the side. You can talk to �the health department about it: 'But I know just my experience with doing. thisi I have been a septic system installer for thirty .years. I deal with these people daily. I do not' see- any other way without a retaining wall.: But they feel, if you retain the sewage from leaching side ways and let it' go down. Where - 99% of. it goes any way. -It is traveling through three feet of clean sand and gravel which their" criteria' calls for. . . :TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : How far would they .require it to go down. TRUSTEE FOSTER: Well you have to .dig into good clean sand. The test hole shows it- is 3 foot. . From ground elevation zero. You have.. a. foot of dark sandy loam'.- three foot of brown loam. sand. or at three . :..feet brown loam sand. ' - That would all have to come out of there and you will have to. fill it with course sand and gravel so that. you*. would have . a continual pervious layer: of material. . The bottom of. - leaching pools would have to. be set a minimal of three feet above the static water table.,,. , So depending. now the pools are two foot high. . . „n Board of Trustees y” ` 38 March 22, 2000 ':Three foot "above. water, that .is . five feet. . So:.then you have another' .. : concrete cover (tape. change) 'So: you are going to' be sticking quite a mays above grade. '. SO the chances are you will Have to put in. a retaining wall. in. WALTER` PERRSON: Wi11 we get health department' approval: 'TRUSTEE FOSTER: Well I do not know: I have talked to the people in .: the health :department Many many times about jobs 'like this .: From a: Trustee ]revel.': They really want to know. what "our .disposition is ;' before ".they' act on an application: We work..with -them. It they would do it? I' do 'not know ,what :: WALTER PERRSON: What .are" the set ,back rules TRUSTEE FOSTER: ', What does it say - what' is our, policy. If it is not going to ;fly through here. It 'is not going' to 'fly there either.'. So if you want to. say.: well if the health department approves it. We' ll- approve it but then it is not going by our criteria. either.'. :: TRUSTEE KRUPSKI c No i' do' not want to marry that that' s for sure: TRUSTEE F05TER: Their criteria includes. retaining walls you have to met theix rules and regulations. . But in their rules and regulations . : .. is a : condrete retaining wall So if this particular 'job meets their criteria: TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: So we are going to have to precede with_ this in some fashion now.- MERLON WGGIN: Can I speak for Mr. DeFeis: . TRUSTEE tRUPSXI: ' Sure: : MERLON WIGGIN: He. had* a copy of this application: . ' His. concern was, . I think the application shows that his house has public water. ` He has' 'a private well next to his driveway which he is still using. He says maybe "sometime . in the future he might get public water: But he has, no. immediate plan to' do that. He was concerned whether this meets a criteria of the. health department distance, '.even though ,it 'is not a Trustee concern. Because it is less than 150 feet. Then it shows that the DeFeis has public water. . TRUSTEE KRUPSKI :'. ,It said that.' Yes. TRUSTEE FOS' ER: Well you will have .to go to board. of review. If the . neighbor' objected. he would not get it. The health department probably weptic .system. But you ould grunt this application for the. s would have to do what they tell you to do to' get it. Regardless of the cost. That is fine. But if 'it does not fly .through here: . . ` It is not going to fly there either,.: : .TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I. think the only way to precede is to .have you contact the health department.. ,.We will write them a letter also.: telling them 'of our concerns . TRUSTEE . FOST.ER: See I 'would call them and ask them, but they do: not have any:' papers you have not applied to them.' „ : ::WALTER PERRON: 'No TRUSTEE FOSTER: So my. suggestionwould .be to .apply ;to the health department. '. : TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: . Let them precede first. TRUSTEE: FOSTER: " They will call us on it. I know they will call" us on it.. . One of .theefellows .will probably cail' 'me on it, as in the past. Then we have something to talk about. . But without him having the paper work or surveys or anything to look at: WALTER PERRSON: I did not apply to them because I believed they would wait until you. Board of Trustees 39. March 22, 2000 TRUS'TEE,. KRUPSKI; _. .Normally .yes .we do' not see something like this. This i.s , problematic: ; I .have to be honest. There is' no light .at the' end' of the' tunnel here:: There is no 'guarantee of permit on this property. TRiJS,TEE . SMITH: We had so m ething. like this before. Al. 'and we wound up2 using :incendiary type toilets. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : What is the minimize size house? You can build in Southold- town. TRUSTEE . FOSTER: 850 bottom floor. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: . 85-0 = I think that you would have to explore "sotttethng; at a minimun size house also. W LTER:.PERRSON:. The* basic house the living area is 833 feet. We added` `on ;because we had to put the, mechanicals . So. we -put' the :.. megh•anica;ls between the house and the garage So that we could get. tlYe' heating 'plant in .and the washer and dryer. Because we know that we:will not -be, able to put• mechanicals below the eight feet above water.. TRUSTEE FOSTER: Put in the' elevator 'then you will go up a little bit. :. W, LTER PERRSO.N I am sure that we can relocate that. Cut it down to whatever the minimum on the ' f•irst. floor. TRUSTEE FOSTER: Well that is the building department. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : No but the small . of the foot print the less impact''. TRUSTEE FOSTER: - . But the building .department has ,the 850 sq. - ft. in the bui.lding code . . : :. TRUSTEE POLIWODA:' Al. would approve this? ' Where would your buffer be? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: The hay bales That is what it looks like here. . So I will make a motion to table the application until we ..hear: from the health department and see how the applicant makes' out with that route. Do I have a second. TRUSTEE FOSTER: * Seconded '.".'::• . TRUSTEE 'KRUPSKI : All in ' favor. ALL AYES 23 . Joseph Edgar .on. behalf. .of ALAN CARDINALE requests a Wetland Permit to dredge an area approx. 30 ' x 100' to .a max. depth of .4' below ALW; .and to change the method of dredging from mechanical-; crane' a' bucket to 'portable hydraulic dredge and to-'relocate spoil from- previous -site. Located: '- 1134 Bridge' Lane; Cutchogue. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : Is any one here like' to speak in favor of or against the application. Cardinale everybody happy with this. BOARD. MEMBERS: Yes TRUSTEE KRUPSKI_ : Do I have 'a• motion to close .the hearing. TRUSTEE SMITH: Second, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Is there a second: TRUSTEE POLIWODA: Seconded. .. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: All in favor ALL AYES TRUSTEE KRUPSKI : Someone make. a motion: TRUSTEE SMITH: Make a motion that :we approve ALAN CARDINALE requests a Wetland Permit to'. dredge an area approx. 30 ' x 100 ' to a max,.' •depth: of 4 '.. below ALW, .and to change the method of dredging from :mechanical crane -and bucket to portable hydraulic dredge and. to. : .relocate spoil from previous. site: . What the hell is the' previous site? l, . �QSu�F C� Town Hall Albert J.Krupski,President j ��� Gy 53095 Main Road James King,Vice-President c t P.O.Box 1179 Henry Smith ti x Southold, New York 11971 Artie Foster 0 1 �� Telephone(516) 765-18,92 Ken Poliwoda �Ql �a Fax(516)765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only Coastal Erosion Permit Application - Z Wetland Permit Application Grandfather Permit Application � e �:� t, Waiver/Amendment/Changes To v'�`,;v t t _ Received Application: ; - O 6 Received Fee:$ S d Completed Application -® d Incomplete SEQRA Classification: Type I Type II Unlisted Coordination: (date sent CAC Referral Sent: &e1 L'J` Date of Inspection:,; y- O O `v Receipt of CAC Report: Lead Agency Determination: Technical Review: Public Hearing Held: d Resolution: Name of Applicant (A ,ti trC C A tAYA Q (_L t Address .3 ( �E L A WE (-R8✓E k) �o If s Phone Number: (63 f ) S_8'!R' - 3 .13 P Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - Q 9f 0 - Q / O „Z Property Location: SAY LAAu q (provide LILrC'O� of #, distance tocross streets, and location) AGENT: {�/ A 1,N"9 9 ( If applicable) Address• �'1 'TA C L L,4 IJ F k oc 4 I2 0 r AJ- l 0 1 /�7 Phone: / - - FAX# r7 1 B -d of Trustees Applicatioi GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet) : f, 471 Area Zoning: Previous use of property: Intended use of property: ( -��n, ',� �'C,; P P Y: E=AJ•^-F, Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? No Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary) : t`L ,b A-1 c -�J=. C I<� li-% M 2 I Bo _, of Trustees Application, WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: ;) r yJ +� ��Go e L O a�'i�v �, ��`C c� wJ I TR Area of wetlands on lot: ��Q �3 square feet Percent coverage of lot: .-C % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: 7,, f e e t (�,) )S„ '�, t K� T�J f N Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: /_ _feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? No X Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? y6 o cubic yards How much material will be filled? , 7 'G cubic yards Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: /.215Li 7�1- Q� yS•ciTf Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: T�' �t,'�L 0 ,�ay � p��ca-.i �1 S�P��� � +� 4�� �f-o,s 'TV��f_ 4-LE 12 A n 1.I L r11 r �-'b)43 c":4gr Y r`QU Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate) : J ®h f4A r EALES L11 ►' 0C S�fla 1�-c7 4c ► Nc&( M 'G/ 3 1 '74W6-4 12/8T1-7e.et 12 PROJECT T.O. NUMBER 617.21 SEC Appendix C State Environmental Quality Review SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART [—PROJECT INFORMATION (—I o be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) 7. APPLICANT iSPONSOR C 2. PROJECT NAME `Fr �,� C A n/t �`A L L L r I /J- ? s C E I)AIt f} to LJ V!;�� 3. PROJECT LOCATION: c Municipality 5" iLt L,. County J (mot HO(_K a. PRECISE LCCATION (Street address ana road Intersections, prominent ianamarKs,etc., or arovrde mapl 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: tNew ❑Expansion Modificationlalteration 5. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: LJ Ai I. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: Initially acres Ultimately acres 3. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH ECISTING ZONING OR CTHER EXISTING LAND USc RESTRICTIONS? Yes ❑No If No,describe briefly 3. ,1H IS PRESENT LAND IjSc IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? Residentlal El!n lustrial r'Commercial 7-1 ,grlcwture ParKlForesu0oen space l_ Olner Descri)e: 10. DOES.ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL OR FUNDING,VOW OR ULTIMATELY F:ROGI ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY 1FE4E.RAL, STATE OR LOCAL)? J2 Yes U No If yes,list agency(s) and permltlaoprovals 11. DOES ANY ASPcCT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? ❑Yes �No If yes, list acency name and permit/approval 12 AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL. REQUIRE MODIFICATION? ❑'Fes r No I CEi-,TIF'C THAT T INFORMATIO ROVID BOVE IS TRUE 70 THE BES—OF MY KNOWLEDGE i Atimicanusocnsor tam\e:'/ OJte: If the action is in the Coastal Area. and you are a state acency, complete the iCoastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment OVER 1 PART I,=V`JInC'J1t��J :- ~�+J�rS��Ji ,�� ze t ICES +C :%.:1 =,kCZZ_ -?IY •r-=c_i-GL� N i 'l+_FP. -;i: i'• H /es. . _fnats :AB review ;roeess and 'isa 're =_'L_ c-AF I B. '.vaL�.:CT;C t 9ECE:`+E �CCrCw:;cC �EViEN :S PRV ICED =-R urll.STE� %C-;CNS ,N i.14'rC=R, aan" . _r :t io. a ie^,ar.,e :Sear I1 rav ne sucerseaec zy znctrer nvotvea aSencv. CCULD %C7;Ct4 ?ESUL' N .1NY -;G`/EFSE °=_ -S ASSCC::.7E7 Ni_,;' =Cl_ZW'-'4G. Answers :nay ce -iancwrtttan. I eyrclei c.isttnq air ;uaiity, surrdcs or ;rounosvater cuauly ;r .uannty, iatse e'/eis, :xaung :ar:ic :arz-^s. senc vase orcccc::on or 315c: oOtenrlal 'cr tros:cn, =rainage or-looctng oroClems? 1-plain wierly: ..... Aesinetic, ir7ricultur3l, irCnaeologtcal. .ltsloflc, or other lavirai or :esourcas: or community or -.etq•^,t;crnoaa a.:arac:3r' -,darn I /ese:atlon or •auna. •Isn. sn etlfisn or wilollla spec:es, signiticant naottal=. or :nrestenea or :ncangerea acec:es? =.clam ortarly: », A Ccrnrnunity's axrs::ng Mans Or;oats as otflc:oily aciaoteo. or a change In use or intensity of use Ot!and Or other natural rescuress7:Explain 3cowiti, ;uoseauent :evetoomint. or related activities likely !o ce rnducea oy 'ne Croaosea ac:lon7 S.-wain crtefly. I .. C5. '_cng :erm. snort :emi. zurr:ulanve,ar other ettects not laennhea In C-05? Exolatn orterly. I I I ' -- _• 7,trer moacs tnc:.icing :-anges n •ise of caner auanuty or:vpe or ;nergyl E<:)tdtn cner v. 3. S 7r!E=E. --R:S -i•+E=E _.K'c_. -C BE. :`tTSG`IE?S'/ ?EI..TED 77 'QT?_IM._ •:C`r°RSE =_NVIRCNME.i7At. .:P4G73' Yes ?io f "es, axclain or1eliv I l 1?ART III--OEi ERMINATICN OF SIGNIFICANCE (,To ce comoleted by Agency) INSTRUCTIONS: Far aac:t adverse effect identified accve,determine whether It is suCstamial,large. :mcortant or otherwise signs. Eacn effect should be assessed In connection vvlth�ts (a) setting (J.e. uruan or :Ural): (t:) procaatlity of ocadt-Wg; Iicl duratit irreversibility: (e) geogracnlc scoce; and {f} magnituce. If necessary, add attachments or reference supporting materials. :Ensur explanations centarn sur'ic:ent aeI it to snow that all •e!evant adverse impacts nave been identified and adequateiv acCresse -hecx ;his nox ,f 'rou nave Identified one or morecotentially large or Significant _averse lmoac:s wnicn occur. -hen orccaea Cirectly :o :he 7UL! F.�F and/or prepare a positive aeclaraticn. — C.ecx :his bcx J you have determined. 5asaa on the information and analysis above and anv sucaorts Coc tr.entat!crr. .na. :he :)r000sed action ':JJL! NOT result in--any significant acvers2 envlrCnmentat imca( AND Orcvice --n at:acrimen(s as necassarv, the seasons supcorting this determination: I ,•.nr )f •Uc )r teia✓om-aIC ..m,:—!!r •l •v ja '-;cn C'/ .•lie JI <l•iaan l•OIC .ilfr�lf I :,gin+tint >r <r••.;Un.iOle _I'.i:f n .CEO +tienCY Myna:ure )r r•+JJr+r•It :rr:e'rnt ;rnrrl 'efOOn�.o• Jrr,[trl J+LC Bi �d of Trustees Applicatiot AUTHORIZATION (where the applicant is not the owner) z, r2A.A1ae C,4m(PAt,'i c-C U L__Nkresiding at 3 1 ?31J 0 PAW- (print owner of property) (mailing address) 0 12 _, �� Y• I ��7�Jr do hereby authorize (Agent) /Z �E�:5S,Dvy to apply for permit(s) from the Southold Board of Town Trustees on my behalf. (Owne ZY signaturdl 8 E .�-d of Trustees Applicatia. G County of Suffolk State of New York WA--� k T P,/2 �9 0-A--� BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE/SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS/HER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT( S) , IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENTATIVES(S) , TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. Signature SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF /l i , Ito Notary Public ?•O'jALIE SALEMME ,'. I'J3LIC.State Of NewYodt 01-SA4800018 Qualified ir,Suffolk County 7 oSU��Q�co Town Hall. 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Telephone 0�� Southold. New York 11971 (516) 765-189Z O! SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Monday, IV-Parch 20, 2000, the following recommendation was made: Moved by Scott Hilary, seconded by Ken Meskill, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees DISA1DPROVAL. of ttie Wetland Permit application of FRANK CAMPANELLI 90-1-2 to construct a one-famil_4 dwelling, septic system, deck and floating dock with ramp. 1275 Cedar Point West, Southold The CAC recommends Disapproval because of the following reasons: I (;oncerns with the road setback and septic setback. 2. The proposed house is within 18' of open water. Vote of Council: N-es. All Motior, Carried FOR31 No.$ TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BUILDING DEPARTMENT TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE SOUTHOLD, N. Y. BUILDING PERMIT (THIS PERMIT MUST BE KEPT ON THE PREMISES UNTIL FULL COMPLETION OF THE WORK AUTHORIZED) NO 3587 Z Dote ..........................Att t:�t....2 ..... 19...�r� Permission Is hereby granted to: C�::1:oT Inc ................................................................................ ................ :: : ;t.uo ......................................... toauilci-maw..Aae ................................................................................... atpremises located at .....9. ........................................................... ............................... g.,T... '.A 1�wq. ..?r.........g0thold...................................................._. pursuant to application dated ...................AU&Wt.........�E............. 1967.., and approved by the Building Inspector. Fee $.10.`2........... Building Inspector 1" s i ' �0 AN- A-) G- ROAD CENTER -.T 15' act 1 APPMCANT TRANSACTIONAL. DISCLOSURE PORN The Town of Soubhold ' s Code of Ethics rohibibe conflicts of nterest on the part; of town officers and employees. The purpose of this form is to provide information which can alert the town of possible conflicts of inberest and allow it to take whatever action is necessary to avoid same. C. YOUR NANB a 'X �- (Last name . First name , Atidd•le init' alo unlass you are applying in the name of someone else or other entity, such as a company. if so, indicate the other person ' s or company ' s name. ) NATURE OP APPLICATIONt (Check all that apply. ) Tax grievance Variance Change of zone App �;al of plat Cxe ption from plat or official map Other ` �� L A- (If "Other, " name the activity. ) W�- &3.n5 f���'�!�� • Do YOU personally (or through Your company► spouete► sibling. parent, or child) have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold? "Relationship" includes by blood, marriage, or business interest. "Business interest" meant; a business, including a partnership, in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of (or employment by) a corporation in which the town officer or employee owns more than 5% of the shares. YES Nd If you answered "YES, ". complete bhe balance of btiis form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself (the applicant) and the town officer or employee. kibher check the appropriate line A) through D) and/or describe in the space provided . The town officer or employee or his or her spouse, sibling, parent, or child is (check all that apply) t A) the owner of greater than 5% of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant (when the applicant is a corporation) t B) the legal or bbneficial owner of any interest in a noncorporate �entity (when the applicant is not a corporation) ; C) an officer, director, partner► or employee Of the �ww 7 , •••dM 4 • AM MAP NUMBER Town of FT-a,u.-mc- EFHCTIVE36�43CO187 G Southold 360813 DATE., MAY 4, 1998 ZONE x r.x r-� C O'[F� !' jq - '' i NDNC' R-27 93' Z 0 TEST 3ORING a GROUND EL, B D' EBROARK BROWN L.1 ANDY LOAM -� F- WN LOAMY SAND --r PALE BROWN FINE 0 5 7' TO COARSE SAND N _ WATER {N PALE BROWN 1 2•D' TO COARSE SAND TEST HOLE: DATEDUG DEC 28,999OATL CIENCE 3.30PM a Cl! SUFFOLK COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH SERVICES cn 0 FOR APPROVAL OF CONSTRUCTION ONLY co 0 o DATE _____ � �-_-�— HS REF NO --------- c 0 I _ I ' TO: THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD COUNTY OF SUFFOLK, STATE OF NEW YORK In the Matter of the Application.of BENALI, LLC SCTM: 1000-92-1-2 FACTUAL OUTLINE From: Patricia C. Moore Attorney for applicant Office and Post Office Address, Telephone 51020 Main Road Southold,NY 11971 (631) 765-4330 411 APR 1 8 2007 i _ , 1 1 Owner: BENALI,LLC by Steven Kram Property: West Cedar Point Drive, Southold Work Session: April 18,2007 The Purposes of Chapter 275 is the protection, preservation, proper maintenance and use of its wetlands. What was constructed was reviewed and approved by the Trustees and is consistent with the policies of Chapter 275. 1. Initial application is for t-shaped 4'x 30' fixed dock 3.5' above grade, with Tx14'hinged ramp and 6'x20' float [a combined series of structures totaling of 50 feet in length] and boat launch ramp (6'x 4' decking and 6'x 14'ramp)and 10' x 12' gazebo. The owner did not want this plan because it was too expensive to construct and maintain,the removal and repair each season was an ongoing expense that was too high, and the effect on the wetlands to remove and reinstall unnecessary. 2. On March 14, 2006 prior to publication of legal notice, prior to field inspection and prior to public hearing,the applicant submitted a modified drawing showing a 4'x 50' fixed dock 3.5' above grade and 5' x 15' float to be placed parallel to fixed dock [hinged ramp removed in this modified drawing; float was reduced in length from 20 to 15 feet and moved from end of fixed dock. It was proposed to be placed along side/parallel to fixed dock.] A new project description was provided and the cover letter described specifically the differences between the new plan and the old plan. This modified plan is shown in drawing"B"[ see Exhibit A] 3. At the field inspection, with the new drawing in hand and the 50' length of the dock into the water staked,the Trustees requested the following modifications to drawing B as reflected in the" Field inspection worksheet" [see Exhibit B]: a. Designate on drawing the clearing limits b. Relocate the gazebo or storage shed C. Add a parking area 20 x 20 d. Reference points for location of gazebo and end of dock were identified e. Noted that the ramp was not necessary 4. The legal notice and the board agenda properly described the modified plan. 5. The modified plan was the subject of the public hearing. At the public hearing, applicant submitted"red lined" drawing depicting the modifications requested by Trustees during . field inspection. [ See Exhibit C ] 6. At the public'hearing, discussions were held with respect to design of the boat launch ramp. How wide, of what material, and whether to be built on grade, or, as requested by Trustee James King; launch ramp to be built 1 foot above grade. THIS WAS AGREED TO BY APPLICANT ALONG WITH THE OTHER ITEMS FROM#3 ABOVE. No objection or comment was made with respect to the applicant's fixed dock or float. [see copy of transcript of public hearing, Exhibit D] 7. The Resolution adopted by board used the initial application description in error and not the modified plan that had been the subject of the field inspection and public hearing. ** ** These transcription errors are not uncommon. When this occurs Heather corrects the transcript with approval of a Board member. She stated to both Mr. Kram and to Jim Fitzgerald (left a message on his voice mail and told him in person)that she went to a Trustee and had this corrected. 8. Upon completion of public hearing, on May 8, 2006 applicant submitted drawing showing Trustee requested field inspection revisions and the modifications to the boat launch ramp (relocated gazebo,parking area, limit of clearing and 6x23 ramp and 6x4 platform) [see Exhibit E] 9. After the hearing, Heather,the Trustee staff member, was preparing the written permit when it became clear that the resolution that was adopted was in error. The resolution incorrectly referred to the initial application AND NOT the application as it had been amended prior to the field inspection, legal notice and public hearing. 10. In May, 2006 Jim Fitzgerald met w/Heather and Trustee Jill Doherty at the Trustees office to discuss the error in the resolution. Heather agreed that the minutes had to be corrected to reflect the approval of the amended application. 11. Heather said in the voice mail to Jim Fitzgerald on 5/26/06, according to notes made by Jim Fitzgerald contemporaneously with the message, "that their previous comments about shortening the dock were incorrect as noted by 'the Trustees' in reviewing the minutes, and the only thing Jim had to do to get the permit was to show the platform at the top of the launching ramp as one foot above grade, and the launching ramp itself should be fiberglass or perforated metal to let the sun through so vegetation can grow under it. Therefore,that problem with the transcript had been resolved. HEATHER ALSO NOTATED THE TRUSTEE TRANSCRIPT WITH THIS INFORMATION. However,this was not necessary because the height of the boat launch above grade would be noted on the Trustees permit,the perforated platform was no longer applicable with an open boat rail. 12. From June through November 2006 the DEC reviewed and approved a reduced final plan. 13. The DEC approved: 4' x 50' open grate decking with 6" piles- no stairs only a ladder at the end (same as Trustees-Heather had noted on the file that 50' included the stairs)) y 1 The float was reduced in size to 5' x 10' (Trustees approved 5' x 15') Boat Launch platform was made "27'-3.5 spaced launching rails" open and without a platform- (Trustees approved 6'x4' + 6' x23'=total length same 27' with,grated platform)- there was no need to show "grated platform" because it was an open boat launch within the footprint approved by the Trustees. Gazebo reduced to 7' x 14' (less than 100 sq.ft.) (Trustees approved 10' x 12') 20' x 20' pervious parking area (same) 14. There were no extra details on the Boat Launch required- Jim Fitzgerald did not make it an issue because they were working with the DEC on the final design of the Boat Launch. In November 2006 the DEC had modified it and reducing the size and square footage of the structure. It was reduced from 6'wide x 27 long (platform)two rails 3.5 feet apart. The open boat launch rails were held in place by two piles and the adjacent dock. The overall structure requires less ground penetration then a platform boat launch, AND IT MUCH MORE ENVIRONMENTAL SOUND THAN THE PREVIOUS PLAN. 15. In all respects the Trustees permit was ready to be issued- Only the ministerial act of typing it was required. The DEC revisions resulted in a smaller plan-reduced environmental impacts meeting all of the Board's policies and permit conditions. There was no further review required by the Trustees because the DEC approved plans were smaller structures then those reviewed and approved by the Trustees. 16. No one ever discussed reducing the length of the proposed dock-the only comment made through Heather, after the error in the resolution was discovered,was that the maximum length was 50 feet( including the stairs). The solution.which was implemented was to eliminate stairs and use a ladder down to the float. The owner did not request another plan-the approved plan is a 50 foot dock with a 6' x 15 float and 6'x 27 boat ramp. The r Trustees approved more than what was actually constructed. The Trustees failed to issue the written permit in June after the minutes of the meeting were corrected. Please issue the written permit granted in June 2006. 17. Owner does not want a Ramp just dock and float. DEC insists that the float must be in no less than 3.5 feet of water. SOLUTION: float can be relocated to "L"- will not protrude out beyond 50' (what we understand from pervious comments to Mr. Kram that the Trustees believed they approved) The DEC placed the float at the end of the 50' dock with the ladder down (no ramp) �_'Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (631) 734-5800 March 14, 2006 President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road MAR 14 2006 Southold,New York 11971 Re: Shirley Kram; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Dear Sir: Judge Kram has requested that certain changes be made in the plan which was recently submitted: the fixed open walkway is twenty feet longer, the fourteen-foot hinged ramp is eliminated,the float is reduced in length by five feet and relocated to the side of, and parallel to,the fixed open walkway, and the launching ramp is increased in length by nine feet to reach the low water line. A possible alternative to the gazebo, a storage shed of the same size,is proposed. Three copies of the revised plan are enclosed. The new project description is as follows: PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Construct fixed open walkway 4' x 50', and float 6' x 15' parallel to the fixed dock; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6' x 23' with 6' x 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' x 12' gazebo or storage shed. Clear upland motes as necessary for access to structures and for off- street parking. The project plan and the included project description mailed to adjacent property owners reflected these proposed changes. Sincerely, i es E. Fitzgera r. a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION �� a,7 07 : 02A KRAM,/MAX MEDICAL 310 476 1655t P_01 �'( l�CJ7-�i 1-1 r RUI'I•rRUr Ci[ 1 �G1�/1LC.� UJt 1 J-1 1-iVJ u a...ii c- i•vi•..•�� i Ate Flan , _ �, _� Prepared fo: ►t + 134 ' — 'Ceder Basch Park' AppticAnt:Steven Kram N SCT#E 1000-9V-2 Situat®:BByvlew C'e w fi Town: Southold Suffolk County.IVY � ad r s Surveyed:01-1"6 p Amended:01-24-M to O/ 7� Amended;02-27-08 �3 Q Ara Amended:03-11-06 � Datum: Low Water ? t S', _r o ��;0s t%8� �,s --� Q p of lt �O -r- , �9b q 1 (d�ltneatod J t Dock,`. _ Jlc ; R. ftXFloat -to L� r s is A , erg 19,E r yJ y� 1g� 3 y✓� ,(� aIr 9 Cross Section 1•=20' A]l hm-dwarS �p IvC31@Od Proposed Proposed D=k 4'X W AU 11knbar 8'wlde 3.51 ebv.gr. kom approved 1bt ramp snips to Lw Float Proposad -- ----- 8'x 151---- HW PREPARED Ot G"abO - ----- - --------- UN MAPSEA LPVEL ING 10'x 72' a of o� r- ------- - -- ----- ----- O BOX 0 Wa deNline on dim ezlst, bttm. R1VERH�,NY by R Fax 105 es1 T22�39� i�tR�0i6 !n�/1006 471.:�1 G.�MY'�'on4.9 o-- i tt James F.King,president S0114o Town Hall Jill M.Doherty,Vice-President 0 53095 Route 25 Peggy A. Dickerson P.O.Box 1179 Dave Bergen Southold,New York 11911-o959 John Holzapfel �� Telephone(691)765-1592 �COUNTY,Nc� Fax(631)'765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Worksession Report Date/Time: " Name of Applicant: S h i cle k(ct' Name of Agent: Property Location: SCTM#& Street Brief Description of proposed action: �— it (' Q n T�f area to be impacted: _Saltwater Wetland Freshwater Wetland _Sound Front Bay Front Distance of proposed work to edge of above: Pa/of Town Code proposed work falls under: _Chapt.97._Chapt. 37_other Type of Application:_Wetland_Coastal Erosion Amendment_Administrative _Emergency Info needed: c1Z Y — ZcJ T J r Modifications: G"'I'. I S -1 W`�f��, r, 4,..� w L s`'„•� ,mot `'� Conditions In/, Present Were: King�-/J.Doherty`fP.Dickersori D. Bergen Holzapfel _Other: "U7 Mailed/Faxed to: Date: 1 O7 :O2A KRAM/MAX MEDICAL 310 476 . 1655+ P_02 vstLJ GJ1 rJY rYOJ IU71310,1761655 P.5 i Plan id red forLW 134 .Beach Park' gnt:Steven Kram f OOD-90-1-2 N 3:8ayview C9 Of, w E Southold c Caunty,NY �.�,40 0'�� �0 _"�P 5f► s led:01-19-O8 W:01-24-06 (o 0 led:02-27-08 Law Wlrter ell,e Lois+ � 6 h �d x°b ofr � _ J� '���qqa of Olt ,}� i WeEland� Dock, R fox �S i IAs ?may i G, i r 44,re 3s Section r22 eb All hmndK e Pvmd proposed Doak 4'x 50' All kgdper V w(le 3-6 abv.gr. from ramp steps to LW approved Ite6 Float r -- 6x15'---- PREPAREOM o Ed /� � —r _ _______=_ LH SEA LEVEL Z Tarim - _ _ _ _ _ MAPPING "Yieotad 'e'did, ®xbf: bl ttn WARHEAD.Ml by R fox bunk p;o�G 631 7222-3= C.,Y! . vr+�a o l KRAM DRAFT —TRUSTEE HEARING 3/22/2006 12. Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of SHIRLEY lJ�� KRAM requests a Wetland Permit to construct a fixed open walkway 4' by 50', and float 6' by 15' parallel to the fixed dock; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float, construct wood launching ramp 6' by 23' with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' by 12' gazebo or storage shed; clear upland vegetation as necessary for access to structures for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Drive, Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 TRUSTEE DOHERTY: The description I read is a little different than on the agenda, it's been updated. We all were at the site the CAC did not inspect, so therefore, no comments. And LWRP found it inconsistent, which we talked about in the field and made some changes the setbacks -- MR. FITZGERALD: The gazebo or shed 25 feet back from the end of the dock and the parking area 20' by 20' is shown. The 25 feet is the figure you gave me. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And there's one comment here from LWRP that 1 don't understand, it says swimming pool and related structures. Because he has that highlighted, but =- MS. CUSACK: He took it out of the code it says swimming pool and related structures have to be 50 feet-- TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Right, it's bold, so I didn't know, right. We talked about the ramp next to it and how we felt we didn't need to have that size ramp there. I see that's still -- MR. FITZGERALD: : The decision is about the width as I recall, and I asked the applicant's son to measure the dolly they use for the Sunfish, and the outside dimension of the wheels is 4'4". TRUSTEE DOHERTY: So, what are you proposing that be? MR. FITZGERALD: Six feet which seems reasonable given the width of the boat, which is somewhat more than that and the width. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: what were you proposing material for that ramp,.to build that? MR. FITZGERALD: I don't know I would presume that marine ply would be. TRUSTEE KING: If we allow that it should be the new grated system, kept low and the stuff will grow up toward -- TRUSTEE BERGEN: Let me ask you this, would it work, would it suffice where instead of installing a ramp, you just clear the area like you said about 6', she said about 4'4", so next to the dock about 6' of extra clearing so they could wheel it down there; is there any need for the ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: That would be the best way of doing it, but the bank at that point is at least 18 inches shy. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Maybe we could use the new material that's out that you could put down and the growth could still grow. MR. FITZGERALD: That's a good idea. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: It's a hard surface, but yet you still have the growth. It's not going to get out of control because you're going to be using it. I think we would rather see something like that. MR. FITZGERALD: I think I would too, it seems more practical. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Here are hand-drawn plans in red. MR. FITZGERALD: I wasn't able to get the real map done by the map guy in time, so I did that and unless you have some changes, if you could act on it contingent upon the new map being that way in black instead of red? TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Sure. TRUSTEE KING: What was the proposed height of this ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: You mean height above grade? It would be at grade. The flat part up top just four feet would be at grade and it would go down, straight down from there. TRUSTEE KING: I'm just thinking DEC, I'd like to see it up off the ground a foot. MR. FITZGERALD: Okay. But there's got to be a way to get the wheels up. TRUSTEE KING: Just have a little ramp up to it out of that graded material, and that would allow some vegetation to grow under it. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And to use that material. Are there any other comments from the Board? I make a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES TRUSTEE DOHERTY: I make a motion approve the application of Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of Shirley Kram for a fixed open walkway 4' by 30'; hinged ramp 3' by 14'; floating dock 6' by 20';`install two piles or metal pipes to w � secure float; construct a launching ramp approximately one , foot high made of a fiberglass or some other or aluminum0 I grating system that the vegetation could grow through, and that would be approximately a 6' by 14' ramp with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end, and to construct4a 10' by 12' gazebo 25 feet back from the landward edge of the dock, and a 20' by 20' area for off-street parking all subject to revised plans showing all that. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES. ' "Proper-T Permit Services P.O. Box 617, CutchogueNY 11935 Rhone: 631-734-5800 Fax: 631-734-7463 MEMORANDUM DATE: May 4,2006 TO: Lauren -Trustees FROM: Jim Fitzgerald SUBJECT: Kram; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Here.are 3 copies of the plan the Trustees approved at the 3/22/06 meeting. Please calculate the permit fee and let me know. la M AY - 8 2005 f iP[a-n View & Hydrographic Data Prepared for Lot# 134 1" =30' 'Cedar Beach Park' Applicant: Steven Kram SCT# 1000-90-1-2 " Town:: Southold C@ 6'PS dq w e Suffolk County, NY 48�3,. �d r s°nth�es�ress S Surveyed: 01-19-06 6Q� A 7a N es oroP°. Amended:01-24-06 Lp o j r779 Aq'!Octs 02-27-06,03-11-06 J3 �` o �7 �tQr7`te 04-04-06, 04-10-06 c7 O 0 Datum: Low Water o CND y io �ry s 0 61 x2�ea • 1/0 u Fc - � k �C '- -;—----L , 7 lk Dock, / a Ramp & -0.4 1 / c i�o/q�q �7S Float -ti" Sk / G I- it ! •/Q > -1 , \ ♦ Cr 04) MAY - 8 20 ' bq °U De • i... _...... ..... .. .._..v... 3S b s�a0 `fie on r{� F70, Ste s4 xS, - g, to LW / Fake Section 1° = 20' Pro osed All hardware P galvanized Proposed Dock 4'x 50' All materials from 6'wide 3.5'abv.gr. approved list ramp steps to LW Float ---------------------- _ Proposed -- _-__ 6'x 15' Gazebo _ __ _ ________4 SEA LEVEL 10'x12' Ed e of �� ---- _ MAPPING --- - - ------- Wet ands ed e - ---- --------- PO BOX#53B delineated o 8" dia. exist. bttm. RIVERHEAD,NY bu R.Fox bank ppiles I-H-06 ll' or_ 631-722-3390 4/102oob 0.45.33PM G.\SLMWamK-4.pro kI r - r_ _ 10/09/2008 11 '. 45 L James F.King,President *QF SO(/�y Town Ha11 Jill M.Doherty,Vice-President ��� ��� 53095 Route 25 Peggy A.Dickerson P.O.Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen Bob Ghosio,Jr. �O Telephone(631) 765-1892 ZPI AMUNT`I,� Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD December 12, 2007 Patricia C. Moore, Esq. 51020 Main Rd. Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DR., SOUTHOLD SCTM#90-1-2 Dear Ms. Moore: The Board of Town Trustees took the following action during its regular meeting held on Wed., December 12, 2007 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of SHIRELY KRAM applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of Chapter 97 (now 275) of the Southold Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated February 28, 2006, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council and to the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coordinator for their findings and recommendations, and, WHEREAS, the LWRP Coordinator recommended that the proposed application for the construction of a gazebo and deck be found Inconsistent with the LWRP, and, the proposed dock, ramp, and float be found Consistent, with the LWRP, and, WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has furthered Policies 6, 9.4,10.3 &10.4 of the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program to the greatest extent practical through the imposition of the following Best Management Practice requirements: increase in the setback of the proposed gazebo to 25', the use of grated materials for the launching ramp and the docking facility, and, j2 2 WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on March 22, 2006, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 97 (now 275) of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, WHEREAS, that for the mitigating factors and based upon the Best Management Practice requirements imposed above, the Board of Trustees deemed the action to be Consistent with the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pursuant to Chapter 268-5 of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, that the Board of Trustees approved the application of SHIRELY KRAM to construct a fixed open walkway 4'X 30', hinged ramp 3'X 14', floating dock 6'X 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure the float; construct a launching ramp approx. one-foot high made of fiberglass or other aluminum grating system to allow vegetation to grow through; a 6'X 14' ramp with a 4'X 6' platform at the landward end; construct a gazebo 25' setback from the landward edge of the dock; and to clear a 20'X 20' area for off-street parking, all subject to receiving revised plans depicting the new description; and, WHEREAS, the construction of docking facility commenced without the benefit of the submission of the revised plans and issuance of a Wetland Permit by the Board of Trustees, and a violation was issued to the property owner on or about April 2, 2007, and, thereafter a substitution was made and the case was adjudicated against Benali, LLC, and, WHEREAS, Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of SHIRELY KRAM applied to the Southold Town Trustees for an Amendment to the Resolution of March 22, 2006 under the provisions of Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated November 7, 2007, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council and to the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coordinator for their findings and recommendations, and, 3 3 WHEREAS, the LWRP Coordinator recommended that the proposed application for the reconfiguration of the existing docking facility be found Inconsistent with the LWRP, and, WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has furthered Policy 6.3 of the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program to the greatest extent practical through the imposition of the following Best Management Practice requirements: the reduction of length of the existing 4'X 50' dock, the use of open-grate construction materials, and a restoration of the marsh at the landward end of the launching ramp, and, WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on Wed., December 12, 2007, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, WHEREAS, that for the mitigating factors and based upon the Best Management Practice requirements imposed above, the Board of Trustees deemed the action to be Consistent with the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pursuant to Chapter 268-5 of the Southold Town Code, and, NOW THEREFORE BE IT, RESOLVED, that the Southold Town Board of Trustees approve the application of SHIRLEY KRAM to amend the Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to read as follows: Wetland Permit to construct a 4'X 40' open-grate catwalk with a 6'X 20' floating dock at the seaward end held in place by two(2)—2" metal pipes and with a ladder down to the float; install a launching rail on the east side of the dock, 3 W X 27' long with approx. four (4) cross-members holding it; construct a gazebo or storage shed less than 100 sq. ft. located 25' landward of the end of the fixed catwalk, in a northwesterly direction, install a 20'X 20' parking area 30' landward of the landward end of the catwalk, and to restore and replant the marsh area at the landward end of the launching ramp. All work must be done in accordance with the plans prepared by Proper-T Permit Services last dated March 3, 2008. 4 4 Permit to construct and complete project will expire two years from the date the permit is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Inspections are required at a fee of$50.00 per inspection. (See attached schedule.) Fees: $674.00 Very truly yours, James . King, Preside Board of Trustees JFK:Ims (Revised 12/1/08)` Cc: Lori Hulse, Assistant Town Attorney James F. King,President %qf SO!/r Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`0 �� 53095 Route 25 P.O.Box 1179 Peggy A.Dickerson l Southold, New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen N ,e Bob Ghosio,Jr. �Q Telephone(631) 765-1892 Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 15, 2008 Patricia C. Moore, Esq. 51020 Main Rd. Southold, NY 11971 RE: BENALI, LLC 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DR., SOUTHOLD SCTM#90-1-2 Dear Ms. Moore: The following action was taken at the Southold Town Board of Trustees Regular Meeting held on Wed., October 15, 2008: RESOLVED, that the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVES the request for a Transfer of Wetland Permit#6325 from Shirley Kram to Benali, LLC, as issued on December 12, 2007. If you have any questions, please contact our office at (631) 765-1892. Sincerely, Jame . King President, Board of Trustees JFK:Ims i James F. King,President V��OF S�Ury� Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`O l0 53095 Route 25 Peggy A.Dickerson P.O. Box 1179Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G Bob Ghosio, Jr. Telephone(631) 765-1892 Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD YOU ARE REQUIRED TO CONTACT THE OFFICE OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES 72 HOURS PRIOR TO COMMENCEMENT OF THE WORK, TO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT FOR A PRE-CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION. FAILURE TO DO SO SHALL BE CONSIDERED A VIOLATION AND POSSIBLE REVOCATION OF THE PERMIT. INSPECTION SCHEDULE Pre-construction, hay bale line 1 st day of construction '/z constructed Project complete, compliance inspectio . ;pl q((X bOT .- ?"Fi r♦r'i•.. ii�•�-,"-. _ N ,< ♦T�t•", ,,��-Yiis.'.,. -. _ sR _ - i'r` .,...r, i��.+ 1r/ , '`Q ( 1 �i..� ,aq.�+ 1°I° Y �.�.. v .i�111� 1//�: +' r r`i' � - ,l •ig /s• Q+f (r��,I v 0 £S f f•+r BOARD OF SOUTHOLD TOWN TRUSTEES rr SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK ,3 PERMIT NO. 6325 DATE: December 12, 2007 +►..� -` r ++' ISSUED TO: SHIRLEY KRAM si PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DR., SOUTHOLD \ r a � Jfu _mot SCTM#90-1-2 AUTHORIZATION Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 275 and/or Chapter 111 of the Town Code of the Town of 4 Southold and in accordance with the Resolution of the Board of Trustees adopted at the meeting held on December 12,2007 in consideration of application fee in the sum of$250.00 paid by Shirley Kram and subject t +0:�• `. the Terms and Conditions as stated in the Resolution,the Southold Town Board of Trustees authorizes and perm. the following: Wetland Permit to construct a 4 X 40 open-grate catwalk with a 6 X 20 floating } dock at the seaward end held in place by two (2)—2" metal pipes and with a ladder dowin ' to the float; install a launching rail on the east side of the dock, 3 %Z' X 27' long with approx. four (4) cross-members holding it; construct a gazebo or storage shed less than 100 sq. ft. located 25' landward of the end of the fixed catwalk, in a northwesterly direction, install a 201X 20' parking area 30' landward of the landward end of the catwalk and to restore and replant the marsh area at the landward end of the launching ramp.All work must be done in accordance with the plans prepared by Proper-T Permi I :sale Services last dated March 3, 2008. y eff IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the said Board of Trustees hereby causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, Iand these presents to be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of this date. t r `. } 01) �Ilff � p•�� �:�I,lr°I,1°N`L'1'. 'f. :, ✓�./r/i♦ a,._ � .;4/.Isl+rl�tir.'k ii�: �.�i+i. ��r/ ,/mod\ ,II /�iit"-a - /S 1�i��`'�` n, TERMS AND CONDITIONS The Permittee, Shirely Kram, c/o 140 East 8 1"st.,NY,NY 10028, as part of the consideration for the issuance of the Permit does understand and prescribe to the following: 1. That the said Board of Trustees and the Town of Southold are released from any and all damages, or claims for damages, of suits arising directly or indirectly as a result of any operation performed pursuant to this permit, and the said Permittee will, at his or her own expense, defend any and all such suits initiated by third parties, and the said Permittee assumes full liability with respect thereto,to the complete exclusion of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold. .2. That this Permit is valid for a period of 24 months, which is considered to be the estimated time required to complete the work involved,but should circumstances warrant,request for an extension may be made to the Board at a later date. 3. That this Permit should be retained indefinitely, or as long as the said Permittee wishes to maintain the structure or project involved,to provide evidence to anyone concerned that authorization was originally obtained. 4. That the work involved will be subject to the inspection and approval of the Board or its agents, and non-compliance with the provisions of the originating application may be cause for revocation of this Permit by resolution of the said Board. 5. That there will be no unreasonable interference with navigation as a result of the work herein authorized. 6. That there shall be no interference with the right of the public to pass and repass along the beach between high and low water marks. 7. That if future operations of the Town of Southold require the removal and/or alterations in the location of the work herein authorized, or if,in the opinion of the Board of Trustees, the work shall cause unreasonable obstruction to free navigation,the said Permittee will be required,upon due notice,to remove or alter this work project herein stated without expenses to the Town of Southold. 8. The Permittee is required to provide evidence that a copy of this Trustee permit has been recorded with the Suffolk County Department of Real Properties Office as a notice covenant and deed restriction to the deed of the subject parcel. Such evidence shall be provided within ninety(90) calendar days of issuance of this permit. 9. That the said Board will be notified by the Permittee of the completion of the work authorized. 10. That the Permittee will obtain all other permits and consents that may be required supplemental to this permit,which may be subject to revoke upon failure to obtain same. James F.King, President ��OF S0VJyO Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`O l0 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Peggy A.Dickerson Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G Bob Ghosio,Jr. Telephone(631)765-1892 Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES December 12, 2007 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Patricia C. Moore, Esq. 51020 Main Rd. Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DR., SOUTHOLD SCTM#90-1-2 Dear Ms. Moore: The Board of Town Trustees took the following action during its regular meeting-held on Wed., December 12, 2007 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of SHIRELY KRAM applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of Chapter 97 (now 275) of the Southold Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated February 28, 2006, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council and to the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coordinator for their findings and recommendations, and, WHEREAS, the LWRP Coordinator recommended that the proposed application for the construction of a gazebo and deck be found Inconsistent with the LWRP, and, the proposed dock, ramp, and float be found Consistent, with the LWRP, and, WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has furthered Policies 6; 9.4,10.3 &10.4 of the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program to the greatest extent practical through the imposition of the following Best Management Practice requirements: increase in the setback of the proposed gazebo to 25', the use of grated materials for the launching ramp and the docking facility, and, r , 2 2 WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on March 22, 2006, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 97 (now 275) of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, WHEREAS, that for the mitigating factors and based upon the Best Management Practice requirements imposed above, the Board of Trustees deemed the action to be Consistent with the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pursuant to Chapter 268-5 of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, that the Board of Trustees approved the application of SHIRELY KRAM to construct a fixed open walkway 4'X 30', hinged ramp 3'X 14', floating dock 6'X 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure the float; construct a launching ramp approx. one-foot high made of fiberglass or other aluminum grating system to allow vegetation to grow through; a 6'X 14' ramp with a 4'X 6' platform at the landward end; construct a gazebo 25' setback from the landward edge of the dock; and to clear a 20'X 20' area for off-street parking, all subject to receiving revised plans depicting the new description; and, WHEREAS, the construction of docking facility commenced without the benefit of the submission of the revised plans and issuance of a Wetland Permit by the Board of Trustees, and a violation was issued to the property owner on or about April 2, 2007, and, WHEREAS, Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of SHIRELY KRAM applied to the Southold Town Trustees for an Amendment to the Resolution of March 22, 2006 under the provisions of Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated November 7, 2007, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council and to the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coordinator for their findings and recommendations, and, 3 3 WHEREAS, the LWRP Coordinator recommended that the proposed application for the 'reconfiguration of the existing docking facility be found Inconsistent with the LWRP, and, WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has furthered Policy 6.3 of the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program to the greatest extent practical through the imposition of the following Best Management Practice requirements: the reduction of length of the existing 4'X 50' dock, the use of open-grate construction materials, and a restoration of the marsh at the landward end of the launching ramp, and, WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on Wed., December 12, 2007, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, WHEREAS, that for the mitigating factors and based upon the Best Management Practice requirements imposed above, the Board of Trustees deemed the action to be Consistent with the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pursuant to Chapter 268-5 of the Southold Town Code, and, NOW THEREFORE BE IT, RESOLVED, that;the Southold Town Board of Trustees approve the application of SHIRLEY KRAM to amend the Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to read as follows: Wetland Permit to construct a 4'X 40' open-grate catwalk with a 6'X 20' floating dock at the seaward end held in place by two(2) —2" metal pipes and with a ladder down to the float; install a launching rail on the east side of the dock, 3 Y2' X 27' long with approx. four (4) cross-members holding it; construct a gazebo or storage shed less than 100 sq. ft. located 25' landward of the end of the fixed catwalk, in a northwesterly direction, install a 20'X 20' parking area 30' landward of the landward end of the catwalk, and to restore and replant the marsh area at the landward end of the launching ramp. All work must be done in accordance with the plans prepared by Proper-T Permit Services last dated March 3, 2008. Permit to construct and complete project will expire two years from the date the permit is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Inspections are required at a fee of $50.00 per inspection. (See attached schedule.) Fees: $674.00 Very truly yours, Ja s F. King, Presi nt Board of Trustees JFK:Ims James F. King, President ' Of S�(/Ty Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,�0� Ol0 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Peggy A. Dickerson l Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G Q Bob Ghosio,Jr. ��ly� �O Telephone(631)765-1892 04UNT1, Fax(631)765-6641 � BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES t� TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: _' h c1)(,t,�.� k 14 rn Please be advised that your application dated r7 /0') has been reviewed by this Board at the regular meeting of /a-/ i. / of) and your application has been approved pending the completion of the following items checked off below. Revised Plans for proposed project Pre-Construction Hay Bale Line Inspection Fee ($50.00) 1st Day of Construction ($50.00) '/2 Constructed ($50.00) Final Inspection Fee ($50.00) f Dock Fees ($3.00 per sq. ft.) Permit fees are now due. Please make check or money order payable to Town of Southold. The fee is computed below according to the schedule of rates as set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code. The following fee must be paid within 90 days or re-application fees will be necessary. You will receive your permit upon completion of the above. COMPUTATION OF PERMIT FEES: 6int&xLft -' (e w Ova of- Woco; /ao`X -t,360,00 TOTAL FEES DUE: $ 6 ,�y, QD BY: James F. King, President Board of Trustees James F. King,President ��OF SO�Tyo Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,�O l0 53095 Route 25 Peggy A.Dickerson [ P.O.Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G Bob Ghosio,Jr. �Oly� �Q Telephone(631)765-1592 cOU Fax(631) 765-6641 NTY,� BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Please be advised that your application dated %//76a� has been reviewed by this Board at the regular meeting of Mild-1 Y7 and your application has been approved pending the completion of the following items checked off below. V/ Revised Plans for proposed project Pre-Construction Hay Bale Line Inspection Fee ($50.00) 1st Day of Construction ($50.00) Y2 Constructed ($50.00) Final Inspection Fee ($50.00) Dock Fees ($3.00 per sq. ft.) 'to ae- &4-0-fml�Wd upbq rTcei0} O� re o e& p la(6 . Permit fees are now due. Please make check or money order payable to Town of Southold. The fee is computed below according to the schedule of rates as set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code. The following fee must be paid within 90 days or re-application fees will be necessary. You will receive your permit upon completion of the above. COMPUTATION OF PERMIT FEES: �600A Mbpec Ce e--�Sb,0o TOTAL FEES DUE: $ 01 O BY:. James F. King, President Board of Trustees O��gUFFO(,�.c4 �� Gy Donald Wilder,Chairman y Town Hall,53095 Main Rd. Lauren Standish,Secretary o P.O.Box 1179 • Southold,NY 11971 Telephone(631)765-1892 Qla Fax(631)765-6641 Conservation Advisory Council Town of Southold At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Wed., December 5, 2007, the following recommendation was made: Moved by James Eckert, seconded by Jack McGreevy, it was RESOLVED to PROVIDE NO RECOMMENDATION to the application of SHIRLEY KRAM to Amend Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to reconfigure the proposed docking facility. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 Inspected by: Glen McNab, Don Wilder Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion Carried 0 James F.King,President �f S01j)'. Town Hall Jill M.Doherty,Vice-President �O l� 53095 Route 25 Peggy A.Dickerson P.O. Box 1179 Dave Bergen G � Southold, New York 11971-0959 Bob Ghosio,Jr. �` �O� Telephone(631) 765-1892 Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Work session Report Date/Time: SHIRLEY KRAM requests an Amendment to Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to reconfigure the proposed docking facility. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 Me of area to be impacted: altwater Wetland Freshwater Wetland _Sound Bay Distance of proposed work to edge of above: P,kt of Town Code proposed work falls under: V—Chapt.275 Chapt. 111 _other Type of Application: v Wetland Coastal Erosion Amendment Administrative yl� pP — — — _Emergency Pre-Submission Violation Planning Info needed: Modifications: Conditions: Present Were: _J.King _J.Doherty—P.Dickerson D. Bergen B. Ghosio, Jr H. Cusack D. Dzenkowski_Mark Terry other Form filled out in the field by Mailed/Faxed to: Date: Environmental Technician Review 11/20/2007 10:56 6314e " 72 PAGE 02 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Ad& Division of Fish, Wiidiife & Marine Resources, Region One HAMM Protection deft/ SUNY @ Stony Brook, 50 Circle Road, Stony Brook, New York 117 90-3409 Phone: (631) 444-0295 FAX., (631) 444-0297 ANxander 8.Grmw& C�nlaatoner N of Viitabtiion 5/10/2DO7 Steve Kirain ,B+enali, LLC 11499 Bellagio Road Los Angeles, CA. 90049 Date of Violation: On or before 4/3/2007 Location of Violation: 1275 Cedar Point Wive West, Southold 'fax Map W# 1000 - 90- 1 -, 12 Pern)it# (if applicable): 1-4738-02841/00002 Dear Sir/Madam: Records of this Aepartm nt indicate that you are in violation of the Environmental Conservation Law (ECL): X Article 15, Protection of Navigable Waters Section 15-0505.1 6NYCRR Part 608 F1Article 15, Wild, Scenic and Recreational Rivers Act Section 15-2709.2 6NYCRR Part 666 Article 13, Protection of Marine Waters Sections 13-0345.2 Article 17, Prohibition Against Pollution of Marine Waters F-I Section 17-0503.2 Article 24, Freshwater Wetlands Act Section 24-0701.1 6NYCRR Part 662 EArticle 25, Tidal Wetlands Act Section 25.0401.1 6NYCRR Part 661 In than you caused., or Wrmitted to be caused: Installation of a 19' x 30' parking area in excess of the approved 20' x 20' parking area; Placernent of unclean fill including ashpalt in the parking area without Page 1. 11/20/2007 10:56 6314, - -"72 PAGE 03 benefit of permit; Non compliance with General Condition#9: Installation of 8"piles which are in excess of the approved 6"piles for this project. Dion Compliance with Special Condition 42: Cleating of wetland and adjacent area vegetation occured seaward of the'proposed shed and parking area; Contravention of thais/dwse Article(s)of the ECG,is a violation and/or a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of no more than$10,000 per violation. Penalties maybe assessed for each day that the violation continues. Please be fuitber advised that violations of the ECL which are not resolved may be the subject of an administrative hearing pursuant to Title 6 of the Official Compilation of Codes,Rules&Regulations of the State of New York(6NYCRR,Part 622). You are hereby advised to cease your oge ation at the referenced location immediately. Please contact the following office within thirty(30)days of receipt of this letter,so that we may attempt to resolve this matter. ]Failure to contact this office within this time period will result in this matter being referred to the Department's Regional Attorney for further enforcement action. To schedule an appointment for a compliance conference in this matter,please contact The Compliance Unit at(631)444-0295. Compliance conferences will be hold with the Regional Manager of Marine Habitat Protection. Very truly you, Charles T.Hamilton Regional Supervisor Natural Resources Region 1 cc: ECO Enright,pakrieta More *My Certified Mail# NOV#07CTH129 Page 2. r-- I� t 1 `l + C q--D �IPAtar, � �U VO 39dd ZLZOPPOTE9 99:01 L00Z/0Z/ZZ New York State Department of Environmental Conservatlon Office of Natural Resources, Region One Am Building 40 - SUNY, Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 9 Phone: (631) 444-0295 FAX: (631) 444-0297 RECORD OF INSP_r;9TION Project Name: Contractor: •�.• Address. Phone: COO 8$1 17Y� Permit: Yes ✓ No Consent Order:Yes No Tax - Permit#. <-l:z S�'i - Yl /r�r�Z, Case# NOV# ECL 25-0401.1 Tidal Wetlands Diagram ECL 15-0505.1 Protection of Navigable Waters ECL 13-0345.2 Protection of Marine Waters 6NYCRR 608.7 Water Quality Certification aC f! ECL 15-2709.2 Wild Scenic Rivers ECL 24-0701.1 Fresh Water Wetlands ECL 17-0503.2 Pollution of Marine Waters Project Description: AS�n,&Q f-7L , 3y" l GI d a I tre W a2=1 j ewe a Eleld Repg Date: 1 � / Time: 'I 1 Inspector: Cn4n, 60 ECO: Project Progress: Started Completed Not Started Other CornMentS/Observations; n .? o00 - .- Project Status: In Compliance-. Non-Compliance:. „^ r� Sketch Made:Yes_ No-- Photos Taken: Yes "- No 3 Persons interviewed at ite: Acknowledgment of Receipt µy C �S I hereby acknowledge receipt of this inspection �� -- Signature: -- Y Name: Address: If oroiect is in non-compliance. contact The Region One Office of Marine Habitat Protection, at(631 44-0295 63 � to discuss this situation. Contravention of Article 15, 24 and 25 of the ECL is a violation and/or a misdemeanor and is punishable by fines of not more than Five thousand($5,000), Six thousand ($6,000) and Ten thousand ($10,000) Dollars per violation per day respectively. Note: This record of inspection has been completed pursuant to an Inspection of only the activities listed above and is not an indication that there are no additional violations of the ECL.at this site. i .. 765-1802 BUILDING DEFT. INSPECTION [ ] FOUNDATION iST [ PGFf LBG. [ ] FOUNDATION 2N [ ] INSULATION [ ] FRAMIN [ ] FINAL [ EPLACE & CHIMNEY REMARKS- DATE �� U� INSPECTOR Town of Southold Town of Southold ` A_ 5 213 Suffolk County, NY A` 5 212 Suffolk County,NY The People of the State of New York vs. The People of the State of New York vs. /LAST NAME(DEFENDANT)) FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL r(✓4Cw/wv�/?1/��F. `/ /�vr� /J®�`_ ST NAME(DEFENDANT) FIRST NAM�J MIDDLE INITIAL STREET ADDRESS ,, O- /�IGy7IT7 ��ru4 LT APT.NO. STREET ADDRESS f APT.NS ' CRY STATE c ZIP Gov �1G I� N"` !11? 7 1 CITY e UnQ /� STATE �/ Z/ LICENSE OR REGISTRATION NUMBER LICENSE OR REGISTRATION NUMBER 7 STATE TYPE OF LICENSE DATE EXPIRES SEX DATE OF BIRTH OPERATOR STATE TYPE OF UCENSE - DATE EXPIRES SEX DATE OF BIRTH MONTH DAY YEAR OWN VEHICLE MONTH DAY YEAR �DPERATOR VEHICLE ES ❑NO OYES ❑NO THE OPERATOR OR REGISTERED OWNER OF VEHICLE DESCRIBED RELO THE OPERATOR OR REGISTERED OWNER OF VEHICLE DESCRIBED BELOW PLATE NO. DATE EXPIRES PLATE NO. DATE EXPIRES STATE PLATE TYP STATE PLATE TYPE ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. ❑ ❑P ❑COMM ❑ ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. ❑ ❑PASS ❑COMM ❑ VEHICLE MAKE ❑ DODGE VEHICLE MAKE ❑ DODGE ❑ BUICK ❑ CHEV ❑ CADILLAC ❑ PONTIAC ❑ BUICK ❑ CHEV ❑ ILLAC ❑ PONTIAC ❑ FORD ❑ S ❑ PLYM ❑ FORD ❑ OLDS PLYM ❑ TOYOTA VOLKS ❑ ❑ TOYOTA ❑ VOLKS ❑ BODY 2 DR ❑ 4 DR ❑ BUS ❑ MCY ❑ S.W. BODY ❑ 2 DR ❑ 0.DR ❑ BUS ❑ MCY ❑ S.W. TYPE ❑ TRUCK ❑ TRAILER ❑ VAN ❑ TYPE ❑ K ❑ TRAILER ❑ VAN ❑ >NJ6MBER — VIN NUMBE THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS CHARGED AS FOLLOWS THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS CHARGED AS FOLLOWS PLACE OF OCCURRE CE PC PLACE OF OCCURRENCE PCT DAY OF OFFENSE AM E PM GTY,TOWN,VILLAGE,OR LET SUFFOLK COUNTY NY DATE OF FFE BE AM ME PM CITY,TOWN,VILLAGE, R HAMLET SUFFOLK COUNTY NY G� z, apt ® aa 11 S'��,�,! y�z o7 off 11'rN o /�✓ fA L VIOLATION OF SECTION BUBO. OF THE❑VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK IN VIOLATION OF SECTION SUED. OF THE❑VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK C/3F C ❑O ER(SPECIFY) / ❑O.S. ❑COM ❑BUS ❑HAZ DEF VEH MAT ❑OTHER SPECIFY) ❑O.S. ❑COM ❑BUS ❑HAZ o.= V ✓ T� �'f�i DEF VEH MAT o a 9 ❑ SPEEDING OTHER O��E ❑ SPEEDING OTHER OFFENSE/J 'n p, MPH IN A MPH ZONE �/Y,] IS O ❑ MPH IN A MPH ZONE /yV/ �6�rir/ MISDEMEANOR❑ Ho t� w m IV FACTU PART(NOT FOR TVB) CD � 1 FACTUAL PART(NOT FOR TVB) OO THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANT DID ON THE STATED DATE,TIME AND PLACE L AS NAM D DEFENDANT ID ON THE STATETE,TIME PLACE S` �lvo `-VE/tY {,,(y^✓ Cy � Vc7f3 �/' O� 015A F e rh The Foregoing,',¢basedX(Pe nal knowlledge)and/or(in source being the attached sworn depOSRion(s)of The Foregoing is based on(personal knowledge)and/or i ein the eRecha sworn a osition s of dated CT'1 w.nl (� �L/�"' dated - / ` PARKING SCHEDULED FINE CONTACT COURT❑ P--ARRKINGG SCHEDULED--���FIINE$ CONTACT COURT❑ THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS SUMMONED TO APPEAR AT THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS SUMMONED TO APPEAR AT SOUTHOLD TOWN JUSTICE COURT,63095 ROUTE 26.SOUTHOLD,NY 11971 SOUTHOLD TOWN JUSTICE COURT,53095 ROUTE 25,SOUTHOLD,NY 11971 ON DATEOFAPPEARANCE(NOTFORTVB) f1!� DATE OFAPPEARANIICE(N^O'T�FOR NB) AT �' �iA mM ON AT 'Cr- APR 18 2007 Town of Southold A 317® Suffolk County,NY The People of the State of_New York vs. LAST NAME(D ENDANT) FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL C o w/tom =9ou STREET ADDRESS APT.NO. CITY T STATE /�1ZIP ✓ - { LICENSE OR REGISTRATION NUMBER STATE TYPE OF LICENSE DATE EXPIRES SEX DATE OF BIRTH OPERATOR MLCI$ OWNS VEHICLE (j � ❑YES ONO . Oki THE OPERATOR OR REGISTERED OWNER OF VEHICLE DESCRIBED BELOW PLATE NO. - DATE IRES STATE PLATE TYPE _ ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. ❑N.Y. ❑N.J. 0 ❑PASS ❑COMM VEHICLE MAKE ❑ DODGE BUICK ❑ CHEV CADILLAC ❑ ' PONTIAC ❑ FORD ❑ OLDS ❑ PLYM ❑ TOYOTA ❑ LKS ❑ BODY ❑ ❑ 4DR ❑ BUS ❑ MCY. ❑ S.W. TYPE TRUCK ❑ TRAILER ❑ VAN- .-❑ f _ VIN:71ilr THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE_IS CHARGED AS FOLLOWS - -PLACE OF OCCURRENCE . ?CT I, 12'!S�✓Cam" A57 2 '50 0 DATE O SE TIME PM CITY,T VIL�Lk E.p R HAV SUFFOLK COUNTY NY IN LATI N OF SECTION SUBD. OF THE❑VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK ❑OTHER(SPECIFY) ❑O.S. ❑COM ❑T10:1 HAZ TG S DEF VEHMAT ❑ SPEEDING OTHER OgFgNSE f MPH IN A ' MPH ZONE- /V /a�j. MISDEMEAN FACTUAL PART(NOT FOR TVB) - THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANT DID ON THE STATfD DATE,TIME AND PLACE �Ti�-vE�' GU O tl The Fomgoing Is based on(personal knowledge)and/or 1p� aoauaaCai wom � dap sdion(s)of ' PARKING SCHEDULED FINE$ CONTACT COURT❑ THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS SUMMONED TO APPEAR AT SOUTHOLD TOWN JUSTICE COURT,53095 ROUTE 25,SOUTHOLD,NY 11971 ON DATE OFAPPEAR�A/N�CEE(NOT FOR TVB) AT JU �—M iFALSE STATEMENTS HEREIN ARE PUNISHABLE AS A CLASS A MISDEMEANOR PURSUANT TO SECTION 210.45 OF THE P.LN.Y.S. COMPLAINANT - DATE i167 BADGE k OURT COPY L APR 8 2007. ;Towq,of Southold A 3171 Suffolk County, NY The People of the State of New York LAST DEFENDANT) FIRST ; _, MIDDLE INITIAL rl"i ,. , . STREET ADDRESS 1 _•—�"�-����+ APT:NO. _ / 1L1�-gi�5 CITY-_•_./'�`_ __ - ✓ _ - -. .. _ .•' ZIP - ('- -- - -- --' ,LICENSE OR REGISTRATION NUMBEfl—: - STATE TYPE OF LICENSE DATE EXPIRES SIX DATE OF BIRTH OPERATOR ,. - -,. :- : - OYES"❑NO - _ THE OPERATOR OR REGISTERED OWNER OF VEHICLE DESCRIBED BELOW DATE EXPIRES - . STATE YPE _ ❑N.Y ❑N.J. ❑N.Y. ❑N J. ❑ ❑COMM El ~- - VEHICLE MAKE DODGE - ,:.❑ - -BUICK-_..-.,.._.... ❑ _...CHEV--r!]L]A FORD cl CAD, ❑ OLDS 0.- ❑. •YOLKS ..,., BODY ❑ .2 DR 4DR ❑ BUS` •❑�MCY .' �..k❑�S.W. -TYPE - ❑: ....-.,.❑ TRAILER -,_.':❑..VAN,_,-'_.'❑_...--:.>--. -YIN NU ____............._..._.__i.. THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS CHARGED AS FOLLOWS - , PLACE OF OCCURRENCE , PCT DATED OFF NSE_. TIMET]: ITY ,VILAGE:ORHWLET SUFFOLK000NTYNY7 n 13 I O ON OF SECTION SUBD. OF THE❑VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK ER-(SPECIFIC t0 O.S. ❑COM El BUS ❑HAZ SPEEDING.�. ❑ MPH INA '':-;MPH ZONE. O�OFF NSE.) ��L�d Sv . 'FACTUAL PART(NOT FOR TVB) J THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANT'DID ON THE STATED DATE,TIME AND PLACE V low uC c.� The Foregoing is based on(personal krowledge)en .- :dated. - PARKING SCHEDULED FINE S -. ..CONTACT COURT THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS SUMMONED TO APPEAR AT •• SOUTHOLD TOWN JUSTICE COURT,0095 ROUTE 25.SOUTHOLD,NY 11971 • OFAPPMRANCE(NOT FORTVB) ON /s� O 7 . FALSE STATEMENTS HEREIN ARE PUNISHABLE AS A CLASS A MISDEMEANOR PURSUANT TO SECTION 210.4'OF THE P.CN.Y:S. COMPLAINANT DATE - BADGE# ' OURT� COPY' fa fihr7,a, p�ti� .11/Z'1/G1JUU 1U;J.1 rAA*J1U ZU0 1440. l•U1YLG1Y1 rAAliY81(7 LLl• WJVUo Nov 25 06 01 :45p P• � NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION DEC P5111MIT NUMBER EFFECTIVE DATE 1�738-Q2841/00002 i T November 2006 FACILITYIPROGRAM NUMBER($) PERMIT EXPIRATION DATE(S) Under theEnvironmental 50 November 2011 Conservation Law TYPE OF.F'ERMIT■Now ❑Renewal O Modification❑Permit to Construct ❑Permit to 0 rate ❑Article 15,TIUe 5:Protection of Waters ❑ Article 17,Till es 7,8:SPDES ❑ Adicl9 27.Tide 9: 6NYCRR 373: Hazardous waste Management ❑ Article 15.Title 10:Water Supply n Article 19-Air Pnllution Control ❑ ArtiCJE 34:Coastal Erosion ❑ Article 15,Title 15:Water Transport 0 Article 23,Title 27,Mined Land Management Reclamation 0 Artiva 15.Title 15_Long Island Wells ❑ Article 36:Roodplain Maregernent 0 Adicle24:Freshwater Wetlands ❑ Article 15,Title 27: Wild,Scenic and ❑ Articles 1,3,17,19, 27,37;6NYCRR Recreational Rivers m Article 25:Tidal Wetlands 380:Radiation Oonlrol O 6NYCRR 608:Water Quality Cur tifica- ❑ Arxiola 27.Title 7: 6NYCRR 360: lion Solid vf68te Man2Q=&nt PERMIT ISSUED TO TELEPHONE NUMBER Shirle W&S Ktam 212-$05 8315 ADDRESS OF PERMITTEE 140 East 81°Street,New York NY 10020. CONTACT PERSON FOR PERMITTED WORK TELEPHONE NUMBER James E.Fib Gerald,Jr..Pro r-T Permit Services.PO Box617.Cutchogue NY 11935-0617 631-734-5800 NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROJECTIFACILITY Krarn Prop",1275 West Cedar Point Urive,Southold LOCATION OF PROJECT/FACILITY SCTM:100D-09O.01 A2 COUNTY 70UVN WATERCOURSE NYTM COORDINATES Suffolk TSouthold West Lake E: N: DESCRIPTION OF AUTHORIZED ACTIVITY Construct a Catwalk using open-grate material measuring approximately 4 feet wide by 50 feet long_ Install a floating dock at the seaward end of the catwalk measuring 5 feet by 10 feet, Install launching rails that shall be spaced 3.5 Feet apart That shall measure 27 feet long. Creete a 20 foot by 20 foot pervioUs parking area and install a 7 foot by 14 foot structure that shall function Cither as a gazebo or Storage shed. All work is to be done in accordance with the attached plans stamped NYSDEC approved. 9y atcepiance:of this permit,the permittee agrees ftt the permll Is contingent upon strict cornpltanre with the ECL,all applicable regulations,the General Conditions specified(see page 2 13 3)and any Special Conditions included as part of this permit. PERMITADMIN15TRATOR: (KSWI ADDRESS George W.Hamn+arth, Region 1 Headctuarter- Deputy PermitAdminslralor Sld..#4o,SUNY,stxy Brook,NY 11790-Z356 AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE DATE �w f_,5 Page i of 4 APR - 2 2007 cN - o a PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED �• DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN ORATE � DECKING AND 6-DIAMETER FILES LA,ODER 2.'-2.5'WIDE A"1TECHED � j TO DOCK FOR ACCESS'D}FLOAT SEAWARD END OF LAUNCH.IDlG RAILS; t � LANDWARD END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; 27 LONG OVERALL rnro PAILS 2X LUMBER 014 EDGE SPACED 3-5'± / APN4 T,OR FLIIdCTIOML EQUIVALENT FLOAT'S X 10'SI_CURED AT END OF.DOCK 13Y1W06" d.PILES OR 2'METAL PIP ES. c-1 HIGH WATER z H EDGE OF WCTLAiJDS;BY "75 7 ¢ _ `fit ---ti LOFW WATER R.FOX, 1199Yt16 SPRING �I � n lJ. r�.. . - NIGf•{WA.TCf; EDGE OF BANK � ,��h �¢�~Pn' r ' r n ALL DIMENSIONAL WNHER, TIMBER AND PILING ARE OF 6.,DIAMETER PILES CCA-TREATED WOOD.ALL 11'±ON CENTER HARDWARE IS 13ALVAN12f_D STEEL.. SCALE IN'= T C.0I el310V>L�tc�r)REMIR DATA REC"E'I(ON VIEIV Altplicat Ion regardil g the properiy of F'PROYECI AS PER j 1'UA.EafISE:•Car�slruct fixed irpeit tM-alkway, hinged Shirlek:i{t'ain,SCPA4#IOOi}-40-1.2 _ AD CONCIITI ON$Ul` ramP Ind floating dock,and two-rnit small crab 'ERMITNCI ° c,; launching ramp for private recrenLional ut osee. RepnrsPnted by �I "Y �� i OUllITZ P P PROPUR-T PEWt UTSERVI(�ES o )A�Tf; DATUM:IvILW � "z --��''� IN"West Lake AT:Sowhold P.U.)lmr 617,( tel�ogue,NY F 1935 COUNTY-gu(Tclk 91ATS:New York Jam E.Fitzgerald,Jr, 516•7-M-5100 �eviscd NoveinUer 3,2ll©6 !- ; r; • r wr J�',�''- (_ Stay\, - 1° = 26N 6 to a 3 8 O / Ile o � r20" oNa o-319 sr s� k�mbere 06 l /6 fly oq 0,7!0i / r°p° / 10, 11 � St ak e f; i SEA LEVEL MAPPING i PO BOX.#538 RIVERHEAD,M 631-722-3390 II/2l/2006 8:38:50AIN G:\SLM\KramWLb.prc 111Z'!/i:UUd 1U.00 rftA1J1U LU6 l�LO- 4V1Y161\1 rnnil\ana LLl YJvua Nov 25 06 01 r 45p 1' ' NEW YORK STATE DIwPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION DEC PERMIT NUMBER EFFECTIVE DATE 14738-02841100002 i T November 2005 FACILITYIPROGRAM NUMBERM PERtl I EXPIRATION DAIE(Sl . Ungleltr�-the EnnArrolnme-kal $0 November 2011 Conservation taw TYPE OF.PERM!T■Now [I Renewal,❑Modification❑Permit to Construct ❑PSrmitio a rate ❑Article 15,Title 5:Protection of Waters ❑ Article 17,Titles 7,8:SPDES ❑ Article 27.Title 9: 6NYCRR 373: Hazardous Waste Management ❑ Article 15.Title 15:Water Supply [1 Arllele 19,Air Pnllutian Control ❑ Artido 34:Coastal Erosion ❑ Article 10,Title 15:WaLerTransport ❑ Article 23,Title 27;Mined Land Management Reclamation 0 Arl.icre 15.Title 15:Long Island Wells ❑ Article 36:Fioodplain Management ❑ Article24:Freshwater Wetlands ❑ Article 15,Title 27: Wild,Scenic and O Arlicles 1,3,17,19, 27,37;6NYCRR Recreational Rivers a Article 25:71dal Wetlands 380:R7diation Conlrol O 6NYCRR 608:Water Quality Ceeiflca- ❑ AMCie 27.rive 7: 6NYCRR 360! lion Solid wes La Management ment PERMIT ISSUED TO 7 TELEPHONE NUMBER ShirleyWahl Kram 212-$t3-�r6315 ADDRESS Of PERMITTEE 140 East 81"Stree6 New York NY 10023. CONTACT PERSON FOR PEI4MITTED WORK TELF�HONE NUIil19ER James E.FitzGaratd.Jr..Pro r-T Permit Services.PO BoxOlT Cutchoque NY 11935-a617 631-734-9800 NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROJECTIFACILITY Kram Property,1275 Wrest Cedar Point Drive,Soulhold LOCATION OF PROJEC7lFACILITY SCTM:1000-090.01-12 COUNTY TOWN LWATERCOURSE NYTM COORDINATES Suffolk SoutholC estL.ake E: N: DESCRIPTION OF AUTHORIZED ACTIVITY Construct a Catwalk using then-griake malerlal measuring approximately 4 feet wide by 50 feet long_ Install a floating dock at the seaward end of the catwalk measuring 5 feet by 10(est. Install launching.rails that shall be spaced 3.5 feet apart that shall measure 27 feet long. Create a 20 fooi by 20 foot perviau's parking area and install a 7 foot by 14 foot slructure that shall function&1hesr as a gazebo or storage shed. All work is to be done in.accordanbe with the attached plans stomped NYSOEC approved_ 5y ataeptancq of this permit,the pel littee agrees firet the permit Is contingent upon swet compliance with rota ECL,atl applicable regulations,the General Conditions specified(see page 2 ri 31 and any Special Conditions included as part oFthis permit, PERMIT ADMINISTRATOR: (KSWI ADDRESS George W.Hammarth, Region 1 Headquarters Deputy PermitAdminsiralor Bid.•940.SUNY,Stony Brook,NY 11790-Z356 AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE DATE ��� Page 1 of 4 I APR - 2 2007 - -- y N� • -CilO a /T� 5 a PROPO-SED LOW-PRDFILE FIXED w _ DOCK 4'X 50'WIThI OPEN t3RATE � DECKING AND 6" JAMETEIZ F'ELFS LADDER 2'-2,5'WIDE A-ITI CHEID c 1 TO DOCK FOR ACCESS To FLOAT N SEAWARD END OF LAUNCH[NIG PAILS; LRFtDV<JARa END OF LAUNCHING RAILS; 2P LONG OVERALL r RAILS 2X LUM13JER Old EDGE SPICED 3-5'± ! APART,OR FLONC71ONAL EQUIVALENT JJ FLOAT'ti'X 10'SI_CURED AT END OF QC1CK 6YIANOW d.PlUES OR 2'METAL PIPES. HIGH WATER z .d EDGE OF WC-TLAtgD5;BY R.FOX, 1119i - `y ---�- —LOW WATER D6 SPRING 1N,. or y tl to f ` HIGH+N,4TCR EDGE OF BANK r ALL DIMENSIONAL LUMBER, 'Wlt t AND PILING ARE OF W DIAMETER PILES COA-TREATED WOOD.ALL 11'±ON CENTER HARDWARE IS GALVANIZED STEEL.. SCALE:90= 1' CO11�'�flIF WER.S DA1�4 ;STCf'I4N VIE V N Y`y U E G Alryilicat Ion regarding Qtie property of f'PROVIEDASPIl rjM Coasicact fixcd open walkway,hinged Sltirley Ximul,SCFM#i(el)-4o.I-2 _ND CONDITIONS OF rRinpnnd(loatingdock and two-rail Mall Bran Repiesented by ID15 'ERMIYNtI Y' 5°�Q�4;t OUl)p 2- launehicg ramp Cor private recreElLional purposes. J�` PROPER-T PEW&T 9E1tVl4,£S DATUM:1v1LW IN:WcsL Lake AT:Santhold P.U.13ox 617,(�tefiogue,NY f 1935 James I Ft f Z � _ COUNT :Sii(Tolk 91ATE:New York �raK yr• 316.7.E 5101) Xeviscd November:3,20U6 stak W E Diagram... s �� �u _ 20 ' � ( 8 o a O% Sri� 2p, es� o� 10 9 g Ar e 6' //- - 06 /� T — CY % o pr � � `� �\ / 0 bps cv � O� Vl l Dock p 4 / \\ �` �0 l St ak i i s \ \ SEA LEVEL MAPPING PO BOX*538 RIVERHEAD,NY 631-722-3390 II/2l/2oo6 8:56:40AM G.\5LM\KromWL&.pro Board of Trustees 77 March 22, 2006 example, what tools are there to go back and assure that the applicant is doing the right thing unless you have a set of. plans and specs. Like putting that pile of material they take out. Okay, it's going to be behind the 1.00 feet so it's out of your jurisdiction, but I'm very concerned, as you mentioned, with the flooding we have in New Suffolk, suppose we,have that pile there, the hay bales are between there and sea, but we get a storm and the runoff starts going the other way down to Lake New Suffolk, and then it gets pumped into the sea. These are the kind of issues we have with this proposal. I mean, granted, I will be as an engineer admit, these bulkheads need to be maintained and repaired, I won't argue with that. It's just a damn poor job of describing what they're going to do and don't provide the tools to follow up to make sure you're getting the kind of job you want when you're projecting the environment. Thank you. TRUSTEE BERGEN: Thank you. MR. RAYNOR: If it helps, I'll be more than happy to talk it over for any rain runoff for any soil. TRUSTEE BERGEN: If no other comments, I'll make a motion to close the public hearing. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Second. TRUSTEE BERGEN: All in favor? ALL AYES. TRUSTEE BERGEN: I make a motion to approve the application of Patricia Moore on behalf of Love Lane Acquisition as described with the conditions that a dry well is installed as we showed on the plans and you'll submit new plans, obviously, showing these, but the dry well, the new walkway is shown in the area that we specified, and that the spoil is going to be moved and stored outside of our jurisdiction no more than 100 feet away from any waterway or wetland area, and contaminated material moved offsite and also would you consider using a silt screen at the entrance of the harbor area to help prevent any debris going out into Peconic Bay in the bulkheading part of this. All subject to new plans. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Second. TRUSTEE BERGEN: All in favor? ALL AYES. '12. Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of SHIRLEY KRAM requests a Wetland Permit to construct a fixed open walkway 4' by 50', and float 6' by 15' parallel to the fixed dock; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float, construct wood launching ramp 6' by 23' with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' by 12' gazebo or storage shed; 77 Board of Trustees 78 March 22, 2006 clear upland vegetation as necessary for access to structures for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Drive, Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 TRUSTEE DOHERTY: The description I read is a little different than on the agenda, it's been updated. We all were at the site. The CAC did not inspect, so therefore, no comments. And LWRP found it inconsistent, which we talked about in the field and made some changes. The setbacks were one of the things. MR. FITZGERALD: The gazebo or shed 25 feet back from the end of the dock and the parking area, 20' by 20', is shown. The 25 feet is the figure you gave me. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And there's one comment here from LWRP that I don't understand, it says swimming pool and related structures. Because he has that highlighted, but -- MS. CUSACK: He took it out of the code, it says swimming pool and related structures have to be 50 feet-- TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Right, it's in bold, so I didn't know, right. We talked about the ramp next to it and how we felt we didn't need to have that size ramp there. I see that's still -- MR. FITZGERALD: The discussion was about the width as I recall, and I asked the applicant's son to measure the dolly they use for the Sunfish, and the outside dimension of the wheels is 4'4". TRUSTEE DOHERTY: So, what are you proposing that be? MR. FITZGERALD: Six feet, which seems reasonable given the width of the boat, which is somewhat more than that. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: What were you proposing material for that ramp, to build that? MR. FITZGERALD: I don't know. I would presume that marine plywood be -- TRUSTEE KING: If we allow that, it should be the new grated system, kept low and the stuff will grow up toward -- TRUSTEE BERGEN: Let me ask you this, would it work, would it suffice if instead of installing a ramp, you just clear the area like you said about 6', she said about 4'4", so next to the dock about 6' of extra clearing so they could just wheel it down there; is there any need for the ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: That would be the best way of doing it, but the bank at that point is at least 18 inches high. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Maybe we could use the new material that's out that you could put down and the growth could still grow through it. MR. FITZGERALD: That's a good idea. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: It's a hard surface, but yet you still 78 c r f Board of Trustees 79 March 22, 2006 have the growth. It's not going.to get out of control because you're going to be using it. I think we would rather see something like that. MR. FITZGERALD: I think I would too, it seems more practical. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Here are hand-drawn new plans in red. MR. FITZGERALD: I wasn't able to get the real map done by the map guy in time, so I did that and unless you have some changes, if you could act on it contingent upon the new map being that way in black instead of red? TRUSTEE DOHERTY: Sure. TRUSTEE KING: What was the proposed height of this ramp? MR. FITZGERALD: You mean height above grade? It would be at grade. The flat part up top just four feet would be at grade and it would go down, straight down from there. TRUSTEE KING: I'm just thinking DEC, I'd like to see it up off the ground a foot. MR. FITZGERALD: Okay. But there's got to be a way to get the wheels up. TRUSTEE KING: Just have a little ramp up to it out of that grated material, and that would allow some vegetation to grow under it. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: And to use that material. Are there any other comments from the Board? I make a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES TRUSTEE DOHERTY: I make a motion approve the application of Proper-T Permit Services on behalf of Shirley Kram for a fixed open walkway 4' by 30% hinged ramp 3' by 14% floating dock 6' by 20% install two piles or metal pipes to secure float; construct a launching ramp approximately one foot high made of a fiberglass or some other or aluminum grating system that the vegetation could grow through, and that would be approximately a 6' by 14' ramp with a 6' by 4' platform at landward end, and to-construct a 10' by 12' gazebo 25 feet back from the landward edge of the dock, and a 20' by 20' area for off-street parking all subject to revised plans showing all that. TRUSTEE HOLZAPFEL: Second. TRUSTEE DOHERTY: All in favor? ALL AYES. 15. En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of SUSAN & LOUIS VALENTE requests a Wetland Permit to remove and replace in-place approximately 114 linear feet of existing timber bulkhead with vinyl bulkhead; backfill with approximately 50 cubic yards of clean sand to be trucked in from an upland 79 3 � �;��Z��. :���< :�i � \ �., �, .gyp+ - '�-.��• ?�� r ,F � y _ ��! _ _ - --- r - .- _�_ _ -•�. � s - Q � � .. �� 'w r.. '4._ ,. '� � i` tt �� �y 1,� Il 1' � ii/i i �♦ f�I� �.. i _ � �_ � �� % /� 1 y�f • �J�`.r� �•��r }:ter r .. ��� ���.�f"— Niel I The Department n` - a• ; • ation (DEG) has issued permit(s) pursuant to the F,,-,. • ;,41 .1)1 Gottservation Law for work being conodtictecj at site. For further information regarding the nature and ?'. . approved work and any Depart::c-;* conditir^!� anplied to the approval, contact the Regional Permit �4 ;a,e refer to the permit number shown ontarting the DEC. drninisArator • Permit Number 1—�73g��o280000 a Expiration Date NOTE This nouns,s NOT a permit Y 1{ R ?NOW APPEAP4 TO 1EXIS3'A, UMLMXW CF '. r•; �;. � ROZ • G DLPT. r CTION k. ^ FOUNDATION 75T ROUGH Pl OG. FOUNDATION 2NO INSULATION J -^ FRAMING FINAL K e •� Y FIRi FIACi A CNIMNiY I-��r ' � 1 ' VAS �M���C♦ , 1 F, '- p E �r soil7'Hp + 3' } TR Z/STEE r i • .y r.� „l t l�7 J � M ,ice ..�'��>r. - Z-t ' ' — _ {'�•-p I � r(AM James F.King,President ��OF SoUryO Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`O l0 53095 Route 25 Peggy A. Dickerson P.O. Box Southold,New Yorkk 11 11971-0959 Dave Bergen �e John Holzapfel �� Telephone(631) 765-1892 y��UNTY,� Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD r a TO: I rr,vv►► ,^.v � . �, "Fa f ems, Please be advised that your application dated /y 6 has been reviewed by this Board at the regular meeting of 3 I a 2/ 06 and the following action was taken: l Ie"S5 ) Application Approved (see below) �) Application Denied (see below) �) Application Tabled (see below) If your application is approved as noted above, a permit fee is now due. Make check or money order payable to the Southold Town Trustees. The fee is computed below according to the schedule of rates as set forth in Chapter 97 of the Southold Town Code. The following fee must be paid within 90 days or re-application fees will be necessary. COMPUTATION OF PERMIT FEES: TOTAL FEES DUE: $ �� FIus pock 4�ee_S , 1%ese w ,( ( Le. BY: James F. King, President Board of Trustees James F.King,President ��OF SOO& Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`O l0 53095 Route 25 Peggy A. Dickerson P.O. Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G �� Telephone(631) 765-1892 John Holzapfel �OCou i Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Worksession Report Date/Time: 3 Name of Applicant: h i 6F Name of Agent:�� -� Property Location: SCTM# & Street �(� �2l (� Ggm �� �•� �� Brief Description of proposed action: C al Ve,.cf area to be impacted: _Sawater Wetland Freshwater Wetland _Sound Front Bay Front Distance of proposed work to edge of above: Pa of Town Code proposed work falls under: st _Chapt.97 _Chapt. 37_other Type of Application: 1/ Wetland_Coastal Erosion_Amendment_Administrative _Emergency unfo needed: Modifications: -)Z,-1� Lj s t"k- Conditions: ��� - �✓► '�.��5 Present Were: �Jng�J.Doherty—P.Dickerson_D. Bergen_J.Holzapfel Other: ��ss - o,Q ll Mailed/Faxed to: Date: CO('(ci 9l,4;yjo� mr. T�tzqq u to -qo y w � Of s 9l � • ' 1 I �s a L Airi ,;: t .a I i r l' ' T `{ 11 VS s.R^ `t :� � �. •*je{J .ems- .,+ f � ' ,Af �, o �' ;r►: a ► a ,�'` i�},�,�..+ •-' march 15, 2006 Field I---action � r 4 I. r.. .. _ 7 ,f ,r 49 Tt t ' #r ' � ,�A'' . `�"'','�:d' T__"fit:".� ,� � ``�'�'>r}*_: Yr � •'�i-��` :u" r.:- a ,iQ 1 t. i otfFtit ' Telephone Town Hall (631)765-1892 y = 53095 Route 25 P.O.Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971-0959 CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL TOWN OF SOUTHOLD At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held We'd., March 15, 2006, the following recommendation was made: SHIRLEY KRAM to construct a fixed open walkway 4'X 30', hinged ramp 3'X 14', and floating dock 6'X 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6'X 14' with 6'X 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10'X 12' gazebo. Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 The CAC did not make an inspection, therefore no recommendation was made. 0 THE SITE OF THE PROPOSED CFDAR PROJECT IS SHADED � FO/NT (T3) 5 � V Q 12 a . 3 13 O mm 8 1 ryfOgR TOWN OF SOUTHOLD � I4 7 � 8 / as 4.SA(c) ?7 ' � A� 15. O1 26 ua s 15 am WEST +a WEST o.. 9 am ' mQ LAKE � nAo s, � 24 23 0 4 4� van 5 16 am $ 4 am fumDER arER LAWN 9 • '4 am r0 ata �~ 18 L4ALe( 28 um TOWN L SOUTHOLO 17 Ap a.v m e La .1c) C Y. 4.y 4 'B 29 q r LUNDEAif'R'UR LA �u a1 Aa, K LAKE z � am I +w 26.1 - 8 b L737 9 p1,— 25 19 20 OR am a 21 ail 5 23 24 Z5 6 9.1 I a Lb aam 1 a 12 F LSA(C) x Q. aan um I s 3 am F I amI Wn ma I R nm I HOG LW ► aw ,b I sxuBepxE xwy, NECIf CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA TAX MAP I PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Application regarding the property of ramp and floating dock,and personal watercraft Shirley Kram,SCTM#1000-90-1-2 launching ramp for private recreational purposes. . Represented by DATUM:MLW PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES IN: West Lake AT: Southold P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 0 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE'•New York James E.Fitzgerald,Jr.. February y 2, ary 20,2006 a S a . _.. r.. ncOMC Oa, ft ESQ" V ,,' t9q 9C of^o o�Oa �El� iARK Bo-1 Gt C d E`', ew[i Mho av W Eudds Pd .� r°$,,n�_Ro:� ' °ond OLD MITH'S D `� 4 5:oV„ 9 v w 'RQa�` °�09 paQ��, Jennies s P1 ovE r PARK (COUNTY) •Eaar arm T ,`CEn �,aa �• m q�� \ . fF,aF AEs. >f o ` 9 `OD`''C E REDON L i /� I 25 \(je % ftP M �C A �� �1 ain C ECCR[Ex°a Founders wE� Landing R `m -S O U T H O L D °a S Iwx R'� Jockey = I_\ o 9c = RLw s°urnw `c<fggNEW �A9Yi^ LE-p,�l i R o I C P. JIILIII. Southold Q h'rsth'r�st,'t�r 1 Y.C. ,\ _ a aqw���.sR � GREAT x of r NECK F Y \// p i ~Oq n S 6 Paradise oB,}gD S ��qtY O 3- by Point Crab RCc p�.. 5 L JR FX BRfL m Pd,Q E I i� h'I��a aqa XooNeck ;"w�'S�='IE O Fw •�O�ggg EW q/ I . Creekll Bay , - ) I 3 q0 max xECa Corey DA CEDAR BEACH E�.°4 H 0 G N E C K COUNTYPARK 1 a EA1p , IV O E F,.q�hR• � 1 B A Y R. Cedar Beach Point 3 THE AREA OF THE PROPOSED SHE PROJECT IS CIRCLED �, LITTLE �' HUG a NECK a P O SO��PtI` E. /SO NASSAU t;j`4J1, POINT ,I CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA VICI1yITY MAP Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram, SCTM#1000-90-1-2 ramp and floating dock,and personal watercraft launching ramp for private recreational purposes. Represented by PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN:West Lake AT: Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York February 20,2006 �I o��oF so�ryol ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE Town Hall, 53095 Main Road TOWN CLERK P.O. Box 1179 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS Southold, New York 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER �� Fax (631) 765-6145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER l Telephone (631) 765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER COUNTY, southoldtown.northfork.net OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: Lauren Standish S4�-�S C�,U r XP FROM: Linda J. Cooper, Deputy Town Clerk rid 0 1 DATE: April 12, 2007 RE: Foil Request of Patricia Moore Transmitted herewith is a FOIL request of Patricia Moore. Please respond to this office within five (5)business days. Thank you. APR 13 2007 i r O�Og�FFO(,�co ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE Town Hall, 53095 Main Road TOWN CLERK c .�� P.O. Box 1179 co Z Southold, New York 11971 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS MARRIAGE OFFICER • FaX(516) 765-1823 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER y��! ���� Telephone (516) 765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER s OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete Section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of Information Officer) . One copy will be returned to you in response to your request, or as an interim response. SECTION I. TO: 7;2-1/S T��S (Department or Officer, if known, that has the information you are requesting.) RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title, tax map number, and any other pertinent information. ) Signature of Applicant: Printed Name: Address,: S ozo /71�`f-in/ 2© f� 5nU17-,-0c_y //97/ Mailing Address (if different from above) : Telephone Number:—,; (& - `f 3 3 o —Date: [ l APPROVED RECEIVED [ ] APPROVED WITH DELAY* [ ] DENIED* APR 1 2 2007 Eliza h A. eville $outhonate eri Freedom of Information Officer * If delayed or denied see reverse side for explanation. PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold, Neira York 11971 Tel:(631)765-4330 i Fax:: (631)765-4643 I� September 22, 2008 I Board of Trustees D)) Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179LT_ Southold, NY 119 t SEP 2 3 2008 OF Southold To�,n � RE: BENAL LLC Boa;d of Trustees PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1 �1 v Dear president King and Board Members : With reference to the above, please let this serve as a request to transfer the permit issued in the name of Shirley Kram to Benali, LLC. My check in the amount of $50 . 00 is enclosed for your transfer fee. Thank you. ri truly yours, cia PCM/bp Enclosures C. e ■ Benali LLC i I PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 O Tel:((631 7 65-46 0 Fax::(631)765-4643 September 12, 2008 Office of Town Attorney l C Town of Southold J i P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 r S E P 15 2008 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM, MEMBER, BENALI LLC Southold Town Board of Trustees PREMISES: CEDAR P I T DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOL SCTM # 1000-90-1( P Dear Kieran: . With reference to the above, please let this letter serve as our request to correct the Trustees Resolution so as to reflect the legal name of the owner, Benali, LLC. The application was filed by Shirley Kram who is a member of the LLC. Please instruct the Board of Trustees to transfer the permit to Benali LLC Thank you. Very truly yours, Cricia C. Moore PCM/bp Enclosures C: Board of Trustees Benali LLC y PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law Fp 51020 Main Roadco) Southold, New York 11971 Tel: (631)765-4330 Fax::(631)765-4643 April 15, 2008 Board of Trustees Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM, MEMBER, BENALI LLC PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1-11 Dear Board members : With reference to the above, please let this letter serve as our request to correct your records so as to reflect the legal name of the owner, Benali, LLC. The application was filed by Shirley Kram who is a member of the LLC. In the meantime, I am enclosing my clients check in the amount of $624 . 00 and ask that you issue the permit in the name Benali LLC and provide our office with same. Thank you. Very truly yours, Patricia C. Moore PCM/bp Enclosures A. PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Tel: (631)765-4330 lJ�c, I1 Fax:: (631)765-4643 �l l April 15, 2008 Board of Trustees )C Town of Southold APR 1 5 2008 P.O. Box 1179 � ' Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM, MEMBER, BENALI LLC PREMISES: CEDAR PO T DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1- 1 e Dear Board members : With reference to the above, please let this letter serve as our request to correct your records so as to reflect the legal name of the owner, Benali, LLC. The application was filed by Shirley Kram who is a member of the LLC. In the meantime, I am enclosing my clients check in the amount of $624 . 00 and ask that you issue the permit in the name Benali LLC and provide our office with same. Thank you. Very truly yours, Patricia C. Moore �. i PC / p Enc o res James F.King, President OF S0 y0 Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President 01 53095 Route 25 Peggy A.Dickerson l� P.O. Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen G Bob Ghosio,Jr. � �O Teleph(e(631)765-1892 �4UNTY, Fax 631)765-6641 � BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: —_'J'h U1( Q AV)4 M Please be advised that your application dated '7 /O') has been reviewed by this Board at the regular meeting of /4-/ /a/ O? and your application has been approved pending the completion of the following items checked off below. Revised Plans for proposed project Pre-Construction Hay Bale Line Inspection Fee ($50.00) � C 1st Day of Construction ($50.00) APR 1 ! 5 2008 .� Y2 Constructed ($50.00) Southhold Totgn Board of Trustees Final Inspection Fee ($50.00) Dock Fees ($3.00 per sq. ft.) Permit fees are now due. Please make check or money order payable to Town of Southold. The fee is computed below according to the schedule of rates as set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code. The following fee must be paid within 90 days or re-application fees will be necessary. You will receive your permit upon completion of the above. COMPUTATION OF PERMIT FEES: Yfteh,Lft SC'w m(d o4- Nwrn N7 i`fPa coo y - W i(4 =t9'x 3.05J sG,,-N, _ X4W(k9 et - Vxx = 1 old x S3MIS4ft, � 4360,60 TOTAL FEES DUE: $ BY: James F. King, President Board of Trustees PATRICIA C. MOO" Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 Tel: (631)765-4330 Fax: (631)765-4643 Q �(J Margaret Rutkowski u LI Betsey Perkins Secretaries March 11, 2008 MAR 14 2008 Southold Town Trustees P.O.Box 1179 Southhold Town Southold Town Hall board of Trustees Main Road, Southold, NY 11971 Re: BENALI, LLC (Kram) 1000-90-1-2 Dear President King and Board: Enclosed please find project plan dated March 3, 2008 and Section view dated February 29, 2008 prepared by PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES which conforms to the Trustee's - resolution. I have submitted the enclosed plan to DEC. I have asked to amend the approved DEC plan (permit number 1-4738-02841/00002) to reduce the length of the dock to 40 feet and request for a 6' x 20' float. As you know we expressed our concern that the plan the Trustees approved would not be approved by the DEC. Mr. King advised us and the Board that he discussed the reduction of the length of the dock from 50 feet to 40 feet and 6' x 20' float with Mr. Hamilton. According to Mr. King, Mr. Hamilton advised Mr. King that the changes would be approved by the DEC because according to Mr. Hamilton's water depth measurements "there is plenty of water" at the end of the dock. The plan was approved by the Trustees in good faith relying on the representations that Mr. Hamilton reviewed and approved the reduced length of the dock. It was no one's intent to knowingly approve a plan which the DEC would reject. We will keep the Board informed of our progress with the DEC. We would ask that the Trustees support us with the amendment to the DEC. V`ry...truly�yours, 1�v Patricia C. Moore cc: Benali, LLC Proper-T permit Services - - MAILING ADDRESS: PLANNING BOARD MEMBERS OF S�Vr P.O.Box 1179 JERILYN B.WOODHOUSE O�`v '1�l Southold,NY 11971 Chair h OFFICE LOCATION: KENNETH L.EDWARDS Town Hall Annex MARTIN H.SIDOR G 54375 State Route 25 GEORGE D.SOLOMON a0 (cor.Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.) JOSEPH L.TOWNSEND �Ii�COU '� Southold,NY Telephone: 631 765-1938 Fax: 631 765-3136 PLANNING BOARD OFFICE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD To: Town of Southold Board of Trustees E C L W E ``c From: Mark Terry, Principal Planner LWRP Coordinator ; �_,; DEC 1 2 2007 _ t Date: December 12, 2007 Svthol Tcivq board of Trustees Re: Proposed Permit to Wetland Permit for Shirley Kram SCTM#1000-90-1-2 SHIRLEY KRAM requests an Amendment to Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to reconfigure the proposed docking facility. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2 The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and.the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP)Policy Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my recommendation that the proposed action is INCONSISTENT with the denoted following Policy Standards and therefore is INCONSISTENT with the LWRP. 6.3 Protect and restore tidal and freshwater wetlands. A. Comply with statutory and regulatory requirements of the Southold Town Board of Trustees laws and regulations for all Andros Patent and other lands under their jurisdiction 1. Comply with Trustee regulations and recommendations as set forth in Trustee permit conditions. The proposed dock was built without a Trustee permit and is in violation of§275-16. Compliance requirements; penalties for offenses, item C. which states: "C. No new permits will be issued to any carter, owner, occupant, builder, architect, contractor or their agents if they are named as defendants in an outstanding or unresolved wetland violation." Pursuant to Chapter 275, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action. Cc. Lori Hulse, Assistant Town Attorney r BENALI, LLC Southold Town Trustees Main Road, Southold s ..._�I I`. . Public Hearing: December 12, 2007 Dear Mr. King and Southold Town Board of Trustees We appreciate the efforts on the part of everyone to try to settle the situation with this dock. I have the DEC approved plan dated November 3, 2006 before the Board and I would respectfully request that you consider the following as you make your decision: 1. We would never have applied for, or built, a dock with a ramp and a float. Because I live so far away it is much too difficult and costly to move the ramp and float seasonally out of the water. We purposely designed a straight dock without a ramp (only 32.5 feet is actually beyond the high water mark) so that there would be NO annual maintenance charges, and no labor charges, to put the ramp and float in and out each season. I have not installed a float and will use the dock for a season before I make a final decision whether I will ever install a float. I have offered, through my attorney, to give up the float if that will resolve this situation. 2. We built the dock to be minimally invasive ecologically. We have light filtering decking (at least 60% of the light is transmitted through the decking) and it is built three (3') feet off the water so that more light will be transmitted to the wetlands below. 3. A great deal of time and money has been spent already. There will be more DEC costs (and who really knows what the DEC will do when they get a permit change application on this -they have turned us down twice when we asked if it was possible to shorten the dock. -Most recently to me and my attorney, in person) as well as more survey costs and more construction costs with no environmental benefit. 4. Some of the trustees have indicated that they thought that the dock was over the "stringline" between the two adjoining properties and their docks. Bob Fox's survey,photos, and the approved DEC permit ALL show that the dock as it exists is NOT over the string line, in fact it is several feet short of the string line (photos and survey attached). 5. Please note that some of the Trustee's have proposed an alternative that would reduce the length of the dock to 40' and allow a 6' x 20' float. If the dock were shortened we would then need a larger float. This alternative would create an additional environmental burden on the wetlands. This would necessitate significant disturbance in the wetlands and increase the surface coverage and shading of the wetlands . Currently the 10' ft of dock that is contemplated for removal has a surface area of 40 square ft. The decking is more than 60% light transmitting and is 3 feet off the water, which means that the effective surface area is less than 16 square feet. The proposal suggested by the Trustees is for the removal of 10 feet of dock and the addition of a 6 x 20 float(120sq feet of float). The float would be impervious to light and represent a SIX TIMES GREATER amount of surface area in the wetlands. This proposal is not the plan we ever wanted, covers much more surface area, and places a GREATER ecological burden on the wetlands. 6. The proposal to reduce the.length of the dock to 40' and add a 6' x 20' float would only decrease the overall length by 4'. This proposal is not only disruptive to the wetlands, but punitive on the applicant. For the above reasons we respectfully request that the Trustees carefully consider this matter and recognize that the issues involving the permit were an innocent mistake. A reduction in the length of this dock would only be a punitive measure, costing us more time and money to have the plan reviewed and approved by DEC. Please realize that the situation as it exists today is the least harmful environmentally and meets all of the DEC requirements. Please approve the pending application without modification. Thank you, Steven Kram for Benali, LLC, rmuruocu rt-%nmiiiv AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL o 20'X 20' 1 20.- M LIMIT OF CLEARING i - HON.SHIRLEY KRAM - . ro � PROPOSED GAZEBO - '. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CS) OR STORAGE SHED 6Q0 PEARL STREET m 7"X IN OR OTHER SIZE I NEW YORK, NY 10007 w LESS THAN 100 sq.ft. U SIX STAKES PLACED, w w NUMBEREDMAS SHOWN w �' o rn ti l _ LU 0 I'� co o 2 Q O ,-o PROPOSED-LAUNCHING •a RAILS p W \ ! L_ SPACED 3.5'±X 27'•OVERALL; O -� O �• 1 . . - CROSS-MEMBER LOCATIONS m TYPICAL c _ i 1 �� �� H ` ° _ SHW ` Q m co cm 01! 1 %-*_---.Ar&7LAND BOUNDARY BY R. FOX, 1119/06 �`, • �'i'•� f O.i'� ��• ^r^^� -O W c1 -O�w 1 • � m PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED 1'11 Ramp 4 w DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE I Qt DECKING AND 6°d.PILESLie G 1 - QO(�''(-p tk ,,4� l ,r; kPPROVED AS PER TERMS -11.2 �I AND _CONDITIONS`Q F ,o PERMIT /-V'7 T t� 'y/�aooa ` FLOAT 5'X 10'SECURED �,p 2.4 r 1 OATS rJS OF DOCK AND d. PILES -3 O _ PIPES.ACCESS TO 1 w l_OAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- a_ ' ED TO DOCK 25• __ SCALE 1 -20 _^- 1 CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA • �A 1 PROJECT PLAN PURPOSE:Construct fixed open wakway,hinged Application regarding the property of ShirleyKratn,SCTM#1000-90-I 2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE; ramp and boating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by ;o 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE launching ramp,for private recreationalpurposes. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES ro MLW • SOUTHOLD,NY 11971 � DATUM: P.O.Box 617,Cutchogue,NY 11935 IN: West Lake AT:Southold_ James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 COUNTY:Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 R4R UM i14�.Pr �tC g }sties. Cs .r �a^-s2.y . MRS t t� cam- - t •,.'"�1... � s..s ?,- Win E. —s-�- MW r scanuuuz[ijjpg(irtu image,/_.i_iz5xj/uu pixels) ti le:///U:/I)ocumentsu/o2Uandu/o2USettiiigs/Bob.U PSI'At RS-FRONT... lie 41 4� J,. f w A- j�j PE, ........ .... !'7 Dlf_Z�� .; W�!- Z; Z_ At, 1 of 12/10/2007 2:28 PM James F. King,President *OF SOUTo Town Hall Jill M. Doherty,Vice-President ,`O yl0 53095 Route 25 P.O.Box 1179 Peggy A. Dickerson Southold,New York 11971-0959 Dave Bergen v' Telephone(631)765-1892 John Holzapfel O1�C00 Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD A Office Use Only P�n� _Coastal Erosion Perinit Application T S Wetland Penn it Application Administrative Permit _✓mendment/Transfer/Extension Received Application: ,r nn _a,/Received Fee:$ R[NOV U_Completed Application u_Incomplete_SEQRA Classification: — 7 2007 Type I Type II Unlisted Coordination:(date sent) ✓I;WRP Consistency Assessment Form / a Southhold Town _CAC Referral Sent: Board of Trustees _Date of Inspection: _Receipt of CAC Report: _Lead Agency Determination: Technical Review: Y61ic Hearing Held: Resolution: Name of Applicant �� �'1 i r ��,, -<rGrY1 •ac in+-uf �JQVI i„ L1�, pl�ne,� Address D 1.:�XSt I S�-epv TN.Y.M.Y. (C)02� Phone Number:( �3 r S- Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - JO - /- Property Location: /2-75 Pc>1rnj 1 ►,kre , SOG(77✓l0Id (provide LILCO Pole#, distance to cross streets, and location) AGENT: _Ta�' {ram R C ° Moore L-5 . (If applicable) Address: J 020 J7'l ct in 2czecl, cSD"7%V Id Phone: 16 S - ���0 `� p7 lard of Trustees Applicat' GENERAL DATA Land Area(in square feet): O 3 0 Area Zoning: 2 _ Previous use of Ll `X o property: Cp • �Sx !O Lcc u mac. n� �s Intended use of property: �Samtie_) Covenants and Restrictions: Yes X No If"Yes",please provide copy. Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date to �o 22 d 6 No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a govenunental agency? No X Yes If yes, provide explanation: -ro he ct� m: nPa4 Project Description (use attachments if necessary): CJqQt e W X ?f-�-o y ' x cGe s! c)c1 ra•P=r' atPLOA eA +0 CA 0 C V— �as .010 91,E Cl�, yJiRn lac $ - 'lard of Trustees Applicat: WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA. Purpose of the proposed operations: Area of wetlands on lot: -1, -7 lob square feet Percent coverage of lot: &-d % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: M/A feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: o feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? X No Yes If yes,how much material will be excavated? cubic yards How much material will be filled? cubic yards Depth:of which material will be removed or deposited: feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): t� 1) r ea u o rP lrA , a�avfi D E C- f/ r,eQ k R si-eA 7 L I Cs 6. i'-cl cQ,e e- nl [•2S i mqL& S l zc�4 5��Ip1�er c\���vere� iw`fe��Qgr s od �i�s� BOARD OF TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD: NEW YORK ---------------------------------------------------------------x In the Matter of the Application of AFFIDAVIT OF SIGN SHIRLEY KRAM POSTING Regarding Posting of Sign Upon Applicant's Land Identified as 1000-90-1-2 ---------------------------------------------------------------x COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) I, PATRICIA C. MOORE, residing a 370 Terry Lane, Southold, New York 11971 being duly sworn, depose and say that: lu 14 On the (3 day of December 2007, 1 personally posted the property known as Cedar Point Drive West, Southold, New York by placing the board of Trustees official Poster where it can easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the post has remained in place for eight (8) days prior to the date of the public hearing. Date of Hearing to be held on Wednesday, December 12, 2007 on or about 6:00 p.m. TMCIA C. MOORE Sworn to before me this 1 day of December, 2007 n�—Duth'o'ld )04 12 2007NotaryP Town BETSYA.PERKINS of Trustees (iofllty Public,State o1 NowYOtk No.01 PE 6130636 Qualified in Suffolk County Commission Expires July 1 PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Tel:(631)765-4330 Fax::(631)765-4643 �Decemb-er' 4 ,� 2007 D EC - 7 2007 Board of Trustees j Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 - - Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1-11 Dear Board members : With reference to the above, enclosed please find green certified mail receipt cards received as of date. Thank you. Very my yours iPatricia C. oore By: Betsy rkins, LA t by *Enclosures PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Tel: (631)765-4330 Fax:: (631)765-4643 November 30, 2007 Board of Trustees Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1-11 Dear Board members : With reference to the above, enclosed please find green certified mail receipt cards received as of date . Thank you. Very truly yours, Patricia C. Moore By: Betsy Perkins, LA by Enclosures - -- f J f DEC — 3 2007 e f h , 11/06/2007 09:30 FAX 310 208 17k426 CONTENT PARTNERS LLC,-_--- 0 001 1 BENA,:LI, LLC c/o Shirley Kram 140 East 81"' Street New York, NY 10028 1310-476-1112 Benali, LLC, as owner, and Shixley Kram, as agent, hereby authorize Patricia C. Moore, Esq. to submit an application to the Southold Town 'trustees. Benali, LLC B ' Y= StevA Kram, member PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Tel:(631)765-4330 Fax::(631)765-4643 November 28, 2007 Board of Trustees Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: SHIRLEY KRAM PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE, WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1-11 Dear Board members : With reference to the above, enclosed please find certified Mail receipts, Affidavit of mailing and copy of letter sent to neighbors . Thank you. Very truly yours, E ' NOV 2 s 2007 Southold TowmW_' -� �atri C. core - Board of Trustees y• Bets Perkins, LA by Enclosures BOARD OF TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD: NEW YORK ---------------------------------------------------------------x In the Matter of the Application of AFFIDAVIT OF SHIRLEY KRAM MAILING Applicant's Land Identified as 1000-14-2-23 ---------------------------------------------------------------x COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) I, Betsy Perkins, residing at Mattituck, New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that: // ,,,, On the ay of November, 2007, 1 personally mailed at the United States Post Office in Southold, New York, by CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED, a true copy of the attached Legal Notice in prepaid envelopes addressed to the neighbors on the attached list. Attached hereto is the white receipt post-marked by the Southold Post Office on said date. ?c etsy Pe in Signature) r�Sworn to before me this TN day of November, 2007. �_ (Notary PIWA&RET C. RUTKOWSla Notary PuNloc,S�taat25off New York 28 Qualified in Suffolk Count�LOrr Commission Expires June 3, PLEASE list, on the back of this Affidavit or on a sheet of paper, the lot numbers next to the owner names and addresses for which notices were mailed. Thank you. KRAM NEIGHBOR LIST SCTM: 1000-95-1-2 TOWN OF SOUTHLD PO BOX 1179 SOUTHOLD NY 11971 SCTM: 1000-90-1-11 DOUGLAS DESEIS 2228 NE 26TH LIGHTHOUSE PT, FL 33064 SCTM: 1000-90-1-3 MARK SAPARITO 1405 WATER TERRACE SOUTHOLD NY 11971 SCTM: 1000-90-1-1 f RECEIPT I RECEIPT RECEIPT I I 7192 6463 3110 0000 5183 I 7192 6463 3110 0000 5176 7192 6463 3110 0000 5190 � I FROM: � ' FROM: FROM: Patricia C.Moore Esq. I Patricia C.Moore Esq. Patricia C.Moore Esq. I RE:KRAM TRUSTEES HEARIN i RE:KRAM TRUSTEES HEARIN RE:KRAM TRUSTEES HEARIN SEND TO: SEND TO: SEND TO: i DOUGLAS DESEIS MARK SAPARITO TOWN OF SOUTHLD 2228 NE 26TH 1 1405 WATER TERRACE PO BOX 1179 I, I LIGHTHOUSE PT FL 33064 SOUTHOLD NY 11971 SOUTHOLD NY 11971 _ I I FEES FEES. J FEES: \)� ♦, .41 I Postag ©�0.41 P s a9�j 0.41 I Pp t@ `�/ 0 6 ie e'e�J 2.65 .".Ce'rSif d fee Cehlfied-Fee y� 5 Return Rem p /gam 2.15 I 'Ret m Receipt 5 I Ret Receipt fT.1 I `�Restrided ,� I Re trilled! Res idt, [ram 5.21 6 ,$ c2a TOTAL $ I T T� I TOTA� �� I ��'., I I POSTMARK OR D POSTMRK R ATE I pZ MARK OR�� TE r _ PATRICIA C. MOORE Attorney at Law 51020 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 �/7 Tel: (631)765-4330 ( / Fax: (631)765-4643 November 27, 2007 CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED RE: SHIRLEY KRAM, BENALI LLC PREMISES: CEDAR POINT DRIVE WEST, SOUTHOLD SCTM # 1000-90-1-2 Dear Neighbor: I represent the above with regard to property located on Cedar Point Drive West, Southold, New York. They have submitted an application to the Southold Town Board of Trustees to amend Resolution dated March 22, 2006 to reconfigure the proposed docking facility. A copy of the Hearing Notice is enclosed together with a copy of a survey. The hearing on this matter has been scheduled for WEDNESDAY, December 12, 2007 on or about 6 : 00 p.m. at Southold Town Hall . If you have any questions, or you wish to support this application, please do not hesitate to contact me . Thank you. r} Veryitruly yours, Patricia C. Moore PCM�1.p enc1S . C: Mrs . Shirley Kram NOTICE OF --- HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York, concerning this property. OWNER(S) OF RECORD: 6h1(11AA Y►CaM SUBJECT OF PUBLIC HEARING: a Mr�d he6&L+tn aloes ►march 21, �.00� -to rtcc�,C%�er� -� pQ)OMe6 dClWa� 4hC1t(+48 TIME & DATE OF PUBLIC HEARING: VJW,, oeee'wwr 110 A000) - On Cr dbtLL4 6'CO PM, If you have an interest in this project, you are invited to view the Town Files) which are available for inspection prior to the day of the hearing during normal business days between the hours of 8 a.m and 4 a M. BOARD OF TRUSTEES * TOWN OF SOUTHOLD * (631 ) 765- 1892 rmuruor_u t-tAmivivu AREA, PERVIOUS GRAVEL - -20'X 20'. 120. r _ LIMIT OF CLEARING - • � HON. SHIRLEY KRAM ' PROPOSED GAZEBO UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT OR STORAGE SHED 5Q0 PEARL STREET TX 14' OR OTHER SEZE I NEW YORK, NY 10007 W LESS THAN 100 sq. ft. } I SIX STAKES PLACED r.0 W r u ---- --1 j NUMBERED`AS SHOWN- w PROPOSED-LAUNCHING RAILS i � — 6� SPACED 3.5'±X 2T OVERALL; p � O � 9 � . CROSS-MEMBER'LOCATIONS Z TYPICAL SHW 1 WETLAND BOUNDARY BY R_ FOX, 1119106 001-1.0 -o.q _0A I mead 'PROPOSED LOW-PROFILE FIXED �'�I Romp ti ', -� ' DOCK 4'X 50'WITH OPEN GRATE I� , at ,p DECKING AND 6"d. PILES I - L'L. �fr ( 0p�19 ,` 4:F, t -�F.2 -3.5 2.h } +;�vtD AS PER TERMS 00 = 1.. —4:1 .• 2.�EI dD CON DITIONS OF . ' - I ERMIT N --Y73.?"D ZPw//6q4!2_ FLOAT 5 X 10 SECURED TO END '' ....__ _,..% �,p. 2.4 r OF DOCK AND BY TWO 6"- d. PILES 3,•Fj i )ATE �-oa S OR 2 METAL PIPES.ACCESS TO } FLOAT BY 2'WIDE LADDER ATTACH- ED TO DOCK ___ 2.5• 2•g _ SCALE: 1" =20' CORPS OF ENGINEERS DATA PROJECT PLAN Application regarding the property of PURPOSE: Construct fixed open walkway,hinged Shirley Kram,' SCTM#1000-90-1-2 STREET ADDRESS OF PROJECT SITE;. ramp and floating dock,and two-rail small craft Represented by 1275 WEST CEDAR POINT DRIVE launching ramp,for private recreational purposes_. PROPER-T PERMIT SERVICES DATUM:MLW gue,NY 11935 SCUTHOLD, NY 1197'� P.O.Box 617 Cutcho -----— ---•• -•- • IN:West Lake AT:Southold James E.Fitzgerald,Jr. 516-734-5800 ` COUNTY: Suffolk STATE:New York Revised November 3,2006 r _ r LWRP CONSISTENCY ASSESSMENT FORM A. INSTRUCTIONS 1. All applicants for permits* including Town of Southold agencies, s11 E- NOV 1 6 2007 Pp P g complete this CCAF for proposed actions that are subject to the Town Southold Waterfront Consistency Review Law. This assessment is inte ded to seuthofld °stew Bow supplement other information used by a Town of Southold agency in determination of consistency. *Except minor exempt actions including Building Permits and other ministerial permits not located within the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area. 2. Before answering the questions in Section C, the preparer of this form should review the exempt minor action list,policies and explanations of each policy contained in the Town of Southold Local Waterfront Revitalization Program. A proposed action will be evaluated as to its significant beneficial and adverse effects upon the coastal area(which includes all of Southold Town). 3. If any question in Section C on this form is answered "yes", then the proposed action may affect the achievement of the LWRP policy standards and conditions contained in the consistency review law. Thus,the action should be analyzed in more detail and, if necessary, modified prior to making a determination that it is consistent to the maximum extent practicable with the LWRP policy standards and conditions. If an action cannot be certified as consistent with the LWRP policy standards and conditions, it shall not be undertaken. A copy of the LWRP is available in the following places: online at the Town of Southold's website (southoldtown.northfork.net),the Board of Trustees Office, the Planning Department, all local libraries and the Town Clerk's office. B. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSED ACTION BENALI, LLC amendment to existing dock SCTM#1000- 90-1-2 Cedar Point Drive West, Southold The Application has been submitted to (check appropriate response): Town Board_Planning Dept._Building Dept. Board of Trustees_X 1. Category of Town of Southold agency action (check appropriate response): (a) Action undertaken directly by Town agency (e.g. capital construction, planning activity, agency regulation, land transaction) (b) Financial assistance (e.g. grant, loan, subsidy) (c) Permit, approval, license, certification: Nature and extent of action: extend approved 4' x 30' fixed dock and 3' x 14' hinge ramp, 6'x 20' floating dock with low profile 4' x 50' fixed dock with open grate decking, ladder(no ramp) and 6' x 15 float Location of action: Cedar Point Drive West, Southold Site acreage: .25 acre Present land use: dock, sun fish launch, gazebo and parking area Present zoning classification: r-40 2. If an application for the proposed action has been filed with the Town of Southold agency, the following information shall be provided: (a)Name of applicant: Benali, LLC (b) Mailing address: 11499 Bellagio Road, Los Angeles CA (c) Telephone number: Area Code ( ) c/o 765-4330 (d) Application number, if any: Will the action be directly undertaken, require funding, or approval by a state or federal agency? Yes No X If yes, which state or federal agency: DEVELOPED COAST POLICY Policy 1. Foster a pattern of development in the Town of Southold that enhances community character, preserves open space, makes efficient use of infrastructure, makes beneficial use of a coastal location, and minimizes adverse effects of development. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Page 2 for evaluation criteria. XYes No Not Applicable Waterfront property wishes to maintain private dock which enhances waterfront property and provides recreational use of owners property. Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 2. Protect and preserve historic and archaeological resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 3 through 6 for evaluation criteria Yes No X Not Applicable- no archeological remains residential property Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 3. Enhance visual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 6 through 7 for evaluation criteria X Yes No Not Applicable Property located on West Lake which maintains several docks. Plan is compatible with waterfront development on West Lake Attach additional sheets if necessary NATURAL COAST POLICIES Policy 4. Minimize loss of life, structures, and natural resources from flooding and erosion. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 8 through 16 for evaluation criteria X Yes No Not Applicable Minimum disturbance with waterfront. Access controlled by dock Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 5. Protect and improve water quality and supply in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 16 through 21 for evaluation criteria X No Not Applicable X No sanitary Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 6. Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystems including Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitats and wetlands. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 22 through 32 for evaluation criteria. X Yes No Not Applicable minimum loss or impact to coastal habitats Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 7. Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 32 through 34 for evaluation criteria. See Section III- Policies Pages; 34 through 38 for evaluation criteria. Yes No X Not Applicable-no air quality issues Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 8. Minimize environmental degradation in Town of Southold from solid waste and hazardous substances and wastes. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 34 through 38 for evaluation criteria. Yes No X Not Applicable-proposed dock no impact on solid waste PUBLIC COAST POLICIES Policy 9. Provide for public access to, and recreational use of, coastal waters, public lands, and public resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III- Policies; Pages 38 through 46 for evaluation criteria. XYes No Not Applicable Proposed dock will promote use of waterfront Attach additional sheets if necessary WORKING COAST POLICIES Policy 10. Protect Southold's water-dependent uses and promote siting of new water-dependent uses in suitable locations. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 47 through 56 for evaluation criteria. X Yes No Not Applicable proposed dock will promote use of private waterfront and open space Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 11. Promote sustainable use of living marine resources in Long Island Sound, the Peconic Estuary and Town waters. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 57 through 62 for evaluation criteria. XYes No Not Applicable dock is designed to minimize impact on Peconic estuary Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 12. Protect agricultural lands in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 62 through 65 for evaluation criteria. Yes No X Not Applicable no agricultural land Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 13. Promote appropriate use and development of energy and mineral resources. See LWRP Section III- Policies; Pages 65 through 68 for evaluation criteria. Yes No X Not Applicable no energy consumption </div> MAILING ADDRESS: PLANNING BOARD MEMIi ERS P.O. Box 1179 • JERILYN B.WOODHOUSE o \qf So(lr�ol Southold,NY 11971 Chair O OFFICE LOCATION: KENNETH L.EDWARDS Town Hall Annex MARTIN H.SIDOR N 54375 State Route 25 GEORGE D.SOLOMON (cor.Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.) JOSEPH L.TOWNSEND lroUNTY,� Southold, NY Telephone: 631 765-1938 Fax: 631 765-3136 PLANNING BOARD OFFICE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD To: Town of Southold Board of Trustees From: Mark Terry, Senior Environmental Planner LWRP Coordinator MAR 2 1 2006 4 Date: March 17, 2006 Re: Proposed Permit to Wetland Permit for Shirley Kram SCTM#1000-90-1-2 SHIRLEY KRAM requests a Wetland Permit to construct a fixed open walkway 4'X 30', hinged ramp YX 14', and floating dock 6'X 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6'X 14' with 6'X 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10'X 12' gazebo. Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2. The property is zoned Residential 40 or R-40. The proposed structure is located in the X500 flood zone. The applicant currently enjoys access to the water. The proposed action is not located within a Significant Fish and Wildlife Habitat Area or Critical Environmental Area. The construction of the gazebo and 6x4 deck has been reviewed to Chapter 95,Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the. records available to me, it is my recommendation that the proposed gazebo and 6x4 deck is INCONSISTENT with the following LWRP Policy Standards; Policy 6 Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystem. 6.3 Protect and restore tidal and freshwater wetlands. A. Comply with statutory and regulatory requirements of the Southold Town Board of Trustees laws and regulations for all Andros Patent and other lands under their jurisdiction 1. Comply with Trustee regulations and recommendations as set forth in Trustee permit conditions. The proposed setback of the gazebo structure from the wetland delineation line is 2 feet; the 61x 4' deck is located within the wetland system as shown on the survey dated 2/27/06; a minimum separation distance of 50' is required pursuant to Chapter 97 (see below). D. Setbacks. (1) The following minimum setbacks apply to any and all operations proposed on residential property within the jurisdiction of the Board of Trustees: (a) Wetland boundary. [51 Swimming pool and related structures: 50 feet. Please require that the applicant relocate the gazebo and deck to amend the application to meet the above mandate to the greatest extent possible. The proposed 4' x30' dock,3'x14' ramp and 61x20' float is generally CONSISTENT with the Policy Standards and therefore is CONSISTENT with the LWRP provided that the applicant demonstrates that the action meets the below policies and the folowwing recommendations are applied to the action; J. Protect visual quality associated with public lands, including publict transportation routes,public parks and public trust lands and waters. 1. Limit water surface coverage or intrusion to the minimum amount necessary. 2. Limit alteration of shoreline elements which contribute to scenic quality. The structure has been designed a low profile (3.5' above grade) to mitigate visual impacts. Additionally the scale of the structure is not significantly out of context to the surrounding dock structures to the east and west of the proposed action. K. Protect visual quality associated with agricultural land, open space and natural resources. 3. Avoid structures or activities which introduce visual interruptions to natural landscapes including: a. introduction of intrusive artificial light sources b. fragmentation of and structural intrusion into open space areas C. changes to the continuity and configuration of natural shorelines and associated vegetation It is recommended to further the above policy that clearing to access the dock structure be limited to less than 15' wide footpath to retain the bio-filtering benefits of the natural vegetation. Additionally, prohibit lighting on the structure to preserve the night sky and limit artificial light sources. 6.1 Protect and restore ecological quality throughout the Town of Southold. A. Avoid adverse changes to the Long Island Sound and the Peconic Bay ecosystems that would result from impairment of ecological quality as indicated by: 1. Physical loss of ecological components Physical loss is often the most obvious natural resource impairment to identify. It usually results from discrete actions, such as filling or excavating a wetland or clearing an upland forest community prior to development. B. Protect and restore ecological quality by adhering to the following measures. 1. Maintain values associated with natural ecological communities. Each natural ecological community has associated values which contribute to the ecological quality of the Town of Southold. These values should be assessed on a case-by-case basis. 2. Retain and add indigenous plants to maintain and restore values of natural ecological communities. a. Protect existing indigenous plants from loss or disturbance to the extent practical. 3. Avoid fragmentation of ecological communities and maintain corridors to facilitate the free exchange of biological resources within and among communities. a. Each individual resource area should be maintained as a complete contiguous areas to protect the area's natural resource values. Specifically, actions that would fragment the ecological community into separate ecological islands should be avoided. b. Where fragmentation of ecological communities has already occurred, the adverse effects of fragmentation can be mitigated by maintaining or providing connecting corridors to allow exchange of biological resources. 4. Maintain ecological integrity of particular locales by maintaining structural and functional attributes, including normal variability, to provide for self-sustaining systems. 5. Avoid permanent adverse change to ecological processes. To minimize ecological impacts the following is recommended: 1. Establish limits of clearing on the parcel to that necessary to access the dock structure. 2 Prohibit the use of CCA treated wood, oil based preservatives containing creosote (CRT) or pentachlorophenol (PCP), applied to the surface of wood materials shall be permitted in the construction materials of the structure. 9.4 Assure public access to public trust lands and navigable waters. E. Provide access to, and reasonable recreational use of, navigable waters and public trust lands under water. 1. Provide for free and unobstructed public use of all navigable waters below the line of mean high water for navigation, recreation, and other public trust purposes, including the incidental rights of public anchoring. 2. Permit limited obstruction of public use, including navigation, in navigable waters: a. for water-dependent uses involving navigation and commerce which require structures or activities in water as part of the use. b. for commercial recreational boating facilities, provided that the loss of navigable waters and use of underwater lands is offset by sufficient public benefits. C. in order to gain reasonable access to navigable waters from riparian lands. 3. Obstruction of navigable waters and underwater lands is limited: b. to the minimum necessary for access to navigable waters. The minimum is determined by evaluating the following factors: (i) the extent of the use's dependence on access to navigable waters, (ii) the range of tidal water level fluctuation, (iii) the size and nature of the body of water, (iv) the nature of public use of the adjacent waters, (v) the traditional means of access used by surrounding similar uses, (vi) whether or not alternative means to gain access are available. Piers, docking facilities, and catwalks must not result in an unnecessary interference with use of public trust lands. Alternatives to long piers or docks include use of dinghies to reach moored boats and mooring in nearby marinas. Dredging solely to accommodate the draft of larger boats is not a recommended alternative. C. by extent and characteristics of the developable adjacent upland area and its ability to support in-water development for the water- dependent use. C. by potential adverse effects on natural resources and their uses, and d. by potential adverse effects on public safety. 4. Structures extending beyond the minimum necessary for access to navigable waters impair public trust interests and open space values associated with the water's surface. Allow such structures only in the following circumstances: a. when necessary for practical and convenient operation of water- dependent industry or commerce, and provided that obstruction of commercial navigation does not result. b. for commercial recreational boating facilities provided that: (i) the loss of navigable waters and use of underwater lands is offset by sufficient public benefit, and (ii) obstruction of commercial navigation does not result. C. when the principal purpose of the structure is necessary: (i) to provide public access for recreational uses (ii) for improvements for navigation (iii) for protection from coastal hazards, or (iv) for essential public transportation and transmission facilities. The proposed scale of the dock does not significantly deviate from the surrounding dock structures. No significant impediment to public trust lands or access will result as a result of the action. 10.3 Allow for continuation and development of water-dependent uses within the existing concentration of maritime activity in harbors, inlets and creeks. In addition to Mattituck Inlet and Creek and the Village of Greenport, important concentrations of water- dependent uses are located at Orient Point, Orient hamlet, Gull Pond, Mill Creek/Budds Pond, Town/Jockey Creek, New Suffolk, James Creek and West Harbor. Individual marinas and other water-dependent uses are located outside of the concentrations of maritime activity. A. Ensure that public actions enable these harbors, inlets and creeks to continue to function as concentrations of water-dependent uses. B. Protect and enhance the economic, physical, cultural, and environmental attributes which make up the character of these harbors, inlets and creeks. 10.4 Minimize adverse impacts of new and expanding water-dependent uses and provide for their safe operation. A. Limit the potential for adverse impacts associated with development of a new water-dependent use by promoting the location of new development at appropriate sites. Appropriate sites include: 1. sites which have been previously developed, 2. sites which require minimal physical alteration to accommodate development, 3. sites that already possess public infrastructure or locational characteristics that would support a water-dependent use. B. Avoid development of new water-dependent uses at sites that are located outside of the traditional concentrations of water-dependent uses or at sites that exhibit important natural resource values or where the proposed use will cause significant adverse affects on community character, surrounding land and water uses, or scenic quality. The proposed dock structure is not located in a Significant Fish and Wildlife Habitat Area or a Critical Environmental Area. The scale of the structure does not significantly deviate from surrounding dock structures. If the following above recommendations are applied, it is expected that, no significant adverse affects on the character of the community, surrounding land or water uses or scenic quality will result from the action. Pursuant to Chapter 95, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action. MAILING ADDRESS: PLANNING BOARD MEMBERS P.O. Box 1179 JERILYN B.WOODHOUSE �O_w`�0� so Southold,Southold,NY 11971 Chair V`' O OFFICE LOCATION: KENNETH L.EDWARDS Town Hall Annex MARTIN H.SIDOR 54375 State Route 25 GEORGE D.SOLOMON �p� (cor.Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.) JOSEPH L.TOWNSEND Old' Southold, NY cou � Telephone: 631 765-193 S Fax: 631 765-3136 PLANNING BOARD OFFICE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD To: Town of Southold Board of Trustees From: Mark Terry, Senior Environmental Planner LWRP Coordinator MAR 17 2006 Date: March 17, 2006 Re: Proposed Permit to Wetland Permit for Shirley Kram SCTM#1000-90-1-2 SHIRLEY KRAM requests a Wetland Permit to construct a fixed open walkway 4'X 30', hinged ramp YX 14', and floating dock 6'X 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6'X 14' with 6'X 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10'X 12' gazebo. Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. Located: 1275 West Cedar Point Dr., Southold. SCTM#90-1-2. The property is zoned Residential 40 or R-40. The proposed structure is located in the X500 flood zone. The applicant currently enjoys access to the water. The proposed action is not located within a Significant Fish and Wildlife Habitat Area or Critical Environmental Area. The construction of the gazebo and 6x4 deck has been reviewed to Chapter 95,Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my recommendation that the proposed gazebo and 6x4 deck is INCONSISTENT with the following LWRP Policy Standards; Policy 6 Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystem. 6.3 Protect and restore tidal and freshwater wetlands. A. Comply with statutory and regulatory requirements of the Southold Town Board of Trustees laws and regulations for all Andros Patent and other lands under their jurisdiction 1. Comply with Trustee regulations and recommendations as set forth in Trustee permit conditions. j•_ The proposed setback of the gazebo structure from the wetland delineation line is 2 feet; the 6'x 4' deck is located within the wetland system as shown on the survey dated 2/27/06; a minimum separation distance of 50' is required pursuant to Chapter 97 (see below). D. Setbacks. (1) The following minimum setbacks apply to any and all operations proposed on residential property within the jurisdiction of the Board of Trustees: (a) Wetland boundary. [5] Swimming pool and related structures: 50 feet. Please require that the applicant relocate the gazebo and deck to amend the application to meet the above mandate to the greatest extent possible. The proposed 4' x30' dock, 3'x14' ramp and 6'x20' float is generally CONSISTENT with the Policy Standards and therefore is CONSISTENT with the LWRP provided that the applicant demonstrates that the action meets the below policies and the folowwing recommendations are applied to the action; J. Protect visual quality associated with public lands, including publict transportation routes,public parks and public trust lands and waters. 1. Limit water surface coverage or intrusion to the minimum amount necessary. 2. Limit alteration of shoreline elements which contribute to scenic quality. The structure has been designed a low profile (3.5' above grade) to mitigate visual impacts. Additionally the scale of the structure is not significantly out of context to the surrounding dock structures to the east and west of the proposed action. K. Protect visual quality associated with agricultural land, open space and natural resources. 3. Avoid structures or activities which introduce visual interruptions to natural landscapes including: a. introduction of intrusive artificial light sources b. fragmentation of and structural intrusion into open space areas C. changes to the continuity and configuration of natural shorelines and associated vegetation It is recommended to further the above policy that clearing to access the dock structure be limited to less than 15' wide footpath to retain the bio-filtering benefits of the natural vegetation. Additionally, prohibit lighting on the structure to preserve the night sky and limit artificial light sources. 6.1 Protect and restore ecological quality throughout the Town of Southold. A. Avoid adverse changes to the Long Island Sound and the Peconic Bay ecosystems that would result from impairment of ecological quality as indicated by: 1. Physical loss of ecological components Physical loss is often the most obvious natural resource impairment to identify. It usually results from discrete actions, such as filling or excavating a wetland or clearing an upland forest community prior to development. B. Protect and restore ecological quality by adhering to the following measures. 1. Maintain values associated with natural ecological communities. Each natural ecological community has associated values which contribute to the ecological quality of the Town of Southold. These values should be assessed on a case-by-case basis. 2. Retain and add indigenous plants to maintain and restore values of natural ecological communities. a. Protect existing indigenous plants from loss or disturbance to the extent practical. 3. Avoid fragmentation of ecological communities and maintain corridors to facilitate the free exchange of biological resources within and among communities. a. Each individual resource area should be maintained as a complete contiguous areas to protect the area's natural resource values. Specifically, actions that would fragment the ecological community into separate ecological islands should be avoided. b. Where fragmentation of ecological communities has already occurred, the adverse effects of fragmentation can be mitigated by maintaining 'or providing connecting corridors to allow exchange of biological resources. 4. Maintain ecological integrity of particular locales by maintaining structural and functional attributes, including normal variability, to provide for self-sustaining systems. 5. Avoid permanent adverse change to ecological processes. To minimize ecological impacts the following is recommended: 1. Establish limits of clearing on the parcel to that necessary to access the dock structure. 2 Prohibit the use of CCA treated wood, oil based preservatives containing creosote (CRT) or pentachlorophenol (PCP), applied to the surface of wood materials shall be permitted in the construction materials of the structure. 9.4 Assure public access to public trust lands and navigable waters. E. Provide access to, and reasonable recreational use of, navigable waters and public trust lands under water. 1. Provide for free and unobstructed public use of all navigable waters below the line of mean high water for navigation, recreation, and other public trust purposes, including the incidental rights of public anchoring. 2. Permit limited obstruction of public use, including navigation, in navigable waters: a. for water-dependent uses involving navigation and commerce which require structures or activities in water as part of the use. b. for commercial recreational boating facilities, provided that the loss of navigable waters and use of underwater lands is offset by sufficient public benefits. C. in order to gain reasonable access to navigable waters from riparian lands. 3. Obstruction of navigable waters and underwater lands is limited: b. to the minimum necessary for access to navigable waters. The minimum is determined by evaluating the following factors: (i) the extent of the use's dependence on access to navigable waters, (ii) the range of tidal water level fluctuation, (iii) the size and nature of the body of water, (iv) the nature of public use of the adjacent waters, (v) the traditional means of access used by surrounding similar uses, (vi) whether or not alternative means to gain access are available. Piers, docking facilities, and catwalks must not result in an unnecessary interference with use of public trust lands. Alternatives to long piers or docks include use of dinghies to reach moored boats and mooring in nearby marinas. Dredging solely to accommodate the draft of larger boats is not a recommended alternative. C. by extent and characteristics of the developable adjacent upland area and its ability to support in-water development for the water- dependent use. C. by potential adverse effects on natural resources and their uses, and d. by potential adverse effects on public safety. 4. Structures extending beyond the minimum necessary for access to navigable waters impair public trust interests and open space values associated with the water's surface. Allow such structures only in the following circumstances: a. when necessary for practical and convenient operation of water- dependent industry or commerce, and provided that obstruction of commercial navigation does not result. b. for commercial recreational boating facilities provided that: (i) the loss of navigable waters and use of underwater lands is offset by sufficient public benefit, and (ii) obstruction of commercial navigation does not result. C. when the principal purpose of the structure is necessary: (i) to provide public access for recreational uses (ii) for improvements for navigation (iii) for protection from coastal hazards, or (iv) for essential public transportation and transmission facilities. The proposed scale of the dock does not significantly deviate from the surrounding dock structures. No significant impediment to public trust lands or access will result as a result of the action. 10.3 Allow for continuation and development of water-dependent uses within the existing concentration of maritime activity in harbors, inlets and creeks. In addition to Mattituck Inlet and Creek and the Village of Greenport, important concentrations of water- dependent uses are located at Orient Point, Orient hamlet, Gull Pond, Mill Creek/Budds Pond, Town/Jockey Creek, New Suffolk, James Creek and West Harbor. Individual marinas and other water-dependent uses are located outside of the concentrations of maritime activity. A. Ensure that public actions enable these harbors, inlets and creeks to continue to function as concentrations of water-dependent uses. B. Protect and enhance the economic, physical, cultural, and environmental attributes which make up the character of these harbors, inlets and creeks. 10.4 Minimize adverse impacts of new and expanding water-dependent uses and provide for their safe operation. A. Limit the potential for adverse impacts associated with development of a new water-dependent use by promoting the location of new development at appropriate sites. Appropriate sites include: 1. sites which have been previously developed, 2. sites which require minimal physical alteration to accommodate development, 3. sites that already possess public infrastructure or locational characteristics that would support a water-dependent use. B. Avoid development of new water-dependent uses at sites that are located outside of the traditional concentrations of water-dependent uses or at sites that exhibit important natural resource values or where the proposed use will cause significant adverse affects on community character, surrounding land and water uses, or scenic quality. The proposed dock structure is not located in a Significant Fish and Wildlife Habitat Area nor a Critical Environmental Area. The scale of the structure does not significantly deviate from surrounding dock structures. If the following above recommendations are applied, It is expected that, no significant adverse affects on the character of the community, surrounding land or water uses or scenic quality will result from the action. Pursuant to Chapter 95, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action. o�g\1FF0��►cG Albert J.Krupski, President �, 0 Town Hall James King,Vice-President �'Z` y 53095 Route 25 P.O.Box 1179 'Artie Foster y Z Southold,New York 11971-0959 Ken Poliwoda 0-1 Peggy A-Dickerson O� "Telephone(631) 765-1892 Fax(631) 765-1366 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only _Coastal Erosion Permit Application etland Permit Application Major Minor Waiver/Amendment/Changes deceived Application: O(o ✓Received Fee:$ a�7' /Completed Application AQ-12(010 _Incomplete _SEQRA Classification: Type I Type I1 Unlisted Coordination:(date sent) .,,CAC Referral Sent: alaD F E B 2 8 2006 Mate of Inspection: ,J[1K){ fie, _Receipt of CAC Report: _Lead Agency Determination: _Technical Review: _/Public Hearing Held: 3 �M 1 O10 _Resolution: �Q Name of Applicant Shirley Kram Address 140 East 81st Street, NY, NY 10028 Phone Number:( ) 212-8 05-6315 Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - 9 0-1-2 Properly Location: 1275 Vilest Cedar Point Drive, Southold (provide L1LCO Pole#, distance to cross streets, and location) AGENT: James E. Fitzgerald, Jr. /Proper-T Permit Services PO Box 617 Cutchogue,NY 11935 ' Cps 631-734-5800 Board of Trustees Application GENERAL DATA Land Area(in square feet): 13, 030 Area Zoning: R-40 Previous use of property: Undeveloped Intended use of property: Private recreation Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date XX No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? X No Yes If yes, provide explanation: PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Construct fixed open walkway 4' x 30',hinged ramp 3' x 14', and floating dock 6' x 20'; install two piles or metal pipes to secure float. Construct wood launching ramp 6' x 14' with 6' x 4' platform at landward end. Construct 10' x 12' gazebo. Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. Board of Trustees Application . WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: Access to water for private recreation. Area of wetlands on lot: 7760 square feet Percent coverage of lot: 16o % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: N/A feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: -0- feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? XX No Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? cubic yards How much material will be filled? cubic yards Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): It is expected that the project will have no significant effect on the wetlands and tidal waters of the Town. 617.20 Appendix C State Environmental Quality Review. SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART I-PROJECT INFORMATION To be completed by A licant or Project Sponsor) 1.. APPLICANT/SPONSOR 2. PROJECT NAME James E.Fitzgerald,Jr.-Proper-T Permit Services Kram dock,ramp,gazebo 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Municipality Southold County Suffolk 4. PRECISE LOCATION(Street address and road intersections,prominent landmarks,etc.,or provide map) 1275 West Cedar Point Drive See attached maps. Southold,NY 11971 5. PROPOSED ACTION IS: 0 New Expansion Modification/alteration 6. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: Construct fixed open walkway 4'x 30',hinged ramp 3'x 14',and floating dock 6'x 20';install two piles or metal pipes to secure float.Construct wood launching ramp 6'x 14'with 6'x 4'platform at landward end.Construct 10'x 12'gazebo.Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. 7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: N/A Initially acres Ultimately acres 8. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTRICTIONS? ❑✓ Yes ❑ No If No,describe briefly 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? WResidential ❑ Industrial Commercial Agriculture ❑ Park/Forest/Open Space Other Describe: Small-to medium-size private waterfront residences. 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL,OR FUNDING,NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY (FEDERAL,STATE OR LOCAL)? Yes ❑ No If Yes,list agency(s)name and permit/approvals: NYSDEC,USACoE,NYSDOS,Southold Trustees 11. DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? Yes 0 No If Yes,list agency(s)name and permit/approvals: 12. AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION? Yes No I CER THAT T F IDED M IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant/sponsor name: J es E. r Date: Feb 27,2006 Signature: < < If the stal,15-on is in the Co I Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment OVER Reset AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING TO THE SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF: Shirley Kram STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK I, James E. Fitzgerald, Jr.,residing at 385 Haywaters Drive, Cutchogue,NY 11935, being duly sworn, depose and say that on the 13t'day of March, 2006, I personally posted the property known as 1275 West Cedar Point Drive, Southold, by placing the Board of Trustees' official poster where it can easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the poster has remained in place for eight days prior to the date of the public hearing,which date is noted thereon to be Wednesday,March 22,2006 at or about 6:30 PM. i J es E. Fitzgeral r. Sworn to before me this day of 'NbM-\� , 2006. Notary Public i AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING TO THE SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF: Shirley Kram STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK James E. Fitzgerald, Jr.,residing at 385 Haywaters Drive, Cutchogue,NY 11935,being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the 13t'day of March,2006, deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth in the Board of Trustees Application, directed to each of the named persons at the addresses set opposite their respective names;that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the addresses of said persons as shown in the current assessment roll of the Town of Southold;that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at Cutchogue,NY 11935, that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by Certified Mail/Return Receipt Re- quested. P J es E. Fitzgerald i Sworn to before me this day of"eft S' �. , 200 . Notary Public muamo Date: March 13, 2006 TO: Adjacent Property Owners (Names and addresses are listed on the attached sheet.) BOARD OF TRUSTEES,TOWN OF SOUTHOLD NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER In the matter of: Shirley Kram, SCTM#1000-90-1-2 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE THAT: 1. An application is being submitted to the Board of Trustees for a permit to: Construct fixed open walkway 4'x 50',and float 6'x 15'parallel to the fixed dock;install two piles or metal pipes to secure float.Construct wood launching ramp 6'x 23'with 6'x 4' platform at landward end.Construct 10'x 12'gazebo or storage shed.Clear upland phragmites as necessary for access to structures and for off-street parking. 2. The project described above is proposed on property adjacent to yours. The street ad- dress of that property is as follows: 1275 West Cedar Point Drive 3. The project,which is subject to Environmental Review under Chapters 32, 37,or 97 of the Town Code, is open to public comment.A public hearing will be held at Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold,New York 11971 at or about 6:30 PM on Wednesday, March 22, 2006. If you wish to comment you may call the office (631-765-1892), or applications may be reviewed and comments may be submitted in writing M to 24 hours prior to the hearing. 4. The project described above will be reviewed by the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold. The project may require independent review and approval by other agencies of the Town, State, or Federal governments. PROPERTY OWNER'S NAME: Hon. Shirley Kram MAILING ADDRESS: United States District Court New York,NY 10007 PHONE NO.: 212-805-6315 A copy of a sketch or plan showing the proposed project is enclosed for your convenience. Fy' March 10,2006 KRAM: ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS NOTICE NOT SENT (PROPERTY OWNER) 1000-90-1-2 Hon. Shirley Wohl Kram United States District Court New York,NY 10007 NOTICE SENT 1000-90-1-1 Mark Saporita 1405 Water Terrace Southold,NY 11971 1000-90-1-3 Douglas Defeis 2228 NE 26 h Street Lighthouse Point, FL 33064 Christopher Broderick 880 Water Terrace Southold,NY 11971 1000-88-6-13.26 Robert Bridges 760 Water Terrace Southold,NY 11971 bqc LA e 40 Ar '� oo sS o qS' 1k set Q a ab� pro 2S� too � � �/o� �9r, � o 4701 e� p &' po 4 *g. e'O► �o/r `Ot - - - - - - -� `i Ed, e of rg re landso8�s _ e � = o� `y9e � delineated , (� \` o b iz. FoxDock, yy Ram a -oq /� L 1 Ol-1a-O6 Float o �/ ��� Cd ,3 b �0 C .a / 3 U p 6 Q .o oh \ ` �a ,/ 'CV s a � st - 71 k J ion STATEMENT TO THE SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES County of AO 0�'►1 ) State of New York ) 1,Shirley Kram,being duly sworn,depose and affirm that I am an owner of the property located at 1275 West Cedar Point Drive,Southold, New York 11971, and identified by Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-90-1-2,and that all work will be done in the manner set forth in the present application and as may be approved by the Southold Board of Town Trustees.I agree to hold the Town of Southold and the Town Trustees harmless and free from any and all damages and claims arising under or by virtue of said permit(s),if granted. I hereby authorize the Town Tnistees or their agent(s)or representative(s)to enter upon my property to inspect the premises in conjunction with the review of the present application. ley ram .... V. / Swom to before me this . .. day of... .. .................200..E. e-SMINA MIKELL Nish rrPUMC,%la of New Yort •• ,. r No.01 M14954251 ^••••••• :^'` t Qualified in New York County Notary Public Commission Empires Aug.7,!V60cl 140 East 91"Sheet New York,NY 10028 President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall,53095 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 Dear Sir: Please be advised that I hereby designate and authorize James E_Fitzgerald,Jr.of Proper-T Permit Services to act in my behalf as my agent in the submission and processing of a ptmnit application for the construction of a dock,launching ramp,and gazebo on my property lo- cated at 1275 West Cedar Point Drive,Southold,and designated by Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-90-1-2,and to furnish,upon request,supplemental information in support of the ap- plication. Since ly, Shirley Kram j APPLICANT TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE FORM The Town of Southold's Code of Ethics prohibits conflicts of interest on dhe nnrt of Town officers and emolp3Laes The putgose of th's form is to ar�vide info nation which can alert the Town of pqgsible conflicts of interest and allow it to take whatever,action is necesspa to avoid same. YOUR NAME: Shirley Kram _ (Last name,first name,middle initial,unless you are applying in the name of someone else or other entity,such as a company, If so,indicate the other person or company name.) NATURE OF APPLICATION:(Check all that apply.) Tax Grievance Variance Cbange of Zone Approval of Plat Exemption from PIat or Official Map Other XX If"Other", name the activity: Wetlands permit Do you personally, (or through your company, spouse, sibling, parent, or child) have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold? `Melationship' includes by blood, rnartiage, or business interest. "Business interest" means a business, including a partnership, in which the Town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of (or employment by) a corporation in which the Town officer or employee owns more than 5%of the shares. YES NO XX If you answered"YES",complete the balance of this form and date and sign where indicated. Namc of person employed by the Torn of Southold: Title or position of that person: Describe that relationship between yourself(the applicant) and the Town officer or employee. Either check the appropriate line A through D (below) and/or describe the relationship in the space provided. The Town officer or employee or his or her spouse, sibling, parent, or child is (check all that apply): A)the owner of greaser than 5%of the shares of the corporate stock ofthe applicant(when the applicant is a corporation); H)the legal or beneficial owner of any interest in a non-corporate entity (when the applicant is not a corporation); C)an officer,director,partner,or employee of the applicant;or D)the actual applicant. DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP Submitted this y of Signature: .•�. Print Name:1 S h i r- e Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (631) 734-5800 February 27,2006 President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 Re: Application for Permit on Behalf of Shirley Kram; SCTM#1000-90-1-2 Dear Sir: Attached are documents which have been prepared in support of the application for a permit to construct a dock, launching ramp, and gazebo on the property of Shirley Kram in the Town of Southold. Proper-T Permit Services represents Judge Kram in this matter, and a letter of authorization is part of this submission. If there are any questions, or if additional information is needed,please call me. Sincerely, ames E. Fitzger ,Jr. Enclosures: Application Fee($250) Letter of Authorization Notarized Statement of Applicant Transactional Disclosure Form =. -- Application Form(3 copies) Short EAF (3 copies) Vicinity Map (3 copies) FEB 28 2006 Tax Map(3 copies) Hydrographic Survey/Project Plan(3 copies) LWRP Consistency Assessment Form a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION i APPLICANT: SHIItLEY KRAM SCTM#: 1000-90-1-2 LWRP CONSISTENCY ASSESSMENT FORM Policy 1 Foster a pattern of development in the Town of Southold that enhances community character, preserves open space,makes efficient use of infrastructure,makes beneficial use of a coastal location,and minimizes adverse effects of development. YES ❑ NO ❑NOT APPLICABLE The construction of a small private-use dock and a small wood personal watercraft launching ramp is consistent with the character of the highly-developed"lakefront" community, and because of the relatively small area of the proposed structures it is felt that there is no adverse impact on the desired preservation of open space. Infrastructure use is not a factor since the project is accessory to and accessed from private property. The project is certainly a beneficial use of the coastal location, and the incremental increase in development in the area is insignificant. VYE 2 Preserve historic resources of the Town of Southold. S ❑ NO ❑NOT APPLICABLE There is no evidence to indicate that the immediate area of the project includes historic features, and it is to be expected that the mainly intertidal nature of the project area is unlikely to have been the site of recoverable artifacts of past civilizations. Policy 3 Enhance visual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. VYEs ❑ NO ❑ NOT APPLICABLE The marine structures proposed are low profile and will be inconspicuous in the proposed location. The proposed gazebo is minimal in size and will be of an open design,minimizing its visual impact. They are all compatible with other existing shoreline structures in the area, and will not adversely affect the dynamic landscape elements (tidal fluctuations, seasonal vegetation changes; seasonal/diurnal changes in ambient light)which might contribute to ephemeral visual qualities. Policy 4 Minimize loss of life, structures,and natural resources from flooding and erosion. YES ❑ NO ❑ NOT APPLICABLE It is intuitively obvious that the likelihood that the proposed structures would contribute to increased hazards which could result in the losses listed is minimal. Natural protective features will not be adversely affected Policy 5 Protect and improve water quality and supply in the Town of Southold. VYEs ❑ NO ❑NOT APPLICABLE The proposed project will not include a pump-out station nor will liquid or solid wastes be discharged into the water or wetlands. Disturbance of the creek bed during construction and thereafter during active use of the structure will be minimal. Policy 6 Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold's ecosystem. V/YES ❑ NO ❑ NOT APPLICABLE Although the shading resulting from the project structure may adversely affect the wetland vegetation immediately under it, efforts will be made in the construction to space the deck planking to permit some sunlight through, and the essentially north-south orientation of the structures will assist in this regard. The project site has been chosen to pass through a naturally-occurring sparsely vegetated area. During construction,the indigenous plants will be protected insofar as possible. The project is not located in a Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitat.All statutory and regulatory requirements, at all levels of government,will be strictly complied with.No dredging, excavating, or filling is proposed. Policy 7 Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. '/YES ❑ NO ❑ NOTAPPLICABLE The construction or use of the project as proposed will not result in significant amounts of new air pollution. The siting of the dock is such as to limit the usable size of the boat, and thus its engine. Policy 8 Minimize environmental degradation in the Town of Southold from solid ` waste and hazardous substances and wastes. YES ❑ NO ❑ NOT APPLICABLE The project as proposed will not result in the generation of any additional solid waste. The handling and storage of petroleum products, if any,will be accomplished through the use of approved containers and facilities, and approved methods of handling and storage will be followed. Policy 9 Provide for public access to,and recreational use of,coastal waters,public lands, and public resources of the Town of Southold. ❑YES ❑NO W/NOT APPLICABLE This policy is not applicable to the proposed project. Policy 10 Protect Southold's water-dependent uses and promote siting of new water- dependent uses in suitable locations. ❑YES ❑ NO [ NOT APPLICABLE This policy is not applicable to the proposed project. Policy 11 _ Promote sustainable use of living marine resources in Long Island Sound,the Peconic Estuary and Town waters. ❑ YES ❑ NO V<OT APPLICABLE This policy is not applicable to the proposed project. Policy 12 Protect agricultural lands in the Town of Southold. ❑ YES ❑NO NOT APPLICABLE This policy is not applicable to the proposed project.